Skip To Content

    20 Trader Joe's Items Worth Selling Your Soul For And 10 That Are, TBH, Overrated

    Hard pass on the cauliflower NO-cchi.

    We hope you love the products we recommend! All of them were independently selected by our editors. Just so you know, BuzzFeed may collect a share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page if you decide to shop from them. Oh, and FYI — prices are accurate and items in stock as of time of publication.

    Note: This post was sourced with quotes from Reddit and has been updated with YOUR answers. Thank you, dear BuzzFeed readers!

    Trader Joe's is one of the few comforts we have left in our pandemic-stricken world.

    I Love Trader Joe's from traderjoes

    But of all the many hit products they carry, there are some misses.

    Nobody's perfect! Here are a bunch of wins that you maybe haven't tried yet, and some controversial "flops" that don't quite live up to the hype. Scroll down for the hot takes!

    BuzzFeed

    1. Underrated: Umami Seasoning Blend

    amazon.com

    "That shit is fantastic!!! I’ve used it in marinara, as a rub, marinade, meatloaf...I also hate the taste of mushrooms. Hard to describe, but this is not 'mushroomy.' It’s magical, really!"

    melissar48d0f437c

    2. Underrated: Gummy Tummies (Penguin Edition)

    amazon.com

    "I'm a sucker for gummy candy, and the Gummy Tummy Penguins are the best!"

    hobbits2isengard

    3. Underrated: Queso Cheese Dip

    exploringtraderjoes.blogspot.com

    "The queso is so good! It just doesn't have that artificial taste like most other store-bought queso, which makes it far better, in my opinion."

    skylersunshineraes

    4. Underrated: Super Lemon Room Spritz

    ebay.com

    "Great alternative to chemical-smelling air fresheners. Brought it on a family vacation and covered up unpleasant bathroom ~scents~ better then Poo-Pourri or matches or anything else. Seriously, you could go in right after and detect nothing but fresh lemon and eucalyptus lol."

    kwo

    5. Underrated: Everything but the Bagel Greek Style Yogurt Dip

    traderjoes.com

    "It's Greek yogurt and it is delicious, almost like a low-calorie French onion dip!"

    charlotte25715

    6. Underrated: Aloe Vera Gel

    amazon.in

    "Trader Joe’s aloe is the best stuff. It’s not even 100% aloe, but it’s the best moisturizer ever."

    ohhowthecamera

    7. Underrated: Smashing S'mores

    ebay.com

    "Anyone else try the S’mashing S’mores? They’re basically s’mores in a little cube, and they are fucking to die for. Sometimes I just eat them right out of the container, but when you heat them up, they taste EXACTLY like regular s’mores."

    bunniesandme

    8. Underrated: The Flower Section

    9. Underrated: Chewable Melatonin

    Bottle of Trader Joe's chewable melatonin
    amazon.com

    "I've tried other brands, but I always grab a bottle from T.J.'s. They are 3 milligrams and have a pleasant minty flavor. I take two and am usually dozing off within the next 20 minutes."

    u/youinreverse

    10. Underrated: Zhoug Sauce

    11. Underrated: Strawberry Licorice Twists

    12. Underrated: Habanero Hot Sauce

    Two bottles of Trader Joe's Habanero Hot Sauce
    amazon.com

    This is one of my personal faves that I always stock up on at T.J.'s. It's a truly spicy hot sauce that will draw tears from your eyes, and I love how nonvinegary it is (despite the fact that there is, in fact, vinegar in the ingredients). It's like pure spiciness with a mild but delicious flavor, so it goes on any kind of cuisine.

    13. Underrated: Virtuoso Lip Balm

    Green and white packaging for a 3-pack of Trader Joe's Virtuoso spearmint lip balm
    amazon.com

    "The Virtuoso Lip Balm is the only lip balm in my life now. Tried it last winter when my lips were cracking apart, along with a whole pile of other balms. I was desperate! Now all the others are in the trash, and this one is the keeper."

    u/MeghanBoBeghan

    14. Underrated: The Chimichurri Rice in the Frozen Section

    Chimichurri rice by Trader Joe's cooking in a pan
    Facebook: traderjoesmealideas4busymoms

    "I put the T.J. salsa verde, cotija cheese (not T.J.'s), and fresh cilantro on top for a twist, and the whole thing takes five minutes. Also this is the busy-mom dish, when the kids have something basic and Mom craves more."

    Jacquelyn Nicoll Goldbeck

    15. Underrated: Crunchy Mochi Rice Nuggets

    amazon.com

    "These pair with wine so well. I don't allow myself to buy them anymore because I eat the entire bag at once."

    u/f4rt054uru5r3x

    16. Underrated: Soy Chorizo

    17. Underrated: Kumato Brown Tomatoes

    Does everyone know how good these are? from traderjoes

    "They’re my favorite store-bought tomato and first choice if they’re available." —Roxbury_Bat

    18. Underrated: Field Fresh Salad (with black currants, asiago cheese, chicken, and sweet basil dressing)

    Field Fresh Chopped Salad with Grilled Chicken Breast from Trader Joe’s http://t.co/RXEKt9gnCp

    Twitter: @TheSaladArtist

    "In the prepackaged salad section. This is a new find for me, but I've had it three times in the last week. So good!"

    u/youinreverse

    19. Underrated: Spicy Cashew Butter Dressing

    20. Underrated: Masala Simmer Sauce

    Jar of Trader Joe's Marsala Simmer Sauce
    amazon.com

    "The Masala Simmer Sauce is so good. ... It’s a great pizza sauce for an Indian-style pizza."

    mythrip

    BuzzFeed

    1. Overrated: Cookie Butter

    amazon.com

    "I was visiting family in America and a friend BEGGED ME to bring back three jars of Cookie Butter. I ended up opening one up just to try it (she was fine with this) and thought it was so bland. That was a few years ago, so I don’t know if they still make it, but I definitely thought it was overrated."

    kmfogleman

    2. Overrated: Dried Mandarins

    Bag of Trader Joe's Dried Mandarins
    amazon.com

    "Not bad, just really overhyped (in my opinion) compared with all the other dried fruit, which is all pretty great."

    u/enigmaticowl

    3. Overrated: Cauliflower Gnocchi

    4. Overrated: Jackfruit Fishcakes

    Trader Joe's Vegan Crabless Jackfruit Cakes, served with lemon and parsley garnish
    Trader Joe's

    "I didn't care for Jackfruit Fishcakes. I like jackfruit, I like fish, I like cakes, but somehow the combination was not a hit."

    u/fantaszja1

    5. Overrated: Danish Kringle

    6. Overrated: Organic Cold Brewed Hibiscus Tea & Lemonade Beverage

    This tea tastes EXACTLY like an eraser - who’s with me? from traderjoes

    7. Overrated: Mandarin Orange Chicken

    8. Overrated: Chili Onion Crunch

    Jar of Trader Joe's Chili Onion Crunch
    ebay.com

    "Chili onion crunch is the watered-down, overrated version of Lao Gan Ma. It’s not spicy or salty and is nowhere near as good."

    u/P0TaHoe

    9. Overrated: The Sushi Section

    10. Overrated: Everything but the Bagel Seasoning Blend

    Bottle of Everything But the Bagel Seasoning from Trader Joe's on a kitchen counter
    ebay.com

    "The only thing it tastes good on, in my opinion, is egg salad sandwiches lol."

    Holly Towner

    Note: Responses have been edited for length and/or clarity.