We hope you love the products we recommend! All of them were independently selected by our editors. Some may have been sent as samples, but all opinions and reviews are our own. Just so you know, BuzzFeed may collect a share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page if you decide to shop from them. Oh, and FYI — prices are accurate and items in stock as of time of publication.
1. A glass butt plug with a flared rose-shaped base that takes the term "rosy cheeks" to a whole new level.
2. A vibrating anal plug that'll rock your world with its graduated design and seven vibration modes.
4. A stainless-steel butt plug that warms up to body temperature or cools down with a quick ice bath. And its wide-sculpted end is perfect for teasing and pleasing.
6. A new-and-improved toy by B-Vibe that combines the best of both worlds with a weighted plug and vibrating cock ring delivering incredible sensations down below.
8. A silky silicone 3-in-1 rabbit vibrator that delivers simultaneous stimulation with a G-spot vibrator, stimulating "bunny ears" and the graduated anal beads — the question is, how long can you last?
9. A line of hand-crafted artisan dildos designed for the modern masturbator who appreciates style over girth, orgasms over options.
10. A vibrating silicone plug from Unbound that's sure to shake things up with its tapered end and ring handle for easy insertion and removal.
11. The Princette Puppypuss by Cute Little Fuckers that is designed for dabbling in butt stuff or exploring those erogenous zones with the tapered legs of this versatile toy.
12. A wavy glass dildo designed to deliver a ~full~ feeling and extra stimulation with each bead. The adorable heart-shaped end offers easy handling or simply a cute accent between the cheeks.
13. A sleek glass butt plug with a magnetic bunny tail that's perfect for role playing or adding a playful touch to your lingerie.
14. A sleek and silky prostate massager boasting six vibration modes to cycle through alone or with a partner using the app or wireless remote control to deliver dual stimulation to the prostate and perineum.
15. A set of three anal plugs with different shapes and sizes that are ideal for beginners who want to explore penetration through the backdoor.
Choose your favorite: the seductive spiral, the narrow bulbs, or the classic graduated bulbs? Convenient retrieval loops offer easy removal.
Promising reviews: "These were great for my entry into anal play, I think the material and size were great with not having much experience. The purple one felt incredible for both my partner and I when he was penetrating me vaginally at the same time. All in all led to a very fun night." —Paige
"This product is perfect for those beginning to experiment and play. Three separate sizes and shapes really helped us ease into the process. Great product for an affordable price. Can't go wrong buying this product and I highly recommend these plugs to be added to your toy box." —Scotty
Get it from Amazon for $12.94+ (available in black and pink/purple).
16. A very beginner-friendly plug made from supple silicone with a tapered tip for effortless insertion that'll hit all the right spots without being overwhelming.
17. A stainless-steel wand by Le Wand with a sleek, elegant curve that'll reach your favorite spots and satisfy them effortlessly. Tease away with the narrower end or test the limits of your pleasure with the ridges and bulb on the other — you know what they say, go big or go home.
18. A 14-inch double-ended vibrating dildo with seven vibrations, so you can get closer than ever with a partner or explore new positions for masturbating. With a length like that, you could certainly fill two holes at once...or at least try.
19. A not-so-girthy curved silicone dildo with a bold abstract pattern and convenient suction cup base, so it stays put even if you don't.
20. A limited edition butt plug that simulates the feeling of rimming with rotating anal beads in the shaft and a vibrating tip that hits your favorite spots.
21. Or a metallic remote-controlled plug is designed for beginners with a slim, tapered design and 15 vibration patterns with six intensities for you to explore.
22. A flexible vibrating butt plug that'll sync to the beat of your favorite songs, mimic your own custom patterns, or buzz along to user-created vibration modes already on the app.
Supple, body-safe silicone offers a waterproof exterior and the spiralized stem traps lube to help the plug stay put.
Promising reviews: "Exactly as described, and exceeded expectations. This is a great buy for individual’s who seek self satisfaction. This (Multi Pattern Vibrating) plug is also a fantastic idea of fun for couples who look to spice things up a bit. Personal Care Products couldn’t get any better. Extremely happy with this purchase, and look forward to purchasing more products by this brand." —William Gardener
"We have had a great time with this. I bought the largest and it took a bit to get used to it. We are a couple of states away from each other and he has had a great time setting me off while I’m at work or doing things around home. The vibration is very intense at the highest setting and at the lowest just keeps you on edge. Being made of the material that it is, you have to keep it clean and let it air out, so it doesn’t smell if you get any fecal matter on it. Definitely recommend!" —JayyDee
23. A hand-crafted confetti glass butt plug because the booty deserves some bold and bright loving too.
24. A 3.5-inch vibrating butt plug with 10 different functions to choose from and explore. A tapered design and T-shaped flared base offer satisfying stimulation and effortless removal.
Promising review: "As someone completely new to anal but eager to try, I wanted to do it right and start from the top. And from the top I did: even being a nervous novice, it wasn't painful at all, and I could use it with plenty of confidence (the gel lubricant I bought with it was a wise choice). While it went in with some pressure at its widest point, it stayed put with surprising comfort. The vibration settings were easy to navigate, and there were plenty out of the 10 patterns to choose from — and enjoy. This was an intense first use for me, and I'll be reaching for this one again and again as I train myself up to sharing this new avenue with my partner. If you're looking for a way to pass the time in quarantine and you're thinking about trying anal play, now's the best time to start, and this is the best toy to start with. (As an added point, since few are willing to discuss it: I have moderate/severe IBS, and the disruption on that side of things was actually fairly minimal. If you think IBS will hold you back here: as long as you have the cleaning apparatus (for yourself and the toy), you go slow and you check in with yourself as you go, you have nothing to fear!)" —K.A.
Get it from Lovehoney for $24.99.
25. A fantasy butt plug shaped like a stinger, but delivering a pinch of pleasure instead.
A tapered tip allows for effortless insertion before giving way to a plump, fulfilling shaft designed with three ribbed rings, so you can take things slow.
Promising review: "The only way I recommend getting stung. Fits perfectly and is well-flared. Love the coloration. My new favorite plug. Shipped sooner than expected as well." —shauntwo
Wandering Bard Toys is a California-based, queer- and family-owned sex-positive boutique creating monster, fantasy and D&D-inspired sex toys and dildos.