Gary (Ross Hall) then:
Gary (Ross Hall) now:
Kiki (Jodie Rester) then:
Kiki (Jodie Rester) now:
Frank (Jason Alisharan) then:
Frank (Jason Alisharan) now:
Betty Anne (Raine Pare-Coull) then:
Betty Anne (Raine Pare-Coull) now:
Tucker (Daniel DeSantos) then:
Tucker (Daniel DeSantos) now:
David (Nathaniel Moreau) then:
David (Nathaniel Moreau) now:
Kristen (Rachel Blanchard) then:
Kristen (Rachel Blanchard) then:
Stig (Codie Lucas Wilbee) then:
Stig (Codie Lucas Wilbee) now:
Eric (Jacob Tierny) then:
Eric (Jacob Tierny) now:
Sam (JoAnna Garcia) then:
Sam (JoAnna Garcia) now:
Note: I didn't include characters from the 1999 revival of 'Are You Afraid Of The Dark?' because I pretend like that revival never existed.