1. Guys with super flat-ironed hair and that made this face in every pic they took:

Frazer Harrison / Getty Images
2. Guys who wore suggestive graphic tees:

Mark Mainz / Getty Images
3. Guys with this "bangs for days" haircut:

Frazer Harrison / Getty Images
4. Guys who just, like, dry humped the air in a congo line:
5. Guys who enjoyed giving each other wet willies while eating pizza:
6. Guys who wore zippered skin-tight baby tees:
Jive Records
7. Guys who, just like, slapped their own asses:
8. Any guy with a bowl/mushroom cut:

L. Busacca / WireImage / Getty Images
9. Guys who were really into patriotism:

Picture Alliance / picture alliance via Getty Images
10. Guys with thermals under short-sleeve T-shirts (but especially graphic tees) and polos:

John Sciulli / WireImage
11. Guys who weren't afraid to expose a tit or two:

Chris Weeks / Getty Images
12. Also those pants, ooh lala:

Chris Weeks / Getty Images
13. Guys who wore fedoras they got as part of a mob costume they bought at Party City:

Kevin Winter / Getty Images
14. Guys who liked having hot wax poured on their chest:
15. Bucket hats you would get at a carnival or fair:

Frank Trapper / Getty Images
16. Any guy with extremely spiky gelled-up hair:

Jim Smeal / Ron Galella Collection via Getty
17. And ESPECIALLY spiky tips that were frosted:

Jim Smeal / Ron Galella Collection via Getty
18. Or if spiky gelled frosted tips wasn't quite your thing, then you always had uncooked ramen noodle hair:
Jive
19. Guys with extremely baggy cargo shorts:

John Sciulli / WireImage
20. Guys who were really into bedazzling:

George De Sota / Getty Images
21. Any guy wearing this exact "going out for the night" outfit:

Megan Gaynes / Getty Images
22. Guys in teen movies who wore corduroy newsboy caps:

Jean-paul Aussenard / WireImage / Getty Images
23. Honestly, most of Aaron Paul's mid-'00s wardrobe was "hot guy" attire:

Ron Galella, Ltd. / Ron Galella Collection via Getty Images
24. Guys who wore matching track suits without shirts:

Scott Gries / Getty Images
25. Any guy who wore beaded and shelled necklaces — preferably puka:

Kevin Winter / Getty Images
26. Guys with *the* Ryan Cabrera haircut:

Peter Kramer / Getty Images
27. Guys who could only figure out one button:
LaFace Records
28. Guys who were really good at making dramatic hand movements:

Picture Alliance / picture alliance via Getty Image
29. Guys who hung out together in piles of stuffed animals:

Ullstein Bild Dtl. / Getty Images
30. Guys with heavily manicured chin straps:

Robert Mora / Getty Images
31. Guys with itty bitty soul patches:

L. Cohen / WireImage / Getty Images
32. Guys wearing giant striped ties as necklaces:

Amy Graves / WireImage / Getty Images
33. Guys with faux hawks:

Ross Kinnaird / Getty Images
Bonus points if they were frosted.

Ross Kinnaird / Getty Images
34. Guys with shredded clothing:

Ron Davis / Getty Images
35. Guys with reflective leather clothing:

Steve Granitz / WireImage
36. Any of the guys who had to stand shirtless outside an Abercrombie in the mall in distressed bootcut jeans or baggy cargo pants:

Hannes Magerstaedt / Getty Images
37. And finally, literally any guy who worked at Hollister and rocked weirdly, almost green-tinted distressed jeans with Hollister logo tees:

Jaimie Trueblood / WireImage for Hollister Co.