back to top

A Journalist Has Been Deported From Nicaragua After Being Doxxed By An Online Mob

UK website the Canary ran an article attacking Carl David Goette-Luciak as a "novice reporter linked to the US regime-change machine" just days before he was arrested.

Originally posted on
Updated on
Frontline Freelance

The Committee to Protect Journalists says a freelance journalist writing for the Guardian and Washington Post has been arrested and deported from Nicaragua after a "targeted online harassment campaign".

Last week, Carl David Goette-Luciak's reporting on anti-government protests in Nicaragua was attacked by US journalist Max Blumenthal in an article published on an American website called Mint Press and British left-wing site the Canary.

The Mint Press article was titled "How an American Anthropologist Tied to US Regime-Change Proxies Became the MSM's Man in Nicaragua", while the Canary ran the headline, "Investigation slams Guardian cooperation with novice reporter linked to US regime-change machine."

Along with Blumenthal's attack, Goette-Luciak was doxxed and targeted by Facebook and Twitter users in mid-September, the CPJ said. An online campaign reportedly accused him of an "attempt to destabilise the country and being a Central Intelligence Agency operative".

Acabo de hablar con @CDGoetteLuciak. Los policías no lo golpearon, pero lo amenazaron con torturarlo. No lo llevaron al Chipote. Lo sacaron sin zapatos, sin camisa, solo en shorts de su casa. "Según policía, me deportaron por opinar 'cosas falsas' y andar en marchas ilegales" https://t.co/GyTl1lntBS

On Monday, local Nicaraguan journalists, including Wilfredo Miranda, reported Goette-Luciak had been detained by authorities, deported to El Salvador, and accused by police of saying "false things". CPJ Américas also tweeted about Goette-Luciak's deportation.

El periodista @CDGoetteLuciak, deportado ayer de #Nicaragua, ha llegado a El Salvador. En menos de 24 horas, las autoridades nicaragüenses lo detuvieron, lo llevaron de su casa, y lo obligaron a abandonar el país. #InformarNoEsDelito https://t.co/ePygZj4zQ5

The Guardian said Goette-Luciak had been covering Nicaragua recently for the paper. The UK-based news outlet said it was trying to confirm the reports about his deportation.

"We are obviously concerned for his safety," a Guardian spokesperson said. "We have seen reports Carl David is no longer in Nicaragua. We are making our own inquiries to confirm his whereabouts as soon as possible."

The CPJ's Central and South America coordinator Natalie Southwick called on the Nicaraguan authorities to investigate the doxxing campaign against the journalist, which began on Sept. 16.

"Doxxing and calling for violence against a journalist are unacceptable acts of intimidation, and Nicaraguan authorities must take immediate steps to find those responsible for the threats against Carl David Goette-Luciak and ensure that they face justice," she said.

Goette-Luciak told the CPJ that people online started publishing all his personal details: "They had the exact address, including the name of the owner of the house, which I didn't even know."

After reports of the arrest surfaced, Blumenthal, Mint Press, and the Canary were heavily criticised by other journalists for their role.

This is what happens when internet conspiracy theorists call reporters “CIA operatives” for political points and retweets. This is why media organizations should not give them and their conspiracy theories platforms. This is not a fucking game. https://t.co/pdGRNwfkoL

Blumenthal, defending his piece, claimed: "Nicaraguan media was buzzing about his documented role as an opposition publicist for days before I published." He has been contacted for comment.

1. I wrote, “There is no evidence [CGDL] is an asset of the CIA” 2. Nicaraguan media was buzzing about his documented role as an opposition publicist for days before I published 3. No one disputes one fact I reported 4. CGDL is on a flight home right now: https://t.co/2fBadzXRQl https://t.co/y96cQNl3GH

In his article, Blumenthal said the use of Goette-Luciak was a "deep embarrassment" for the Guardian and accused it and the other news organisations who commissioned him of "feigning objectivity".

The decision by the Canary to republish the story comes as tensions are already running high between the hyperpartisan pro-Corbyn site and Guardian staff. The Canary's editor Kerry-Anne Mendoza took part in a Twitter boycott of the Guardian last week after it emerged staff were unhappy at the decision by the National Union of Journalists to invite her to deliver a Black History Month lecture at the Guardian's London office.

Update: The Canary's editor, Kerry-Anne Mendoza, said the arrest by Nicaraguan authorities "reinforced rather than undermined" Max Blumenthal's attack on the freelance journalist.

"The Canary republished the criticism by Max Blumenthal because it was well-researched and reliable. Max is an award-winning journalist with extensive experience of reporting from areas of conflict, often at great personal danger. Blumenthal's report criticised the Guardian’s irresponsible decision to gather news from this particular source. News outlets have a duty of care to the journalists they send into dangerous situations. In allowing a clearly partisan source to work for them, the Guardian should have been aware of the risks and taken action to mitigate them. Blumenthal's criticism is reinforced rather than undermined by Goette-Luciak’s later arrest and deportation."

Update

BuzzFeed News acknowledges that Max Blumenthal neither doxxed anybody nor threatened violence and did not intend to imply beyond the reported facts that there was any indication that Carl David Goette-Luciak was deported as a result of Blumenthal's article.


Mark Di Stefano is a media and politics correspondent for BuzzFeed News and is based in London.

Contact Mark Di Stefano at mark.distefano@buzzfeed.com.

Got a confidential tip? Submit it here.