back to top
Tasty

18 Next-Level Thanksgiving Pies

It's time to get wild.

Posted on
Jenny Chang / BuzzFeed

1. Nutella Tart With Toasted Hazelnut Crust

The pie is making me feel things no pie has ever made me feel before. Recipe here.
Sally McKenny / Via sallysbakingaddiction.com

The pie is making me feel things no pie has ever made me feel before. Recipe here.

2. Cranberry-Lime Pie

A gingersnap crust with a cranberry-lime filling? What more do you need? Recipe here.
Bobbi Lin / Via bonappetit.com

A gingersnap crust with a cranberry-lime filling? What more do you need? Recipe here.

3. Salted Bourbon Pecan Pumpkin Pie

Two of the best Thanksgiving desserts, perfectly united in one. Recipe here.
Tieghan Gerard / Via halfbakedharvest.com

Two of the best Thanksgiving desserts, perfectly united in one. Recipe here.

4. Peanut Butter Pie

Peanut butter all day, every day. Recipe here.
Jamie Lothridge / Via mybakingaddiction.com

Peanut butter all day, every day. Recipe here.

5. Butterfinger Pie

I'm hyperventilating. Recipe here.
Shelly Jaronsky / Via cookiesandcups.com

I'm hyperventilating. Recipe here.

6. Pumpkin Pie With Toasted Marshmallow Topping

Marshmallow topping can do no wrong. Recipe here.
David Lebovitz / Via davidlebovitz.com

Marshmallow topping can do no wrong. Recipe here.

7. Vanilla Bean Tarte Tatin

French it up! You won't regret it. Recipe here.
Michael Graydon + Nikole Herriott / Via bonappetit.com

French it up! You won't regret it. Recipe here.

8. Avocado Key Lime Pie

Avocado makes everything better. EVERYTHING. Recipe here.
Lindsay / Via lifeloveandsugar.com

Avocado makes everything better. EVERYTHING. Recipe here.

9. Maple Sugar Pie

An unexpected and perfect addition to the Thanksgiving table. Recipe here.
Alex Lau / Via bonappetit.com

An unexpected and perfect addition to the Thanksgiving table. Recipe here.

10. Sweet Potato Pie

The perfect alternative to the traditional pumpkin pie. Recipe here.
Joy Wilson / Via joythebaker.com

The perfect alternative to the traditional pumpkin pie. Recipe here.

11. Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie

Chocolate chip cookie? Good. Pie? Good. Chocolate chip cookie pie? Very good. Recipe here.
Averie Sunshine / Via averiecooks.com

Chocolate chip cookie? Good. Pie? Good. Chocolate chip cookie pie? Very good. Recipe here.

12. Caramel Apple Crumble Pie

Why choose between a crumble and a pie when you could have both? Recipe here.
Kristin Rosenau / Via pastryaffair.com

Why choose between a crumble and a pie when you could have both? Recipe here.

13. Cookie Butter Pie

A brand new way to express your cookie butter addiction. Recipe here.
Shelly Jaronsky / Via cookiesandcups.com

A brand new way to express your cookie butter addiction. Recipe here.

14. Peanut Butter And Grape Galette

Grapes are delicious, and so are grape pies. So, why don't we make more of them? Recipe here.
Molly Yeh / Via mynameisyeh.com

Grapes are delicious, and so are grape pies. So, why don't we make more of them? Recipe here.

15. S’mores Pie

How is this not already a Thanksgiving classic? Recipe here.
Kelly Senyel / Via justataste.com

How is this not already a Thanksgiving classic? Recipe here.

16. Salted Honey Macadamia Tart

You know what's even better than salted caramel? Salted honey. Recipe here.
Loraine / Via notquitenigella.com

You know what's even better than salted caramel? Salted honey. Recipe here.

17. Pecan Pie Brownies

The best of both worlds. Recipe here.
Kelly Senyel / Via justataste.com

The best of both worlds. Recipe here.

18. Butterscotch Pie

*Heavy breathing*. Recipe here.
Hayley Parker / Via thedomesticrebel.com

*Heavy breathing*. Recipe here.