back to top

26 Beauty Products Our Readers Loved In 2015

::Prints out, uses as shopping list::

Maitland Quitmeyer for BuzzFeed Life

We asked members of the BuzzFeed Community to tell us the best makeup they bought in 2015. Here are the results:

1. Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara

"Literally life-changing, especially if you spend years trying to find a gorgeous mascara!"—Submitted by Miranda."It's not better than sex, but it's really, really close. It separates and gives volume and doesn't flake and I don't know what more you could ask for in a mascara."—Submitted by Kodier.Get it here.
toofaced.com

"Literally life-changing, especially if you spend years trying to find a gorgeous mascara!"

—Submitted by Miranda.

"It's not better than sex, but it's really, really close. It separates and gives volume and doesn't flake and I don't know what more you could ask for in a mascara."

—Submitted by Kodier.

Get it here.

2. Everything from Colour Pop, but mostly the ultra-matte lipsticks.

"Their matte lippies and ultra-matte liquid lipsticks are so amazing, last all day, don’t leave your lips dry, and feel super light on your lips. They also come in a super-wide range of more subtle to more crazy colors and everything in between."

—Submitted by Jasmine.

"Affordable, comfortable, and flattering on so many skin tones!"

—Submitted by Adele.

Get them here.

3. Becca x Jaclyn Hill Shimmering Skin Perfector in Champagne Pop

"Must-, must-, MUST-have, perfect for any skin tone!"—Submitted by K Workman.Get it here.
sephora.com

"Must-, must-, MUST-have, perfect for any skin tone!"

—Submitted by K Workman.

Get it here.

4. Anastasia Beverly Hills Dipbrow Pomade

"Gives me that perfect 'bitch, what you say?' arch that I cannot leave the house without."—Submitted by Queenbeyondthewall.Get it here.
anastasiabeverlyhills.com

"Gives me that perfect 'bitch, what you say?' arch that I cannot leave the house without."

—Submitted by Queenbeyondthewall.

Get it here.

5. The Original Beauty Blender

"I could never validate spending $26 on a makeup sponge, but am I ever glad that I did."—Submitted by Chantal Babin."I could not live without my Beauty Blender. I don't even remember how to do makeup without it." —samh402f7f040.Get it here.
beautyblender.com

"I could never validate spending $26 on a makeup sponge, but am I ever glad that I did."

—Submitted by Chantal Babin.

"I could not live without my Beauty Blender. I don't even remember how to do makeup without it." —samh402f7f040.

Get it here.

6. NYX Matte Lip Cream

"Even though they dry matte, they don’t make your lips feel dry. They come in shades that compliment every skin tone (yes, there are nudes for us darker girls)."

—Submitted by Robyn Sabarrec.

"This was the year I really got into makeup — and the first thing I bought was the NYX matte liquid lipsticks, and they were a game-changer."

—Submitted by Addison.

Get them here.

7. Kat Von D Tattoo Liner

"I have extremely oily eyelids/skin and I couldn't find an eyeliner that wouldn't transfer and last the whole day until I got this liner. It lasts me a good eight hours!"—Submitted by Amy."I've fallen asleep and woken up with my eyeliner still on point. Which says a lot because I'm Korean and eyeliner has always come off."—Submitted by Kyle.Get it here.
katvondbeauty.com

"I have extremely oily eyelids/skin and I couldn't find an eyeliner that wouldn't transfer and last the whole day until I got this liner. It lasts me a good eight hours!"

—Submitted by Amy.

"I've fallen asleep and woken up with my eyeliner still on point. Which says a lot because I'm Korean and eyeliner has always come off."

—Submitted by Kyle.

Get it here.

8. Jeffree Star Velour Lipstick

"Goes on like lip gloss, dries matte so fast, and super pigmented!"

—Submitted by Jacquie.

"These are SO amazing and hydrating; they stay on and apply like perfection."

—Submitted by Maria Diwanji, Facebook.

"They have changed the makeup game."

—Submitted by Danielle Calder, Facebook.

Get it here.

9. Too Faced Born This Way Foundation

"Literally liquid magic."—Submitted by Lindsay Rael."Holy cow, I don't usually like liquid foundations, but this stuff is AMAZING. It actually feels good on my skin. I would get occasional acne, but haven't seen any since I started using BTW. I catch my reflection in my rear view mirror and go, 'Damn, look at how glowy I look!'"—Submitted by Shannon Whatley, Facebook.Get it here.
toofaced.com

"Literally liquid magic."

—Submitted by Lindsay Rael.

"Holy cow, I don't usually like liquid foundations, but this stuff is AMAZING. It actually feels good on my skin. I would get occasional acne, but haven't seen any since I started using BTW. I catch my reflection in my rear view mirror and go, 'Damn, look at how glowy I look!'"

—Submitted by Shannon Whatley, Facebook.

Get it here.

10. Urban Decay All-Nighter Setting Spray

"I do not leave the house without this."—Submitted by Kristin Burr."Spray it and never worry about your makeup melting or transferring ever again."—Submitted by narcimetamorpho.Get it here.
urbandecay.com

"I do not leave the house without this."

—Submitted by Kristin Burr.

"Spray it and never worry about your makeup melting or transferring ever again."

—Submitted by narcimetamorpho.

Get it here.

11. Kate Moss for Rimmel Lasting Finish Lipstick

"It smells like cinnamon rolls and the color makes me feel fierce!"—Submitted by Grace.Get it here.
us.rimmellondon.com

"It smells like cinnamon rolls and the color makes me feel fierce!"

—Submitted by Grace.

Get it here.

12. Urban Decay Naked Palette in Smoky

It's AMAZING. The brush is great for the smoky-eye look. I love mixing and matching the colors!"—Submitted by Olive.Get it here.
urbandecay.com

It's AMAZING. The brush is great for the smoky-eye look. I love mixing and matching the colors!"

—Submitted by Olive.


Get it here.

13. Maybelline Matte and Poreless Foundation

"This is the ONLY foundation I have found that is the right color for my skin tone."—Submitted by Ashley.Get it here.
maybelline.com

"This is the ONLY foundation I have found that is the right color for my skin tone."

—Submitted by Ashley.

Get it here.

14. Makeup Forever HD Finishing Powder

"I live in Australia and the humid weather makes me SHINY. This is so light and so totally effective, and it smooths over my pores."—Submitted by Nicole."This stuff is the best. Makes my oily spots matte and photo-ready."—Submitted by Emily.Get it here.
makeupforever.com

"I live in Australia and the humid weather makes me SHINY. This is so light and so totally effective, and it smooths over my pores."

—Submitted by Nicole.

"This stuff is the best. Makes my oily spots matte and photo-ready."

—Submitted by Emily.

Get it here.

15. NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer

"There really is no dupe for this. Simply perfect. I finally wear concealer without fear." —Submitted by Laura.Get it here.
narscosmetics.com

"There really is no dupe for this. Simply perfect. I finally wear concealer without fear."

—Submitted by Laura.

Get it here.

16. Benefit Roller Lash Mascara

"It makes my eyelashes touch my eyebrows."—Submitted by Clare."I don't even need to use an eyelash curler and my lashes look flawless!"—Submitted by Keaton.Get it here.
benefitcosmetics.com

"It makes my eyelashes touch my eyebrows."

—Submitted by Clare.

"I don't even need to use an eyelash curler and my lashes look flawless!"

—Submitted by Keaton.

Get it here.

17. Tarte Amazonian Clay Blush

"So many amazing colors, and it lasts all day. And most importantly, Tarte doesn't test on animals and is cruelty-free."—Submitted by RawPups.Get it here.
tartecosmetics.com

"So many amazing colors, and it lasts all day. And most importantly, Tarte doesn't test on animals and is cruelty-free."

—Submitted by RawPups.

Get it here.

18. E.l.f. Eyeshadow Primer

"No kidding: My eye makeup lasted 18 hours without creasing or fading."—Submitted by Crystal.Get it here.
elfcosmetics.com

"No kidding: My eye makeup lasted 18 hours without creasing or fading."

—Submitted by Crystal.

Get it here.

19. Hourglass Mineral Veil Primer

"I was so sad the day I tried a sample and it lived up to the hype. The price tag hurts. But damn is it worth every penny."—Submitted by Narcimetamorpho."Definitely a must before applying foundation. It doesn't irritate my sensitive skin, plus I've received compliments on how smooth and clear my skin is. Absolute best!" —Submitted by Xing Yoong.Get it here.
hourglasscosmetics.com

"I was so sad the day I tried a sample and it lived up to the hype. The price tag hurts. But damn is it worth every penny."

—Submitted by Narcimetamorpho.

"Definitely a must before applying foundation. It doesn't irritate my sensitive skin, plus I've received compliments on how smooth and clear my skin is. Absolute best!"

—Submitted by Xing Yoong.

Get it here.

20. Kat Von D Shade + Light Face Contour Palette

"I wanted to try the contouring trend and was sold when I bought the Kat Von D Shade and Light palette. It looks great on my pale skin, and the colors that don't work on me for contour make great eye hadows."—Submitted by Caitlin Dwyer McDonnell, Facebook."It has truly changed me."—Submitted by Julia Magnani, Facebook.Get it here.
katvondbeauty.com

"I wanted to try the contouring trend and was sold when I bought the Kat Von D Shade and Light palette. It looks great on my pale skin, and the colors that don't work on me for contour make great eye hadows."

—Submitted by Caitlin Dwyer McDonnell, Facebook.

"It has truly changed me."

—Submitted by Julia Magnani, Facebook.


Get it here.

21. NARS Velvet Matte Lip Pencil

"This is the most beautiful lipstick I have ever seen. It literally makes me feel like I am part dragon and also part Taylor Swift."—Submitted by Emma."My go-to red lipstick; I never wore reds before and now it's my holy grail."—Submitted by lauramc2.Get it here.
narscosmetics.com

"This is the most beautiful lipstick I have ever seen. It literally makes me feel like I am part dragon and also part Taylor Swift."

—Submitted by Emma.

"My go-to red lipstick; I never wore reds before and now it's my holy grail."

—Submitted by lauramc2.


Get it here.

22. L'Oréal Miss Manga Mascara

"Makes your lashes look so full and long! Tip: Warm up in bra to make it go on smoother and make your lashes look longer!"—Submitted by Photog Writer.Get it here.
lorealparisusa.com

"Makes your lashes look so full and long! Tip: Warm up in bra to make it go on smoother and make your lashes look longer!"

—Submitted by Photog Writer.

Get it here.

23. Lorac Eyeshadow Palettes

"My holy grail product. They are so pigmented and easy to blend. This has easily changed the way I do my own makeup and others'."

—Submitted by Sara.

"Incredibly smooth, super pigmented, and would work on damn near every skin tone."

—Submitted by Katelyn.

Get them here.

24. IT Cosmetics Your Skin But Better CC Cream

"It has a super-high SPF (UVA and UVB), and it's light like a moisturizer, but it provides so much coverage that I use it as foundation. It's the best product I've purchased in years."—Submitted by Megan.Get it here.
itcosmetics.com

"It has a super-high SPF (UVA and UVB), and it's light like a moisturizer, but it provides so much coverage that I use it as foundation. It's the best product I've purchased in years."

—Submitted by Megan.


Get it here.

25. Benefit Push Up Liner

"Flawless cat eye every time, I kid you not. I've applied it in a moving car and on the bus, and it really stays put."—Submitted by Elyse Guziewicz, Facebook."It manages to be somewhere between a pencil and a liquid. Super easy to control, and it stays put."—Submitted by McMolls.Get it here.
benefitcosmetics.com

"Flawless cat eye every time, I kid you not. I've applied it in a moving car and on the bus, and it really stays put."

—Submitted by Elyse Guziewicz, Facebook.

"It manages to be somewhere between a pencil and a liquid. Super easy to control, and it stays put."

—Submitted by McMolls.


Get it here.

26. The Balm Mary-Lou Manizer

"To die for."—Submitted by Ingeborghavarsteina."This is the holy grail of powder highlighters. It goes on perfectly smooth and is perfect for both natural and more dramatic looks!"—Submitted by Maggie Parsell, Facebook.Get it here.
thebalm.com

"To die for."

—Submitted by Ingeborghavarsteina.

"This is the holy grail of powder highlighters. It goes on perfectly smooth and is perfect for both natural and more dramatic looks!"

—Submitted by Maggie Parsell, Facebook.

Get it here.

Note: Submissions have been edited for lengeth and/or clarity.

Want to be featured in similar BuzzFeed posts? Follow the BuzzFeed Community on Facebook and Twitter.

Connect with As/Is