back to top

These Parents Are Furious After Their 8-Year-Old Daughter Was Told To Cover Up At An Ontario Pool

In Guelph, only girls 4 and younger can go topless at the pool.

Posted on

Cory McLean and Anika Warmington's four children — three boys and daughter Marlee — were all wearing bottoms at the pool last Saturday, but only one of them was told to cover up.

According to the The Record, staff asked Marlee how old she was before asking her to put a top on. Guelph's policies say that only girls who are 4 or younger can go topless.

"(Marlee) was completely embarrassed. All of a sudden you're made to feel as a girl that somehow your body needs to be covered, even though it looks exactly like everyone else's," Warmington told The Record.


Warmington took to Twitter to complain, using tags like #girlsshamefree and #guelphshamesgirls.

.@guelphmercury my daughter told to cover up at Guelph public splash pad #girlsshamefree #dblstandard #guelphshamesgirls

In an interview with the Canadian Press, Kristene Scott, Guelph's general manager of parks and recreation, defended the 4-and-under rule. She said the city tries to balance both legal rights and "cultural norms" in its policies.

"Not everyone has the same comfort level with females being topless," she said.

In 1991, University of Guelph student Gwen Jacob was fined for walking through the city without a top on. Though a judge found her guilty, the conviction was overturned in appeals court in 1996. The case established that women in Ontario have the right to go topless in public without fear of charges — just like men.

"This policy sexualizes young girls and shames of their bodies starting at 4 years old! It promotes a message that victimizes innocent children," the petition says.

"It teaches them that governments, strangers and institutions control their bodies and not themselves."

The petition is nearing 300 signatures.

Lauren Strapagiel is Managing Editor for BuzzFeed News and is based in Toronto, Canada.

Contact Lauren Strapagiel at

Got a confidential tip? Submit it here.