Skip To Content

    Feast Your Eyes On The Weirdest Sandwiches Ever

    Wait, what?

    by , ,

    We recently asked the BuzzFeed Community to tell us their favorite weird-but-delicious sandwich combinations. And because we'll try anything (at least!) once, we actually made them, ate them, and lived to tell the tale.

    Find your picks — and our taste-test video — below.

    1. Ham, mayo, cheese, and Oreos on white bread.

    Jon Premosch / BuzzFeed

    —Tanya Bendall

    2.

    Kimchi. Grilled. Cheese. Kimchi and cheddar work surprisingly well together, and adding avocado just makes it even more out of this world.

    —Rachel Gutauskas

    3.

    Peanut butter and jelly, with classic yellow mustard. I did this to gross someone out once, and it was actually good.

    j4db98640f

    4.

    Ham and Nutella! In Portugal, it's normal to put butter in your ham sandwich, but since I'm allergic I decided to make a trade. Best decision ever.

    —Mariana Cardoso

    5. Fried chicken sandwich topped with Flaming Hot Cheetos and ketchup.

    Jon Premosch / BuzzFeed

    —Kristin Johnston

    6.

    Cheddar cheese, pepperoni slices, and maple syrup on toast.

    jennifera43f8ed51b

    7.

    Apples, peanut butter, and cheddar melted on sourdough. It started as a weird teen craving but I still eat it when I need a pick-me-up or just a different breakfast or lunch.

    —Emily Foley

    8.

    Ramen on a tuna sandwich.

    stagswag88

    9. Potato salad, sliced hotdogs, graham crackers, and maple syrup on white bread.

    Jon Premosch / BuzzFeed

    —Amber McGee

    10.

    Not sure if it's a Midwest thing or not, but everyone in my family is a fan of deer summer sausage with grape jelly on fresh white bread. It's a great sweet and salty combination.

    —Teri Strate-Crane

    11.

    Peanut butter and onion sandwiches, which I got from the movie Little Monsters.

    —Ape Row

    12. Avocado, American cheese, red wine vinegar, and Hidden Valley Ranch powder on a roll.

    Jon Premosch / BuzzFeed
    Jon Premosch / BuzzFeed

    "I've been eating this sandwich for about 15 years consistently." —Darrah Jones

    13.

    My favorite sandwich filling is rice with soy sauce, vegetable oil, and salt mixed in. I use ordinary white sliced bread. My family calls it "kumot-kumot" because you mix the rice with the flavorings by squeezing it.

    —Jose Lorenzo Libo-on

    14.

    Baked beans with cheese and bacon on toast.

    —Rex Tabor

    15.

    Take two slices of pizza — preferably pepperoni — and put French fries and Ranch dressing on one. Put the other slice face down on top, and hold it just like a sandwich. Fuckin' legit, man.

    Mofugrob

    16.

    Anchovies and kimchi on lightly toasted bread. The trick is not to overdo it with either one. The only condiment needed is the thinnest layer of mayo. Delicious!

    —Kristina Baldridge

    17. Peanut butter, mayonnaise, bananas, and pickles on wheat.

    Jon Premosch / BuzzFeed

    —Laura Morgan

    18.

    My pick is basically a taco in a baguette: Refried beans, mushrooms, and cheese on one side — and guacamole and pico de gallo on the other.

    —Stephanie Rood

    19.

    Mozzarella cheese slices and Oreo bites; it's like an Oreo cheesecake sandwich!

    —Nicole Rodriguez

    20.

    Peanut butter, banana, and sauerkraut on a whole grain sub roll. It's almost like a Reuben; creamy, tart, and super tasty.

    —Alexis Mundis

    21.

    Mayo, cheddar, cranberry sauce and smoked oysters. It started when my now-ex asked me to make him a sandwich, in a really awful, entitled, sexist way: he hated smoked oysters. I had to take a bite out of it when he flipped out, but it's actually surprisingly great.

    —Melissa Oleksiuk

    22. Cheez Whiz and Corn Pops on a roll.

    Jon Premosch / BuzzFeed

    "Don't knock it 'til you try it." —Alexis

    23.

    A grilled cheese with barbecue sauce, a fried egg, and pickles — cooked in a waffle iron instead of a pan.

    —Jessicka Hydra

    24.

    Smoked salmon and dark chocolate spread. Don't ask, don't question it, just make it. I swear it's good. Promise.

    —Libby Russell

    25. Turkey, potato chips, bananas, and Nutella on white bread.

    Jon Premosch / BuzzFeed
    Jon Premosch / BuzzFeed

    —Kat Sparkman

    For more, follow the BuzzFeed Community on Facebook. 😎

    Photos by Jon Premosch; Food Styling by Lindsay Hunt; Art Direction by Brian Madigan.