Skip To Content

    Here Are 14 Wildly Unpopular Opinions People Have About Oscar-Nominated Movies And Actors

    "I can't even finish Marriage Story."

    We asked the BuzzFeed Community to tell us their most controversial opinions about Oscar-nominated movies and actors, and they certainly did not hold back. Here's what they said:

    1. La La Land was actually a liiiiiiittle bit better than Moonlight.


    "As a gay man, this is blasphemy for me to say...but I really thought La La Land deserved Best Picture over Moonlight. I found Moonlight well-intentioned, but boring. La La Land was a brilliant technicolor dream grounded by a sublime Emma Stone." —kmichaels13783

    2. Cats' "Beautiful Ghosts" deserved a nomination for Best Original Song.

    Universal Pictures

    "The song is breathtaking, the vocals are on point, the music is enchanting, the lyrics are gorgeous, and the song understands the character better than the movie ever could. Andrew Lloyd Webber and Taylor Swift deserved better." —ultimatefangirl12

    3. Little Women should've won every single award it was nominated for.

    Sony Pictures Releasing

    "It's probably the only rewatchable Best Picture nominee. How did Renée Zellweger win against Saoirse Ronan?" —karthikt3133

    4. Leonardo DiCaprio's best performance, by far, was in What's Eating Gilbert Grape — not The Revenant, even though he won the Oscar for it.

    Paramount, 20th Century Studios

    "He's never been as good as he was in What’s Eating Gilbert Grape." —heygirlheyyy

    5. Adam Driver should have won Best Actor for his performance in Marriage Story instead of Joaquin Phoenix for Joker.


    "Joaquin’s Joker performance was absolutely breathtaking, but I’ve never seen a performance as raw and real as Adam’s." —elexisgrace

    6. Once Upon a Time in Hollywood was actually pretty boring and didn't deserve all the hype.

    Sony Pictures Releasing

    7. The Godfather was incredibly boring and didn't deserve all the praise it got.

    Paramount Pictures

    8. And Marriage Story wasn't actually that good of a movie.


    "I can’t even finish it." —linzemae

    9. The Shape of Water is also too overhyped, and honestly, the Amphibian Man was just plain terrifying.

    Fox Searchlight


    10. Meryl Streep deserved to win Best Actress for her performance in Florence Foster Jenkins.

    20th Century Studios

    "Meryl Streep’s performance in Florence Foster Jenkins was otherworldly and far too underrated! Streep definitely should’ve taken home that award!" —elexisgrace

    11. Brokeback Mountain deserved to win Best Picture above anything else.

    Focus Features

    "It had first-rate acting, a great script, and it was realistically heartbreaking." —slyghost86

    12. Roman Griffin Davis was robbed of a Best Actor nomination.

    Fox Searchlight

    "Roman Griffin Davis should have been nominated for Jojo Rabbit. He did an amazing job and deserved more recognition."


    13. Bohemian Rhapsody wasn't groundbreaking by any means...and honestly would've been better as a TV movie.

    20th Century Studios

    14. Finally, Laura Dern's Oscar-winning performance in Marriage Story was good, but all of her other film performances are better.


    Note: Responses have been edited for length/clarity.

    Want to be featured in similar BuzzFeed posts? Follow the BuzzFeed Community on Facebook and Twitter!