In case you've been living under a rock for the past two weeks, Netflix released Season 2 of You, the psychological thriller starring Penn Badgley as a super-creepy sociopath named Joe Goldberg. Netflix And when I say he's super creepy, I mean he's SUUUUUUUUUUUUUUPER creepy. Netflix The other night, Penn appeared on The Late Show With Stephen Colbert to talk all about all things You Season 2. View this video on YouTube youtube.com Stephen asked Penn one of the many questions on our mind, which is: How exactly does he make himself seem so scary? CBS It turns out, the trick is actually pretty simple. CBS And Penn told us a little story to explain exactly how the magic happens. CBS And I gotta admit... I was equally surprised and amused. CBS Penn went on to explain exactly why he doesn't have to do much to make Joe seem creepy, because Joe is creepy all by himself! CBS Then Stephen asked Penn the question that was on ALL of our minds. CBS And Penn did not disappoint!!!! It was actually just as uncomfy as you'd expect it to be. Tap to play or pause GIF Tap to play or pause GIF CBS Like....... CBS So there you have it, folks! Joe Goldberg can do creepy all by himself, and Penn is just there to make the words come to life. Netflix Now I'll leave you with the face of your worst nightmare. Byeeeee! 👋 CBS Watch the full clip here.