Skip To Content
  • Viral badge

This Woman Is Talking About Celebs The Media Used To Consider "Fat" When They Weren't, And How They Manipulated A Whole Generation

"The scrutiny placed on thin, conventionally attractive people affected a generation of people of all shapes and sizes to scrutinize themselves and the people around them with hatred."

Meet 32-year-old Rosey Blair, who is a plus-size lifestyle blogger and size-inclusive consultant.

She has been going viral on TikTok for her videos where she discusses the portrayal of fat people in movies and TV...and how, a lot of times, the people who were cast as "fat" characters weren't even fat:

@roseybeeme

Fat characters in movies/tv that really weren’t that fat. #fatbabe #plussize #plussizeactress #fyp #foryou #nowandthen #WhatIdWear

♬ Funky Town - The Dance Queen Group

More recently, however, she has been gaining a lot of attention for talking about how the media made us believe certain celebrities were fat when they weren't fat at all, like Kate Winslet:

@roseybeeme

Helping heal millennials one tik tok at a time #titanic #bodypositivity #katewinslet

♬ Blue Blood - Heinz Kiessling & Various Artists

"There was a time in Hollywood when this woman was laughed at in casting rooms — and referred to as 'Kate Weighs-A-Lot.' And compared to the heroine-chic models and actresses at the time, Kate was noticeably larger than what was popular. Joan Rivers even said that they both could have fit on that raft if Kate was five pounds lighter," she says in her TikTok.

Century Fox Film Corp. All rights reserved. Courtesy Everett Collection / @roseybeeme / tiktok.com

In addition, she talks about how the media warped the minds of an entire generation to have a false sense of body image and be judgmental toward other peoples' bodies:

@roseybeeme

jessica was never fat and saying she was hurts fat and thin people alike. #FreeFreeDance #jessicasimpson #bodypositivity

♬ Blue Blood - Heinz Kiessling & Various Artists

In her videos, Rosey also talks about how the media personally affected her growing up. (She shared the image of herself in 2009 on the left.) "When I saw that picture of Jessica, I thought to myself, 'Oh boy! She's disgusting,' because I was manipulated by the media. I remember the full media blitz that occurred to emphasize that she had really let herself go and was fully disgusting."

@roseybeeme / tiktok.com, Logan Fazio / Getty Images / @roseybeeme / tiktok.com

"How is this disgusting? This is freaking stunning. You wanna know how big she was here? She was a size four. FOUR."

The number of celebrity women who were shamed about their bodies by the media — and even fellow industry professionals — is truly sickening:

@roseybeeme

The mid aughts were not a vibe #bodypositivity #Tyrabanks #2000s #y2k

♬ Blue Blood - Heinz Kiessling & Various Artists

"In 2007, Tyra Banks went to the beach and had a great day. But the paparazzi were there to make sure she didn't have a great month. Soon, magazines were filled to the brim with images comparing her Sports Illustrated covers to just a regular, fun day at the beach."

FameFlynet / BACKGRID / @roseybeeme / tiktok.com, @roseybeeme / tiktok.com

BuzzFeed spoke to Rosey, who said that during quarantine, she started rewatching a bunch of films from her childhood. "I've been plus-size my entire life, so I would always mentally note when I saw someone onscreen who resembled me, or when the media referred to them as being larger. I was shocked to see that some of my old plus-size role models weren't large people at all. I wondered if this impacted the way I saw myself and other people in bigger bodies, so I started making TikToks exploring this idea. As it turns out, a lot of other people had the same misconceptions," she said.

@roseybeeme / tiktok.com

She added, "Whenever there was a character in a film that was plus-size, she was always timid, naive, or the exact opposite — sexually confident and often abrasive. When there was a woman in the industry who put on weight, she was seen as a trainwreck, as mentally unwell."

In one of her videos, Rosey explains how Amy from Pitch Perfect is just a two-dimensional, shallow depiction of a fat person so that the screenwriter can make fat jokes.

In the '90s, there wasn't a lot of plus-size representation in Hollywood. "I felt seen and acknowledged when there were round-faced actresses in film and television. Most memorably, people like Brittany Murphy in Clueless and Ginnifer Goodwin in Mona Lisa Smile. It's funny how there was such a lack of actual plus-size actresses that we all misremember round-faced women as being plus-size."

Entertainment Pictures / Alamy Stock Photo

"Round-faced, straight-size actresses are also often cast to portray plus-size characters, which helps no one," added Rosey.

Rosey thinks everyone is just now starting to realize how much the media has altered our thinking. "As I searched through images of Jessica Simpson during the infamous chili cook-off, I was really astounded at how the photos did not match my memory of the event. I saw her as a plus-size woman who was around my size at the time — which was 18-20 — and was shocked to see how much thinner she actually was."

Jessica singing on stage in a tank top and jeans
Logan Fazio / Getty Images

However, as you can see in the comments of her videos, the negative perceptions people have of body image are still very much a thing — largely because of how the media portrays celebs. "I think traditional media has a long way to go. It's important for the media to know that everyone has stories, not just people who can fit into haute couture on a red carpet," Rosey said.

@roseybeeme / tiktok.com

Rosey also talked about a more recent body-shaming instance when Selena Gomez was called fat in her bikini in 2015.

"If you want to look for a woman who has been championing herself and her image in movies for a long time, look to Queen Latifah. Her films have been doing the right thing for a very long time," she said.

"I think my media could be misconstrued as 'these people aren't fat, they're beautiful!' The message I hope to convey is that the scrutiny placed on these thin, conventionally attractive people affected a generation of people of all shapes and sizes to scrutinize themselves and the people around them with hatred," Rosey said.

You can follow Rosey on TikTok and Instagram.