Skip To Content
    Feb 14, 2020

    17 Times Lucas Scott Was Utter Trash On "One Tree Hill"

    Nathan is simply the superior brother.

    1. First, when he cheated on Brooke with her best friend, Peyton...

    The WB / Via camillewing.tumblr.com

    2. ...REPEATEDLY:

    The WB

    3. When he saw nothing wrong with immediately dating Peyton after breaking up with Brooke:

    The WB

    Karen was not here for Lucas's bullshit.

    4. When he worried Brooke, Peyton, and his mom by sneaking out to go hook up with Nicki (who turned out to be his friend Jake's ex):

    The WB

    To be fair, he didn't know who Nicki was at the time, but this was still pretty bad.

    5. When Haley tried being a cheerleader and he made her feel bad about it:

    The WB

    6. When he slut-shamed Brooke while she was in the middle of a pregnancy scare:

    The WB / Via brucasdaily.tumblr.com

    7. When he flipped out over Haley even considering sleeping with Nathan:

    The WB

    8. When he decided to leave town with Keith because it was easier than fixing all his mistakes:

    The WB

    9. When he went behind Nathan's back and messed up their brotherhood:

    The WB

    10. When he called Brooke a skank for sleeping with Chris when they weren't even officially together...

    The CW / Via brucasdaily.tumblr.com

    Yeah, Brooke wasn't completely innocent here and Lucas had a right to be hurt, but he was still WAY out of line.

    11. ...and acted all morally superior over it:

    The WB / Via brucasdaily.tumblr.com

    12. When he compared Nathan to their horrible dad:

    The WB / Via naley.co.vu

    13. When he and Peyton kissed AGAIN and then Lucas hid it from Brooke AGAIN...

    The WB / Via oth-gifs.tumblr.com

    Granted, the circumstances were pretty extreme this time (Peyton literally almost died!), but the way Lucas handled the whole situation still wasn't great. It was kind of unreasonable to expect Brooke to not be upset about the kiss, given the history between Lucas and Peyton.

    14. ...and then brought up Chris Keller to try and make it seem like he and Brooke were "even":

    The WB

    15. When he blamed Peyton for their breakup just because she didn't want to get engaged so young:

    The WB / Via dailyleyton.tumblr.com

    16. When he cheated on his fiancé Lindsey with Peyton:

    The WB / Via serenashumphrey.tumblr.com

    GET IT TOGETHER, LUCAS.

    17. And finally, when Lindsey left him and he blamed it all on Peyton instead of taking any responsibility:

    The WB

    Honestly, Lucas just sucked. Thank god for Nathan!

    The WB / Via sansestark.tumblr.com

    TV and Movies

    Get all the best moments in pop culture & entertainment delivered to your inbox.

    Newsletter signup form