We hope you love the products we recommend! All of them were independently selected by our editors. Just so you know, BuzzFeed may collect a share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page if you decide to shop from them. Oh, and FYI — prices are accurate and items in stock as of time of publication.
1.WoodLife Prints makes custom wood prints for a truly memorable gift. A piece from this shop that's this sweet and sentimental is must-gift option. It's just ~written in the stars~.
2.Tea Heritage creates darling little tea bags filled with different flavors like jasmine, Earl Grey, and pumpkin chai guaranteed to make that tea lover swoon.
3.Chicly Built dreams up some incredibly cool planters, housewares, and vases — no ifs, ands, or ~butts~ about it! Select between booty pots, body sculptures, or cat air planters.
4.Pastry Made — a must-bookmark shop for the baker at heart. This incredible shop sells embossed rolling pins with intricate designs of favorite characters, animals, and so much more.
5.Heritage Apothecary offers up everything from crystal encrusted smudging vials to incense and charging plates. Their beautiful packaging and spiritual goodies make something from this shop a no-brainer present for the witch you love.
6.SoGloss designs epic nail wraps for an easy mani at home that seriously looks professional. The store has over 100 designs, so you've got tons of options to pick from that they're sure to love.
7.Little Low's shop is filled with darling illustration and cards your mate will adore, especially coming from you.
8.Pickle Dog Designs sells a bunch of cutey, eclectic handmade goods. You can find anything from doxie magnets, to thank-you and recipe cards, and jewelry.
9.Lobo Floral Market takes gorgeous flowers, dries them, and then arranges beyond stunning of bouquets, so you can gift them some sweet florals for Valentine's Day that'll actually last past a week.
10.Astral Weekend's funky shop has all the colorful, flower-power goods their heart could ever want. *This* is the place to find all the bright, psychedelic goodness their life needs.
11.The Little Avocado is a pastel-admirer's dream shop. Filled with flirty blankets, cutesy cowgirl stickers, and inventive macrame, there is surely something unique in here for your gift recipient. Good job, you. Good job.
12.Skin Foodie specializes in skincare and beauty using raw organic ingredients their skin will love to soak up.
13.Silk Suds Shop creates the most gorgeous artisan soaps I think I have ever seen, in addition to other heavenly body products like lotions and perfume oils. BUT THE HAND SOAP! Just look at this beauty:
14.Creepy Gals — your new favorite spot for all gifts equally creepy and wonderful. C'mon, a shop with a Barbara from Beetlejuice enamel pin? Creepy gals get it.
15.Mother of Pearl makes absolutely fabulous candles (hello Venus de Milo, hello David) that'll take your candle gift-giving to an elegant new level.
16.Art 2 The Extreme transforms regular ol' crayons into custom name gift sets, donuts, and other fun things. This, my friends, is art in itself!
17.Gratia Box Co. assembles cute and simple, all-occasion gift boxes — perfect for when you're out of ideas but still want to be thoughtful...like for, uh, Valentine's Day. This shop has you covered!
18.Hereafter laser cuts gorgeous wooden stationery and keepsakes you can customize with personalized messaging. I mean, these intricate details are...*swoons*.
19.Oake & Ashe is your go-to spot for all things weaving. This adorable shop sells weaving looms and supplies, including a range of starter kits so they can pick a new hobby, no problem.
20.Penny and Horse sells fun (and informational!) illustrated prints, like classic cocktails and their accompanying recipes, coffee guides, and laundry cheat sheets.
21.Halifax Hollow — a small batch food shop handcrafted in Vermont that whips up goodies like this simple syrup set (oh, hello faaaaancy lavender) so they can play around in the kitchen like a wizard. A splash of this and dash of that — they better name their next boozy drink after you!
22.1801 & Co. offers tons of stylish office supplies and other custom goods that'll add some va va voom to their new WFH space.
23.Alijhae Arts draws up magical illustrations of Black couples and people, and then sells them in print, sticker, and t-shirt form. Might as well get them all three — I mean, they deserve to all of these whimsical designs!
24.Oh Me So Holy creates celebrity and custom prayer candles, which allows you to get the Britney-stan you know a candle worthy of their time. Or if they love their pet more than humans, you can customize it with a photo of their fur child. Congrats, you win Valentine's Day!
Them when they open your gift (obviously, because it's amazing):