The day after Twitter formally announced its plans to go public — which will hinge on its strength as an advertising platform — some users received an unusual and novel notification: an iPhone push notification from a brand.
This morning, my phone buzzed with a new message from Twitter. My account is set up such that Twitter only sends notifications to my phone on the receipt of a direct message. But this is what I saw:
Lately, I’ve been receiving notifications about popular tweets and newly popular accounts from Twitter through an internal service called
MagicRecs, which works via direct message. I assumed this had something to do with that, but it didn’t — though I do follow Dropbox, I received no direct message or reply from its account. It seemed to be an advertisement pushed to my phone, and nowhere else. An advertising phantom.
Others had the same experience. Some today, and one all the way back in May:
Just got a push notification from the twitter app from Dropbox. Very strange.
The twitter app just sent me a push notification for a promoted tweet, so I deleted it.
For some reason, Twitter has push-notified me about a tweet by @Dropbox I was not mentioned in. If advertising, doesn’t AAPL prohibit that?
This does seem like it might be prohibited by Apple’s developer guidelines, which state: “Apps cannot use Push Notifications to send advertising, promotions, or direct marketing of any kind.”
Though it’s hard to imagine Twitter hasn’t considered that, and decided that this is somehow different. Anyway, interesting timing!
Another possibility: Twitter has been been testing, on Android in particular, a system that notifies users of certain tweets deemed notable, not unlike @MagicRecs, but built into its apps. It’s possible that this tweet, which was posted two minutes before I received my notification, was selected as notification-worthy regardless of its content — it’s sort of popular, and again, I do follow Dropbox.
If the argument from Twitter is that because I follow Dropbox, and because the tweet was popular, that this wasn’t an ad, or that Dropbox didn’t pay for this, then fine: Twitter wins on a technicality. But plenty of more popular tweets come and go, and I’ve never seen this before. It seems notable that the first unprompted notification I’ve ever received from Twitter was about the only non-news brand I follow.
Twitter did not immediately respond to a request for comment. We will update if and when it does.
Update 1: Another user claims to have received a similar notification earlier this week:
@fwd @BuzzFeed It didnt start today, Itâ€™s been rolling out throughout the week. Been getting them as early as Tuesday.
Update 2: According to a recent tweet sent by Twitter CEO Dick Costolo, it seems that the push notifications are most likely a content surfacing experiment that’s gone astray as a result of a “bug”:
@CRS_One @fwd @BuzzFeed sounds like a bug. We don’t send ads via push notification. Will look into it.
More than anything, the potential “bug” appears to be a victim of unfortunate timing. When you’re a hammer, everything looks like a nail. And when one of the internet’s most prominent tech companies is about to go public, everything looks a bit like an ad unit.
- The White House defended rolling back Obama-era transgender protections, with Sean Spicer repeatedly insisting it's a "states' rights issue."
- Recreational marijuana needs "greater enforcement" of federal law, said Spicer, pitting the White House against eight states that legalized its use.
- A researcher with Human Rights Watch was denied entry into Israel earlier this week with the country's government calling the human rights organization "propaganda."
- Beyoncé has pulled out of performing at Coachella, citing doctors' advice about keeping a less rigorous schedule while pregnant 🐝😭