back to top

The London Underground Lines In "Sherlock" Are All Wrong

Sherlock returned with a London Underground story. But the real mystery was how the transport network fitted together. Warning: contains spoilers.

Posted on

The show starts with Watson on the Jubilee line, showing off his new moustache.

BBC

He then zooms along the District line.

BBC

And pops out by Euston Square station, which is on the Hammersmith & City and Metropolitan lines.

North Gower Street is standing in as Baker Street.
BBC

North Gower Street is standing in as Baker Street.

Once Watson is reunited with Sherlock, the pair look at a strange video. It shows a suspicious man attempting to travel one stop on the District line from Westminster by using a Jubilee line train.

BBC

But the man has vanished by the time his Jubilee line train reaches St James's Park. Which isn't that surprising, since St James's Park is only on the District line

He's probably been diverted to Stanmore.In reality, this was probably filmed on the disused Jubilee line platform at Charing Cross station.
BBC

He's probably been diverted to Stanmore.

In reality, this was probably filmed on the disused Jubilee line platform at Charing Cross station.

Confused by the fact that London Underground trains are pulling into stations on completely different lines, Sherlock and Watson rewatch the footage.

BBC

And Sherlock concludes that the "five minute" journey between Westminster and St James's Park must have somehow been made to last ten minutes.

In reality it takes less than two minutes and at peak times there's 28 trains an hour running along the route, leaving little room for delays. But who are we to question Sherlock?
BBC

In reality it takes less than two minutes and at peak times there's 28 trains an hour running along the route, leaving little room for delays. But who are we to question Sherlock?

The fearless investigators decide to get involved and avert a disaster. So they pop into Westminster station on the Jubilee and District lines.

BBC

Then there's a sign for the Northern Line in the background.

BBC

And then they're in the abandoned Jubilee line station at Charing Cross, where Sherlock and Watson climb down a ventilation shaft.

Which they use to access a District line train...

BBC

...by running along a disused section of the Picadilly line...

BBC

...from the former Aldwych station.

Aldwych is an abandoned station that was also used in the film V for Vendetta.
BBC

Aldwych is an abandoned station that was also used in the film V for Vendetta.

Ultimately, the shape-shifting London Underground network is an even bigger mystery than working out how Sherlock survived his fall.

Via bbcsherlockftw.tumblr.com

We hope all will be revealed next time.