Skip To Content

    Why “Scream” Fans Think These Two Beloved Characters Might Return In A Future Movie

    Reminder: No dead body, no death.

    WARNING: There are major spoilers for the new Scream in this post.

    On the surface, Stu Macher and Kirby Reed (played by Matthew Lillard and Hayden Panettiere in the original Scream and Scream 4, respectively) don't seem to have anything in common, apart from a love of horror movies.

    Stu in Scream and Kirby in Scream 4

    One big thing they do have in common? Fans desperately want them both to return to the franchise.

    This might sound odd, because, wait, didn't they both die?

    Let's consider Kirby first. Toward the end of Scream 4, after delivering one of my favorite moments in the movie (and whole franchise if we're being honest), she appears to be murdered by Charlie.

    Kirby in Scream 4

    Director Wes Craven himself even said Kirby had likely survived.

    @adudeinaz I don't think so. She was still moving when we cut away from her...

    Twitter: @wescraven

    As horror fans well know: No dead body, no death.

    Plus, while Kirby was stabbed twice in the gut, in the Scream universe, that's nothing a quick trip to the hospital can't fix.

    Sidney in Scream 4

    And if screenwriter Kevin Williamson's original vision for Scream 5 had panned out, there definitely would have been room for Kirby.

    Kirby in Scream 4

    That said, there were rumors that Williamson didn't intend for Kirby to survive.

    Kirby in Scream 4

    As it turns out, the new Scream officially settled the debate. Eagle-eyed fans have noticed that while Richie is watching a YouTube video about Stab 8, there's a recommended video in the sidebar called "Interview with Woodsboro Survivor Kirby Reed!"

    Still, there's always Scream 6!

    Channeling my inner #Kirby #Scream4 Thanks to my boys ⁦@anthonyleonard⁩ ❤️

    Twitter: @haydenpanettier

    After all, nobody knows how to suck someone back into their shenanigans quite like Ghostface.

    All right, now let's move on to Stu.

    Stu in Scream

    Full disclosure: While I totally understand wanting to see more of Matthew Lillard as Stu...I don't really buy it.

    Stills of Stu's death in Scream

    But hey, what do I know?

    Stu in Scream

    So, could Stu still return?

    Screenshot from the new Scream of a YouTube sidebar featuring a video called "Did the real-life Stu Macher survive?

    It's possible that this is a hint that Stu might be alive, or it's the filmmakers' way of playfully acknowledging a debate that's been raging for over a decade.

    Stu in Scream

    But again, anything's possible — especially considering we did see the return of a 100% dead character from the original Scream.

    Either way, Matthew Lillard seems to be in full support of the direction the Scream franchise has taken — with or without him.

    Dear #SCREAM fans, 2.0 is a love letter to each and every one of you. Congrats to the new cast & crew… welcome to the family. Wes would be proud.

    Twitter: @MatthewLillard

    Do you think we'll see Kirby or Stu in a future Scream movie? Tell us in the comments!