back to top
TVAndMovies

We Don't Need A Second Season Of "13 Reasons Why"

Here are some reasons why. (Spoilers ahead.)

Posted on

If you're like me, you watched 13 Reasons Why in almost one sitting and looked something like this by the end:

CBS

And when it ended in a way that left a number of things unanswered, your brain was like this:

Like, did Alex survive? What's Tyler planning? Will Bryce have to pay for all the harm he caused? And can Clay move on and be happy?

Netflix / Via popsugar.com

These big questions leave the door open for Season 2 — and there are many hints that the show will likely be picked up for more episodes.

Netflix

As much as I loved these characters and want some answers, I think it would ultimately be better to let the show remain as a great 13-episode project. And here's why:

1. The source material

13 Reasons Why was written as a book with no sequels — why not let it stay that way? It's about Hannah's story, which comes full circle. While there are other loose ends, I think it's more meaningful that we don't necessarily know how everything turned out. Life is messy and sometimes you don't have everything tied up neatly.
Penguin Teen

13 Reasons Why was written as a book with no sequels — why not let it stay that way? It's about Hannah's story, which comes full circle. While there are other loose ends, I think it's more meaningful that we don't necessarily know how everything turned out. Life is messy and sometimes you don't have everything tied up neatly.

2. The content

There has certainly been a mixed response to 13 Reasons Why — some are inspired by the show's anti-bullying message, while others claim it's triggering and potentially dangerous. While we obviously don't know what Season 2 would be about, the two likely topics would either be Alex's own attempt to take his life or Tyler's plans to harm others as revenge for being bullied. Both paths seem like they would go to an even darker place than Season 1.
Netflix

There has certainly been a mixed response to 13 Reasons Why — some are inspired by the show's anti-bullying message, while others claim it's triggering and potentially dangerous. While we obviously don't know what Season 2 would be about, the two likely topics would either be Alex's own attempt to take his life or Tyler's plans to harm others as revenge for being bullied. Both paths seem like they would go to an even darker place than Season 1.

3. The star

13 Reasons Why has a phenomenal young ensemble cast, but there's no denying that Katherine Langford's portrayal of Hannah anchored the whole show. While I'm sure Hannah would be present in flashbacks somehow, I personally would miss having Langford as the main character.
Netflix

13 Reasons Why has a phenomenal young ensemble cast, but there's no denying that Katherine Langford's portrayal of Hannah anchored the whole show. While I'm sure Hannah would be present in flashbacks somehow, I personally would miss having Langford as the main character.

If there is a Season 2 (and it sounds like there will be), you can bet I'll give it a chance and see where the writers take things. But I personally think this story was strong enough to exist on its own, without any follow-up.

  1. So, what do you think? Do you want a Season 2 of 13 Reasons Why?

    Correct
    Incorrect
    100%, I need to see more from these characters!
    Correct
    Incorrect
    Yes, but only if the storyline makes sense.
    Correct
    Incorrect
    No, Season 1 is perfect and it should stay that way.
    Correct
    Incorrect
    I didn't even like Season 1, TBH...
Oops. Something went wrong. Please try again later
Looks like we are having a problem on the server.
So, what do you think? Do you want a Season 2 of 13 Reasons Why?
  1.  
    vote votes
    100%, I need to see more from these characters!
  2.  
    vote votes
    Yes, but only if the storyline makes sense.
  3.  
    vote votes
    No, Season 1 is perfect and it should stay that way.
  4.  
    vote votes
    I didn't even like Season 1, TBH...
Take quizzes and chill with the BuzzFeed app.