Skip To Content
  • Viral badge
  • Poll badge

Maggie Gyllenhaal Has No Idea Where Taylor Swift's "All Too Well" Scarf Is

"And I left my scarf there at your sister's house..."

Ahhhhh, fall 2010. It was a simpler time. A time when Taylor Swift and Jake Gyllenhaal strolled throughout Brooklyn sipping maple lattes and wearing cute fall attire. A time before the old Taylor died:

Swarbrick /

That time is obviously immortalized in the lyrics of Taylor's iconic song "All Too Well," where she documents the process of leaving her scarf at Jake's sister's house:

AZ Lyrics / Via

I try not to spend too much time thinking about how Taylor allegedly knew that the scarf was in Jake's drawer EVEN NOW. Like was she stalking him? IDK! Like I said, I try not to spend too much time thinking about it.

LEST YOU FORGOT, Jake's sister is actor Maggie Gyllenhaal, which means the scarf was ALLEGEDLY discarded in Maggie's Park Slope brownstone.

Jason Merritt / Getty Images

But when Andy Cohen asked Maggie if she really had Taylor's scarf on Watch What Happens Live last night, she was pretty confused about the whole thing:

YouTube / Via

Maggie about the scarf: "I DON'T KNOW HER."

Once Andy explained the whole "All Too Well" lyric thing a bit, Maggie conceded that the scarf could potentially be at her house:

YouTube / Via

The truth is, we may never know where the scarf is now, but we'll always know what it smells like:

AZ Lyrics / Via

Watch Andy ask Maggie the question we all needed answered here:

View this video on YouTube

Fast forward to 2021: Now that Taylor has released the 10-minute of "All Too Well" in Red (Taylor's Version), everyone is once again wondering the whereabouts of the scarf.

Jake Gyllenhaal probably: No seriously Maggie, I know the scarf is at your place. I’m in some real deep shit right now. Where the hell is the scarf?!

Twitter: @poppadarv

poor maggie gyllenhaal waking up and realising she’s gonna be asked about that damn scarf for 10 more years.

Twitter: @Ingrid_Ege

Seriously though how much of Maggie Gyllenhaal’s Oscar campaign Q&A is gonna be about a scarf a teenager left at her house over a decade ago

Twitter: @BrianDuffield

For context: this tweet is referring to Maggie's movie The Lost Daughter, which was just released and is getting some Oscar buzz.

  1. Where is Taylor's scarf?

    Where is Taylor's scarf?

Oops. Something went wrong. Please try again later
Looks like we are having a problem on the server.
Where is Taylor's scarf?
    vote votes
    Somewhere in Maggie's house
    vote votes
    In Jake's drawer, even now...
    vote votes
    At a Goodwill store somewhere
    vote votes