Remixed: A New Kind Of Mint Julep

This cocktail is not just ideal for Kentucky Derby day, but also any other day of the year, if you ask me. Here’s tasty a recipe from an 1862 book that uses cognac instead of bourbon.

Bourbon is the obvious choice of booze for a julep, especially on Kentucky Derby day, which takes place where bourbon was born. But in his 1862 book How to Mix Drinks Jerry Thomas offers a recipe that uses cognac instead.

With leftover cognac from the Hot Brandy Toddy, I made a couple batches of Thomas’ Mint Julep for my boyfriend – who wooed me with homemade bourbon mint juleps the summer we met – and one of his friends. I was certain the brandy would throw them off, but they drank approvingly. This could indicate an imminent comeback for cognac, or more likely, a lack of discrimination when it comes to brown liquor.

Tips for Lazy Boozers

• Instead of sugar and water, I used simple syrup I’d already made (by dissolving equal parts of sugar and water in a heated saucepan). Either works fine.

• Okay, CONFESSION TIME: I skipped the bouquet arrangement and the fruit topping. But looking back, those “small pieces of sliced orange on top in a tasty manner” seems like a missed opportunity with the cognac. So consider going the extra mile with those puppies if you’re feeling patient.

Check out more articles on!

  Your Reaction?

    Starting soon, you'll only be able to post a comment on BuzzFeed using a Facebook account or via our app. If you have questions or thoughts, email us here.

    Hot Buzz

    25 Desserts So Good-Looking You’d Be OK Leaving Your Family For Them

    Celebrity Accent Battle

    Now Buzzing