Skip To Content

    29 Non-Traditional Holiday Songs That Won't Drive You Insane

    No carols, only bops.

    1. "Underneath the Tree" — Kelly Clarkson

    Kelly Clarkson singing in a formal red dress as snow falls around her
    Sony / Via

    Honestly one of the most underrated holiday songs. Even if you rate it, it's still underrated.

    2. "Christmas (Baby Please Come Home)" by Darlene Love

    Darlene Love sings in front of a microphone wearing a red and white patterned top
    ABC / Via

    Love's "All Alone On Christmas" deserves a shout out, but it's just edged out by this absolute icon.

    3. "Ribbons and Bows" by Kacey Musgraves

    Kacey Musgraves dances in front of a cheering crowd in a room decorated for Christmas
    Amazon Prime

    Kacey Musgraves has some great holiday music, but this up-tempo bop is the best. There's nothing super revelatory about it; it's just pure FUN, and who doesn't need that at the holidays?

    4. "A Christmas Duel" by The Hives and Cyndi Lauper

    Cover of the single for "A Christmas Duel" by The Hives and Cydni Lauper
    The Orchard / Via

    What's more festive than people being hurling insults at each other and begrudgingly spending time together? *Cough*

    5. "Christmas in Hollis" by Run DMC

    Run DMC perform in a room decorated for Christmas
    Sony / Via

    It is impossible to listen to this song and not be in a good mood.

    6. "Don't Shoot Me Santa" by The Killers

    Brandon Flowers sings in the backseat of a convertible with tinsel wrapped around his body
    UMG / Via

    A frankly ridiculous song, and I mean that in the best possible way.

    7. "Fairytale of New York" by The Pogues

    Black and White still from the "Fairytale of New York" music video; Shane MacGowan  sings at at a piano, wearing sunglasses and a suit
    Warner Music UK / Via

    This song is not without controversy, with a lot of pushback over offensive words used in the lyrics. But there's no denying the huge impact the song has had on the holidays. In the UK, it even beats out Mariah Carey for the most-played modern Christmas tune.

    8. "White Wine in the Sun" by Tim Minchin

    Time Minchin smiles while singing into a microphone
    CBS / Via

    This song speaks directly to the skeptical, secular millennial holiday spirit, while also delivering one hell of a love song to his own baby girl. He also evokes distinctly Australian imagery that is a stark contrast to traditional white Christmas vibes.

    9. "Let It Snow" by Boyz II Men

    Boyz II Men wear matching Christmas cardigans and sing while sitting around a table in front of a bookshelf
    Universal Music / Via

    So much '90s nostalgia. Remember Boyz II Men performing it on The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air? Incredible

    10. "Someday at Christmas" by Stevie Wonder

    Stevie Wonder sits in a room decorated for Christmas
    Sony / Via

    Released in response to the Vietnam War, "Someday at Christmas" is a wistful song about wanting peace, happiness and equality on Earth.

    11. "That's Christmas To Me" by Pentatonix

    Pentatonix sit in a room decorated for Christmas, with a tree and presents off to the side
    Sony / Via

    Pentatonix have so many excellent covers of classic holiday songs, but this original is lovely too.

    12. "Christmas Time (Don't Let The Bells End)" by The Darkness

    Justin Hawks sings in front of a fire
    WMG / Via

    No offence to "All I Want For Christmas Is You", but this is the holiday song that is actually the most fun to sing along to.

    13. "California Christmastime" by the Crazy Ex-Girlfriend cast

    Darryl and Carol from Crazy Ex-Girlfriend wear Christmas sweaters and look into the camera while a woman with curly hair and a henna tattoo on her chest looks down
    The CW / Via

    Like every Crazy Ex-Girlfriend song, "California Christmastime" is both hilarious and catchy as hell.

    14. "Santa Tell Me" by Ariana Grande

    Ariana Grande dances in a dark room while wearing a Christmas sweater and sparkly reindeer antlers
    Republic / Via

    Ariana brings her own flavor to the classic Christmas genre: asking Santa to solve all your romantic troubles.

    15. "Christmas in Harlem" by Kanye West featuring Cyhi Da Prynce and Teyana Taylor

    Single cover of "Christmas in Harlem" featuring the text: "Christmas in Harlem" Kanye West, Cyhi Da Prynce, Teyana Taylor
    Universal / Via

    Kanye West might not be the first artist you think of in association with Christmas, but this is an underrated addition to the non-traditional canon.

    16. "Santa Baby" by Eartha Kitt

    Earth Kitt stands in front of a red striped wall wrapped in fur with her shoulders exposed
    VCI / Via

    The holidays deserve some sexy songs too. And this is the sexiest.

    17. "Blue Christmas" by Elvis Presley

    A sweaty Elvis Presley wears a black leather jacket and sings into a microphone
    Sony / Via

    Another sexy Christmas song, but this one is also kinda mopey. Because sad and horny is the vibe of the season.

    18. "Please Come Home For Christmas" by Eagles

    Single cover for "Please Come Home For Christmas" by Eagles featuring a group of people sitting around a pool in swimsuits
    Mercury / Via

    There are a few significant covers of this song, but this is the most iconic of them all.

    19. "Have Yourself A Merry Little Christmas" by Judy Garland

    Close up of Judy Garland in Meet Me In St Louis
    Warner Bros / Via

    Written for Meet Me In St Louis (a fantastic movie), this song has transcended its origins to become a Christmas classic. But Judy Garland's wistful take on it is still the definitive one.

    20. "2000 Miles" by The Pretenders

    Chriss Hynde wearing a dark bonnet with fake snow on her head and shoulders

    With themes of yearning and loss, it captures the way the holiday season makes you miss people in a very particular way.

    21. "How To Make Gravy" by Paul Kelly

    Paul Kelly playing a guitar and singing into a microphone while standing on a rooftop, with a guitarist standing behind him

    "How To Make Gravy" tells a cathartic story that captures the feeling of being separated from your family and missing Christmas altogether.

    22. "River" by Joni Mitchell

    Black and white image of Joni Mitchell ice skating
    Warner / Via

    There have been many amazing covers of this heartwrenching song, but nothing beats Joni.

    23. "Mistletoe" by Justin Bieber

    Justin Bieber wearing a jacket and standing in front of a lantern in the snow
    UMG / Via

    It's a bop and if you deny it you're just deluding yourself.

    24. "Last Christmas" by Wham!

    George Michael stares intently at someone over a wine glass; in front of him a man and a woman carry on a conversation
    Sony / Via

    Not quite the greatest holiday song of all time (that title is reserved for another, which I'll get to, don't worry), but it's up there.

    25. "Merry Christmas Baby" by Otis Redding

    Record cover of "Merry Christmas Baby" by Otis Redding, featuring an image of Otis Redding in the middle of a star

    Many have tried, but no one has ever done this song as well as Otis Redding.

    26. "Snowman" by Sia

    Claymation image of a girl with two snowmen
    WMG / Via

    A sweet little ditty that's elevated by Sia's soulful voice. Sia's entire holiday album is wonderful.

    27. "Baby, It's Cold Outside" by the Glee cast

    Kurt and Blaine from Glee wearing school uniforms and singing together
    Fox / Via

    There's a lot of discourse around this song, but it's damn catchy, and this performance by Kurt and Blaine on Glee is an utter delight.

    28. "What Christmas Means To Me" by John Legend and Stevie Wonder

    Cover of "A Legendary Christmas" album by John Legend featuring John Legend wearing a Santa hat
    Columbia / Via

    John Legend's holiday album is a wonderful mix of classics and original songs, but it's this cover/duet with Stevie Wonder that is the ultimate gift.

    29. "All I Want For Christmas Is You" by Mariah Carey

    Mariah Carey wears a red outfit with fluffy white trim and bends down next to a reindeer
    Sony / Via


    Like this list? Here's a Spotify playlist for your listening pleasure: