Witch's Brew Frappuccino REAL Correct Incorrect REAL Via Getty Images NOT REAL Correct Incorrect NOT REAL Via Getty Images Correct! Wrong! REAL The totally ~bewitching~ beverage debuted in October 2018 and featured a concoction of bat warts and lizard scale powder. Via @starbucks / instagram.com Cookies and Scream Frappuccino REAL Correct Incorrect REAL Via Getty Images NOT REAL Correct Incorrect NOT REAL Via Getty Images Correct! Wrong! NOT REAL This drink doesn't exist, but it'd probably be one worth hollering about if it did. Frappula Frappuccino REAL Correct Incorrect REAL Via Getty Images NOT REAL Correct Incorrect NOT REAL Via Getty Images Correct! Wrong! REAL YES, YES, YES. The Halloween Frappula Frappuccino was a thing, and it graced us with its ghoulish presence back in 2016. Via @starbucks / instagram.com Very Berry Hibiscus Refresher REAL Correct Incorrect REAL Via Getty Images NOT REAL Correct Incorrect NOT REAL Via Getty Images Correct! Wrong! REAL The drink comes from a family of Starbucks Refreshers and is made with blackberries and green coffee extract. Via Starbucks.com Shaken Iced Piña Colada Tea Infusion REAL Correct Incorrect REAL Via Getty Images NOT REAL Correct Incorrect NOT REAL Via Getty Images Correct! Wrong! REAL This drink is like a cocktail in a cup, and it tastes like paradise. Via Starbucks.com Shaken Berry Daiquiri Iced Tea REAL Correct Incorrect REAL Via Getty Images NOT REAL Correct Incorrect NOT REAL Via Getty Images Correct! Wrong! NOT REAL Ugh, if only! But for now, we'll just have to settle for some of the other iced teas on the menu that, you know, actually exist. Shaken Peach Citrus White Tea Infusion Lemonade REAL Correct Incorrect REAL Via Getty Images NOT REAL Correct Incorrect NOT REAL Via Getty Images Correct! Wrong! REAL Yep, this drink is real. The peach and white tea flavors are subtle and oh-so-refreshing! Via Starbucks.com Blueberry Black Tea Infusion REAL Correct Incorrect REAL Via Getty Images NOT REAL Correct Incorrect NOT REAL Via Getty Images Correct! Wrong! NOT REAL This drink is 100% fake. But we'd totally get our hands on this flavor combo if we could. Nitro Lemon Fog REAL Correct Incorrect REAL Via Getty Images NOT REAL Correct Incorrect NOT REAL Via Getty Images Correct! Wrong! REAL Seriously not lying here, folks. Unless you go to Starbucks *JUST* for the classic Nitro Lemon Fog, you probably haven't noticed it buried under all the Frappuccinos. Via Starbucks.com Hot Fudge Swirl Mocha REAL Correct Incorrect REAL Via Getty Images NOT REAL Correct Incorrect NOT REAL Via Getty Images Correct! Wrong! NOT REAL Though we wish it were! This drink would be exactly what our chocolate dreams are made of. Salted Caramel White Chocolate Fudge Frappuccino REAL Correct Incorrect REAL Via Getty Images NOT REAL Correct Incorrect NOT REAL Via Getty Images Correct! Wrong! NOT REAL If this drink sounds too good to be true — it is! One thing's for sure, though: It'd literally be decadence in a cup. Steamed Apple Juice REAL Correct Incorrect REAL Via Getty Images NOT REAL Correct Incorrect NOT REAL Via Getty Images Correct! Wrong! REAL Steamed apple juice is an actual beverage on the menu! It's actually a soul-warming alternative for those who prefer a non-caffeinated drink. Via Starbucks.com Cinnamon Dolce Praline Hot Chocolate REAL Correct Incorrect REAL Via Getty Images NOT REAL Correct Incorrect NOT REAL Via Getty Images Correct! Wrong! NOT REAL As far as Starbucks hot chocolate goes, this is not a real option. It does sound like it'd be the perfect drink to slowly sip in front of a fireplace. Fairy Dust Frappuccino REAL Correct Incorrect REAL Via Getty Images NOT REAL Correct Incorrect NOT REAL Via Getty Images Correct! Wrong! NOT REAL This drink is about as real as actual fairies, but that doesn't mean we won't still fantasize about what it'd taste like. Cinnamon Maple Macchiato REAL Correct Incorrect REAL Via Getty Images NOT REAL Correct Incorrect NOT REAL Via Getty Images Correct! Wrong! NOT REAL This heavenly-sounding fall drink exists only in our dreams. We can almost picture frolicking through the leaves with a cup in hand.