Give it a chance: American Housewife

Be excited: Atlanta

Be excited: Better Things

Avoid: Bull

Give it a chance: Conviction

Give it a chance: Designated Survivor

Give it a chance: Divorce

Give it a chance: Eyewitness

Avoid: The Exorcist

Be excited: Fleabag

Give it a chance: Frequency

Give it a chance: Good Behavior

Be excited: The Good Place

Give it a chance: The Great Indoors

Be excited: Insecure

Avoid: Kevin Can Wait

Give it a chance: Lethal Weapon

Avoid: MacGyver

Avoid: Man With a Plan

Be excited: Marvel's Luke Cage

Give it a chance: No Tomorrow

Avoid: Notorious

Be excited: One Mississippi

Be excited: Pitch

Avoid: Pure Genius

Be excited: Quarry

Be excited: Queen Sugar

Be excited: Search Party

Be excited: Speechless

Be excited: Shut Eye

Avoid: Son of Zorn

Give it a chance: Sweet/Vicious

Be excited: This Is Us

Give it a chance: Timeless

Give it a chance: Westworld

Note: The premiere episode for Amazon's Woody Allen series Crisis in Six Scenes was not available to screen, and therefore was not included. And though Netflix has new episodes of Gilmore Girls and Black Mirror coming this fall, as they are continuations of existing shows, they were not included because the shows themselves are not new.
UPDATE
The Westworld entry has been updated to omit a spoiler.