Skip To Content

    18 Toys From Amazon Your Kids May Try To Steal From Your Pets

    Here are a few toys that you might just find hiding in your kids' rooms.

    We hope you love the products we recommend! All of them were independently selected by our editors. Just so you know, BuzzFeed collects a share of sales and/or other compensation from the links on this page. Oh, and FYI — prices are accurate and items in stock as of time of publication.

    1. A plush cactus toy that is perfect for your dog to destroy. It contains another toy stuffed inside of it, meaning that once your dog (which, you know they will) tears through the first layer of plush, they will have another squeaky toy to play with. It's also extremely soft, so you might just find this toy in your toddler's collection.

    A dog chewing on a green plush cactus toy

    Promising review: "Bought one for my mom’s 'super chewer' and one for our corgi. They have become the favored toys for both dogs! While the super chewer is working on destroying his, it’s been two to three weeks and the outer cover is still intact. Meanwhile, the corgi loves fetching his." —Meghan S.

    Price: $10.99 (available in four deigns)

    2. A set of four plush mice, because your kitten needs something new to hunt for a while. This pack comes with two toys containing bells for the daytime, and two toys without bells inside for nighttime play. Not to mention, your child will think this toy looks great on display with their other stuffed animals.

    Cat cuddling with the snake-like toy

    Promising review: "My little foster kitten loved her long-tail mouse! She hunted, caught, killed, and tried to eat it (nursed on it actually). She loved this toy better than any of the other dozens of toys she had! Will keep these 'in stock' from now on for all my fosters to take home with them." —CycleAZLindyB

    Price: $9.98 (available in two designs)

    3. A Lambchop squeaky toy to keep your dog busy for hours on end. If your child is a Lambchop fan, then they will surely want to play with it, too.

    Beagle cuddling with the lamb plush toy

    Promising review: "This is the third at least we have gotten for our dog, who goes through squeak/noisemaking toys like candy. It is the only toy that reliably lasts more than an hour or so in his jaws; we think because the noise it makes sounds different enough from other squeaks that he doesn't immediately have the urge to destroy it." —Gretchen S.

    Price: $5.99 (available in three designs)

    4. A set of five cute cat-shaped toys that come in a variety of colors for everyone in your household. These toys are ideal for your cat to chase around, while your child snags one away to keep by their bedside table.

    a white cat with a brown and black striped tale holding a grey cat-shaped toy with pink, black, orange, and red cat-shaped toys next to them

    This product contains five cat-shaped toys.

    Promising review: "Our cat loves this toy. She is an older cat who likes to use these as her pillow. She also loves to carry and toss them. These cats are the perfect size and she really does use and play with them every day." —BACuyler

    Price: $9.98 (available in three colors)

    5. A hedgehog plush toy, because it contains a squeaker for the best day of play your furbaby has had in a while. When playtime is over, both your furry friend and child will want to snuggle this soft toy as they snooze away.

    a beige chihuahua with a brown and tan stuffed hedgehog toy

    Promising review: "Well, it was not quite a month before the dog eviscerated it. Yet she loved it for all that time and carried it with her everywhere. And now that all the stuffing has been removed, she is still carrying the limp remains around with her. So I'm still giving it 5 stars." —needingknittles

    Price: $5.99 (available in sizes S-XL)

    6. A set of sushi plush toys so cute, even you might want to steal them from your little kitten. Each toy contains mint-flavored catnip, making this a great way for your feline friend to enjoy moments of play while taking care of their teeth, too.

    A kitten asleep and cuddling an assortment of black yellow red and yellow stuffed sushi toys

    This product comes with six plush toys.

    Promising review: "Just got these in and my baby LOVES them! Super soft, well made, and she immediately started drooling and playing with them. Super cute, great size for her to roll around and play with." —Riley Coyote

    Price: $15.99

    7. A hide-and-seek plush toy that your dog will definitely want to use as a pillow. It'll turn your dog into a four-legged Sherlock Holmes in no time, as this toy is great for hiding treats. Beware: your child might want to play a makeshift version of whack-a-mole with this one.

    Dog sleeping while cuddling the plush log toy

    Promising review: "This thing is way sturdier than I thought it would be! It's not a typical 'soft, plush toy' like most of the other similar hide-and-seek toys, but more of a sturdy fabric that has a soft texture on the outside. It's great for hiding treats and it takes a while for my big guy to remove all the little dinosaurs and find the prizes inside." —Susan

    Price: $15.99 (available in six designs)

    8. A chew toy soft enough for your pet, and cute enough for your child's desk set up. This toy has chew guard technology, meaning that it will stand the test of time as your dog tries to tear through it like it's nobody's business.

    Dog playing with the rainbow fuzz ball toy outside

    Promising review: "This product is one that is a staple in my household. My doberman destroys almost everything I buy for her. For some reason, the material in this product is quite strong and she would rather chew on it than destroy it. I have three of these in my arsenal, which I cycle through one by one as they get gross and then rebuy about twice a year." —deathnesia

    Price: $8.98 (available in two sizes and in four colors)

    9. A windmill cat toy that will help keep your mischevious kitty in one spot for an extended period of time. The LED balls on this toy hold catnip, while the spiked center is perfect for those cute little cheek scratches that your felines love to do. Simply suction this toy to any wall or surface and witness the hours of fun ensue. This product resembles a fidget spinner, so you'll definitely find your child playing with this, too.

    a turquoise spinning toy with a spiked center, with two rotating LED balls (one of which is lit blue)

    Promising review: "Unconventionally using this as a baby toy. Just toss the cat nip (I put a light up bouncing ball in the other side) and stick it to your wall low enough the crawling baby can get to it. It’s currently deterring my 8-month-old from outlets and cords! Cheap and convenient!" —Elizabeth

    Price: $10.99

    10. A chargeable stuffed goldfish toy whose tail flops when activated. If you are looking after the dental hygiene and wellness of your cat, you do have the option to stuff this toy with the catnip included in your purchase. Plus, the flopping tail will mesmerize your child, the same way that singing fish wall decor kept you engaged during your youth.

    A brown and orange striped cat with a silver flopping fish toy in between their paws

    Promising review: "Excellent quality and the USB recharging is awesome! There is a zip compartment in the belly just open it up to switch it on/off, or charge it, or add a fresh catnip pouch (optional, it came with 1). Kitty loves it!" —Janet Blair

    Price: $12.49 (available in two colors)

    11. A llama stuffed toy so precious, your kid will want to display it in their room. It squeaks and comes with extra plush stuffing, meaning it will last quite a while as your dog chews through.

    a grey and white puppy sitting in their bed with an ivory llama stuffed toy next to them

    Promising review: "My Aussie loves his llama!!! Usually he rips things off the toys we give him (like eyeballs) but this one has held up so well! Not to mention, it’s so stinking cute! This is my favorite dog toy purchase this year." —Alison M.

    Price: $7.80 (available in two designs)

    12. A stuffed Yoda toy your child will surely wish to add to their collection of Star Wars figurines. It even squeaks, making it a perfect toy to keep your four-legged companions preoccupied while you take care of your to-do list.

    a german shepard chewing on a green, brown, and beige stuffed Yoda toy

    Promising review: "I have a 7-month-old English bulldog puppy who loves his Yoda. He carries him around all day and sleeps with him at night. He’s a pretty aggressive chewer but for some reason, he hasn’t destroyed this toy. Yoda is holding up well and I will be buying a few extras just in case anything happens to his Yoda." —Ciara

    Price: $7.99 (available in three sizes and in two designs)

    13. A Gumby dog toy, because your child might be tired of your dog stealing their real Gumby toy. This is a plush toy that contains no squeakers, making it perfect for late night playing while you try to get your beauty rest.

    a pug holding a green plush gumby toy with its tail

    Promising review: "Gumby has been in my home for about two weeks now. My dog grabbed Gumby out of my hand when I took it out of the box and it has become his new favorite toy. Everywhere that he goes in the house, Gumby is hanging out of his mouth." —Lanie

    Price: $3.99 (available in sizes medium and large)

    14. A squeaky stuffed giraffe your animal will surely drag all around the house. The 22-inch arms and legs that contain squeakers are perfect for bigger dogs to chew on — but your child may also want to hang this adorable toy on their bed post.

    A black dog with an orange and yellow stuffed giraffe toy in its mouth

    Promising review: "My rescue mastiff/pit chews anything and everything and I wanted to try to put a stop to that. This was delivered three days ago and it’s still in one piece, so it’s worth the price. He likes chewing it and he enjoys playing tug-of-war with it, too. This toy is a win and I will buy one again if and when he tears it up." —NJS

    Price: $8.32 (available in four designs)

    15. A soft flying disc that your child will love throwing and your dog will have a blast catching. For those of you near the shore, this disc floats in the water, meaning you will never lose your dog's new favorite toy.

    a black and brown dog sitting in grass with an orange frisbee in front of them

    Promising review: "This is a great disc, particularly for those who are concerned about damaging their dog's teeth and are looking for a soft toy." —Publius-1776

    Price: $7.95 (available in four colors)

    16. A squeaky rubber ball for your dog to enjoy a fun fall day playing catch. This toy contains a gum-massaging spiked exterior, which will help with your dog's dental hygiene while it plays for hours in the sun. Your child will definitely want to throw this around the house for a bit, too.

    a grey god with a green collar napping with a blue rubber spiked ball in its arms

    Promising review: "My squeaky-loving monster-chewer says thank you, thank you, thank you! Literally, this is THE first squeaky toy my bully-shepherd cross has not been able to chew through AT ALL in the entire year I've had him!" —ksc

    Price: $7.99

    17. A stuffed cupcake that your child might find suits their interior design choices. This toy contains not just one, but two squeakers that will hold your dog over until dinnertime.

    a tan mastiff with a blue and white stuffed cupcake toy between its paws

    Promising review: "I have a pit/lab mix and previously he would tear a plush toy up in less than 25 secs. Lately, we have been getting him the sturdy plush toys that don't have ears, tails, beaks, flippers, etc. Well, to my surprise this toy is still intact after three days." —Hallee Nichols

    Price: $6.80 (available in two designs)

    18. An avocado stuffed toy, because your cats deserve to enjoy this delicious fruit, too. This toy is stuffed with catnip, making it great for both playtime and dental hygiene. Your kids will surely want to add this toy to their next fruit-and-veggie-inspired puppet shows.

    An orange and white cat with a stuffed green and brown avocado in front of it

    Promising review: "My big 18-pounder loves these things. This is my second one after the first one finally broke down after about two months. Keep in mind he's a big, strong cat who was extremely rough with it as he is all his toys." —Joel Rudy

    Price: $3.19 (available in 28 designs)

    The reviews for this post have been edited for length and clarity.

    What's your favorite product?

    Tell us about your favorite product
    Your review may be featured in a post.
    Minimum 25 characters, 1500 characters left
    Upload up to 4 photos you took of the product and/or how you use it. (We love before & after photos!)
    View our photo guidelines with tips that increase your chance of getting featured.
    Max 10 MB. Accepted file types: .jpg, .jpeg, .png.

    Need A Shopping Buddy?

    Get great products - from pros in the fine art of buying stuff online - delivered to your inbox!
    Newsletter signup form