back to top

24 Dark And Spooky Makeup Products So Pretty, They'll Make You Shiver

Get ready to look scary good!

Posted on

We hope you love the products we recommend! Just so you know, BuzzFeed may collect a small share of sales from the links on this page.

1. Kat Von D Saint And Sinner Eyeshadow Palette has 24 pigmented shades inspired by stained glass in gothic cathedrals. Apply it on your lids whenever you're ready to vamp out. / Via @katvondbeauty, / Via @katvondbeauty

The palette includes a range of metallic, mattes, shimmers, and glitters matching the theme of ~saints and sinners~!

Promising Review: "The shadows are ridiculously pigmented and blend flawlessly. Honestly, they're the best pigmented shadows I've ever purchased. Even the shimmers are easy to blend, and you won't need to wet your brush for them to show. When you dip your brush in, you will probably comment out loud to yourself about how good they are." —SOJD

Get it from Sephora for $62.

3. Pat McGrath Labs Mothership Palette allows your dark soul to be creative with vivid colors that'll make you drool. / Via @patmcgrathreal

The Mothership Palette has cream-infused powder so the colors will literally spread like BUTTER on your lids and who doesn't want that?!

Promising Review: "It's a known rule in the makeup industry that darks are hard to make, and this has been an excuse for darker colors being inferior to nudes for a long time. The black in this palette is the most pigmented and opaque shadow I’ve ever seen!" —owphiMUA

Get it from Sephora for $125.


4. Colourpop Dr. M Ultra Matte Lip glides smoothly onto your lips with tons of color that dries absolutely kiss-proof. Score!

Promising Review: "The best dark green matte liquid lipstick I have yet to find! This color is the perfect dark green, and it's a very fun and pretty color for those times when you wanna grab attention or go on a night out." —Michelle

Get it from Colourpop for $6.

5. L.A. Girl Smokey Eyeshadow can give you the most alluring eyes this side of Halloweentown. All you need now is a skeleton taxi driver.

Promising Review: "I've been looking for a good smoky eye palette that was actually SMOKY. Most of the colors on the eye shadows I get are too light for my skin tone. The colors are amazing and some are darker than others!" —Pierce Household

Get it from Amazon for $5.67 or Jet for $5.90.

6. Makeup Forever Artist Liquid Matte Lipstick has a ridiculously long-lasting, saturated formula that won't dry out your lips during the witching hour. / Via @makeupforeverofficial

Promising Review: "So happy with this. The formula is one of the best I've ever tried; it's matte, long lasting, but most importantly it's not drying and doesn't make your lips look cracky!" —kate010

Get it from Sephora for $20. Available in 15 colors.

7. BH Cosmetics Nude Rose Night Fall Palette is absolutely cruelty-free without sacrificing its smooth and vibrant application. Just because you're up to no good doesn't mean you don't care about animals!

Promising Review: "Love this palette! It goes on very smoothly and I love all of the colors that come with it, especially the glittery eyeshadows!" —Vanessa M.

Get it from BH Cosmetics for $11.99 or Jet for $17.20.


8. Lime Crime Velvetines Liquid Matte Lipstick has brilliant dark shades that are completely touch-proof and transfer-proof, so when you go and bite into someone's neck no one will ever even know you were there.

Promising Review: "Lime Crime knows how to make a long lasting, true matte lipstick. I love dark matte lips and this is one of my favorites. I wear it often and really like it. I only have to apply once in the morning, and after I've eaten!" —Alison M.

Get it from Amazon for $20. Available in 44 colors.

9. Milk Makeup Tattoo Stamp creates absolutely edgy marks on your face so it'll look like you took the plunge and got *forever* tattoos.

Promising Review: "These stamps are so fun. They give you a perfect star or heart every time. This is perfect for days I don't feel like wearing a lot of makeup but still want to look really cute. The packaging is very sleek and fits into my makeup organizer perfectly." —groveyardd

Get it from Urban Outfitters for $12. Available in five shapes.

10. Urban Decay Little Vices Lipstick Kit includes five delightfully sinful matte shades that'll have you looking as creepy as you dare to be! / Via @urbandecaycosmetics, / Via @urbandecaycosmetics

It comes with five vibrant lipsticks including creams, metallics, and mattes!

Promising Review: "I love Urban Decay lipsticks. There's no smell, they're moisturizing, and they don't have any strange feel to them. The color stays on, but doesn't dry your lips out." —Jill123123

Get the set of five from Sephora for $25.

11. Sonia Kashuk Showstoppers Eyeshadow Quad comes with a blend of sparkly, matte, and metallic shades to use to your (black) heart's desire!

Promising Review: "I love all of Sonia Kushuk's shadow and this one is just as nice. The colors are super neutral and pretty and the shimmer is beautiful as ever. I always get compliments on these shadows." —Marty200M

Get it from Target for $10.95.


12. Lorac Pirates of The Caribbean Eye Shadow Palette will have you looking like a real life Jack Sparrow even after Halloween is over. / Via @loraccosmetics

Promising Review: "This is a lovely set, the box is gorgeous, and I love the Pirates theme. The eyeshadows are what you expect from Lorac and just add the final touch to a fantastic product!" —J. Hall

Get it from Amazon for $52.

13. Stila Stay All Day Liquid Eyeliner waterproof formula will stay in place, even if you cry tears of evil. / Via @stilacosmetics

Promising Review: "I am extremely picky with eyeliner. I have only found one other that I actually like. This is amazing; it lasts all day, and the eyeliner itself lasts months before having buying another one. It's extra dark, and can create a very neat, fine point." —Jessica

Get it from Amazon for $22 or Jet for $21.49. Available in 14 colors.

15. Milk Makeup Lip Color features a demi-matte formula for everyone who wants to look like Elvira, but still wants a little sheen!

Promising Review: "These lipsticks are so amazing. The colors are beautiful and so pigmented! The formula is smooth and finishes matte. I love that it looks kind of like a liquid lipstick, but it's very moisturizing and doesn't dry your lips at all." —mercyy

Get it from Urban Outfitters for $22. Available in 12 colors.


17. Essie Nail Polish Neutrals have a bright, satin finish so your nails can match your black cat.

Promising Review: "I bought this color yesterday and I'm already wearing it now. I was excited to try it out, and it didn't disappoint! It was super easy to apply; I only needed one coat and it dried very quickly." —Olivialute

Get it from Target for $8.99.

19. ILNP Missed Calls Holographic Nail Polish has a mix of sparkly blacks and greens for just the right amount of creepy to match your scary costume.

Promising Review: "I am absolutely in love with this polish and now a fan of this brand! I enjoy how smooth it spread on my nails! One coat was good but two coats was beautiful, and it doesn't have a harsh polish smell." —Angelica

Get it from Amazon for $10+.


20. Mac Cosmetics Le Disko Eyeshadow is rich in pigment and won't leave much fall out for a really bold-ass club eye.


Promising Review: "What can I say I was blown away! This eyeshadow is the bomb dot com; it's very pigmented and has glitter to add a little razzle dazzle." —Celndy

Get it from Nordstrom for $18. Available in 10 colors.

21. Benefit Bolder And Bigger Brows Kit can deliver dramatic-ass eyebrows for that cool bar you've been dying to go to.

Promising Review: "This kit is great — it has all the components you need to make a dramatic and bold statement with your brows. I love it." —Lorrie

Get it from Sephora for $34.

22. Tarte Lash Paint Mascara is equipped with an ultra-black, volumizing color so your eyelashes can be super dark and sultry. / Via @tartecosmetics

Promising Review: "This is the real MVP! I have naturally long lashes and this mascara makes them longer and actually holds the curl. I always try different kinds of high-end mascaras, and none have held up like this one." —emilyottt

Get it from Sephora for $23.


24. Colourpop Yin To My Yang Set debuts smoky fall colors cute-ass ghouls and goblins will be fucking jealous of.

It features six autumn metallic colors, and their first matte black shadow to keep things interesting!

Promising Review: "These shadows are amazing. They're super pigmented and blendable with a buttery soft feel." —Alysa S

Get the set of six from Colourpop for $22.

Reviews here have been edited for length and/or clarity.