We hope you love the products we recommend! Just so you know, BuzzFeed may collect a small share of sales from the links on this page.
1. Kat Von D Saint And Sinner Eyeshadow Palette has 24 pigmented shades inspired by stained glass in gothic cathedrals. Apply it on your lids whenever you're ready to vamp out.
2. Anna Sui Curl and Volume Mascara can have your eyelashes as long as bat wings, thanks to a scary good wax base that'll hold your curl in place!
3. Pat McGrath Labs Mothership Palette allows your dark soul to be creative with vivid colors that'll make you drool.
4. Colourpop Dr. M Ultra Matte Lip glides smoothly onto your lips with tons of color that dries absolutely kiss-proof. Score!
5. L.A. Girl Smokey Eyeshadow can give you the most alluring eyes this side of Halloweentown. All you need now is a skeleton taxi driver.
6. Makeup Forever Artist Liquid Matte Lipstick has a ridiculously long-lasting, saturated formula that won't dry out your lips during the witching hour.
7. BH Cosmetics Nude Rose Night Fall Palette is absolutely cruelty-free without sacrificing its smooth and vibrant application. Just because you're up to no good doesn't mean you don't care about animals!
8. Lime Crime Velvetines Liquid Matte Lipstick has brilliant dark shades that are completely touch-proof and transfer-proof, so when you go and bite into someone's neck no one will ever even know you were there.
9. Milk Makeup Tattoo Stamp creates absolutely edgy marks on your face so it'll look like you took the plunge and got *forever* tattoos.
10. Urban Decay Little Vices Lipstick Kit includes five delightfully sinful matte shades that'll have you looking as creepy as you dare to be!
11. Sonia Kashuk Showstoppers Eyeshadow Quad comes with a blend of sparkly, matte, and metallic shades to use to your (black) heart's desire!
12. Lorac Pirates of The Caribbean Eye Shadow Palette will have you looking like a real life Jack Sparrow even after Halloween is over.
13. Stila Stay All Day Liquid Eyeliner waterproof formula will stay in place, even if you cry tears of evil.
14. Morphe Pro Eyeshadow Palette has 35 different dark-ass colors you can mix for the perfect blend of ~mysterious~.
15. Milk Makeup Lip Color features a demi-matte formula for everyone who wants to look like Elvira, but still wants a little sheen!
16. Physician's Formula Cat Eye Liquid Eyeliner comes with a precision felt-tip applicator to make your wing truly fly.
17. Essie Nail Polish Neutrals have a bright, satin finish so your nails can match your black cat.
18. Kat Von D Sinner Lipstick Set is perfect for fulfilling your spooky aesthetic with a purple darker than wine.
19. ILNP Missed Calls Holographic Nail Polish has a mix of sparkly blacks and greens for just the right amount of creepy to match your scary costume.
20. Mac Cosmetics Le Disko Eyeshadow is rich in pigment and won't leave much fall out for a really bold-ass club eye.
21. Benefit Bolder And Bigger Brows Kit can deliver dramatic-ass eyebrows for that cool bar you've been dying to go to.
22. Tarte Lash Paint Mascara is equipped with an ultra-black, volumizing color so your eyelashes can be super dark and sultry.
23. Paint Glow Halloween Vamp Lipstick totally has the spirit of the undead with its velvety, creamy texture and ultra-black pigment.
24. Colourpop Yin To My Yang Set debuts smoky fall colors cute-ass ghouls and goblins will be fucking jealous of.
It's crazy just how SCARY you are, my goodness.
Reviews here have been edited for length and/or clarity.