Skip To Content

    36 Stylish Things For Anyone Who Wants To Pretend They're In A Hallmark Movie

    You'll find yourself falling in love with these items faster than a Hallmark heroine does for their hometown arch nemesis.

    We hope you love the products we recommend! All of them were independently selected by our editors. Just so you know, BuzzFeed may collect a share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page if you decide to shop from them. Oh, and FYI — prices are accurate and items in stock as of time of publication.

    Unless otherwise specified, all sizes in this post are listed in women's.

    1. Fuzzy earmuffs the main character always seems to be wearing while they walk through their thoroughly decorated small town with a hot chocolate in hand.

    a reviewer in pink fuzzy earmuffs
    amazon.com

    Promising review: "So cozy and comfortable!! They’re exceptionally soft, and they fold up for easy storage! I love them so much. Highly recommend!!" —MS

    Get them from Amazon for $12.95 (available in five colors).

    2. A Sherpa sweater, soft and stylish so you can be as comfy as possible when you win over that forever-grumpy rival bakery owner with your treasured pumpkin pie recipe.

    a reviewer in the sweater in light gray
    amazon.com

    Promising review: "I love this sweater so much that I purchased the gray and pink colors! I will be purchasing every color in this sweater. They’re amazing and I find any excuse to wear them. The sweater is baggy for the days you’re not feeling 100 or it looks super cute partially tucked into your jeans. 100% comfortable and if comfortable is your style, this is YOUR sweater!" —Alicia

    Get it from Amazon for $27.73+ (available in sizes S–2XL and 18 colors).

    3. Square-toe Chelsea boots, because who better to rock white shoes in winter than someone channeling their inner Hallmark heroine?

    the chelsea boots in an off white color with a strechy black side panel
    Everlane

    Promising review: "This is my second pair. I bought a pair of black and love them so much I decided to get another color. They are very comfortable to walk in, no rubbing anywhere, and no need to break them in. I ordered a half size bigger to have more room for thicker socks. The bottom is hard if you are on your feet all day, so the half size up also allows me to put in a soft insole. Beautiful design and color, works with all kinds of pants and dresses/skirts." —irenehy

    Get them from Everlane for $195 (available in sizes 5–11 and three colors).

    4. A drapey flannel so soft and cozy, you'll barely realize you're breaking a sweat in front of the person you've been majorly crushing on while helping them decorate their family's tree.

    a model in a light blue and white flannel shirt
    Abercrombie & FItch

    Get it from Abercrombie & Fitch for $59 (available in sizes 2XS–2XL).

    5. A chunky turtleneck, because even if you already own a plethora of sweaters you're not going to be able to resist adding this snuggly beauty into your collection. I mean, what else would a Hallmark movie star stock up on?

    reviewer wearing the top with jeans and a white crossbody bag
    reviewer wearing the white sweater with blue jeans

    Promising review: "I love this sweater. The price point is great. Super cozy and is perfect for the fall/winter season. This sweater would look perfect with a pair of distressed jeans and a cute fedora hat." —Tracy Fletcher

    Get it from Amazon for $19.99+ (available in sizes XS–XL and in eight colors).

    6. Steve Madden ankle boots you'll want to declare your love for in a spectacle in front of the whole town thanks to their bedazzled accents and how comfortable they are.

    model wearing the chunky black boots with jewels around the ankle
    Steve Madden / Via instagram.com

    Promising review: "I absolutely love these boots. They are so comfortable. I fell in love when I walked into my hair salon and three stylists were all wearing them. They praised the longevity of standing and no fatigue. I have since worn them while walking all over the city in great comfort and warmth all while being super cute." —Laura A.

    Get them from Amazon for $116.95+ (available in sizes 5–13, wide, and in seven colors and styles). 

    Psst: This item is included in Prime Wardrobe, so you can give it a trial run if you're a member!

    7. An oversized knitted sweater vest to wear on its own or pair with a turtleneck for the ultimate addition to your fall wardrobe. Keep giving us fashionable-bookshop-owner-in-a-romance-novel viiiibes!

    amazon.com, amazon.com

    Promising review: "Love this! Well worth the price! I ordered a medium so that it wouldn’t be too oversized and look awkward. And it fits perfect!! I paired it with a white turtleneck underneath, but the options are limitless here. Was surprised at the quality of this item...it’s very soft and thick. Which wasn’t what I expected at all. My only real complaint is the price of the item. However, this item is very trendy, so I understand. Would definitely, and might, buy again very soon!" —Amazon Customer

    Get it from Amazon for $29.99+ (available in sizes S–L and 14 styles).

    8. Spanx faux-leather leggings you can wear to show all of the locals how edgy and stylish you are now that you live in the Big City.

    a model in the faux leather leggings
    Spanx / Via instagram.com

    I splurged on these two years ago. I don't know why I waited so long! They're super soft on the inside, edgy on the outside, and just freakin' fabulous. If I venture to any family gatherings this holiday season you better believe you'll find me in these bad boys. I love pairing them with an oversized sweater for a look that's stylish but still cozy.

    Get them from Nordstrom, Spanx, or Amazon for $98+ (available in sizes XS–3X).

    9. A pink sweater you'll already be able to picture yourself curling up in after spending the day plotting how to save your family's coffee shop from being sold to a big business.

    a model in a light pink sweater with oversized sleeves
    Who What Wear Collection

    This sweater is fabulous not only for the way it looks but because it was also made of existing materials! No new fabric went into the design process, which is super cool IMO.

    Get it from Who What Wear Collection for $135 (available in sizes XS–2XL and two colors).

    10. A chic peacoat that'll show all of those old townies you're a city girl with big dreams who swears they're only home to visit for the holidays and would *never* be caught dead living there full-time again.

    a model in a warm brown peacoat
    Madewell

    Promising review: "For two years I have been in search of the perfectly oversized, wool coat. I cannot tell you how many I purchased, and returned! This coat is exactly what I was looking for. It is just the right fit. I purchased the medium and I have enough room to wear a sweater underneath. It is also not too long (I am 5-foot-4). I also love the rich brown color with the accent of charcoal gray under the lapel. It is a must-have!" —Aggie248

    Get it from Madewell for $298 (available in sizes 2XS–XL).

    11. A oversized open-front sweater, perfect for throwing on before heading out to bake holiday cookies with the kids of the man you just might happen to be falling in love with.

    a model in an oversized green cardigan
    American Eagle

    Promising review: "I love the oversized fit. Looks so cute on and you can wear it with multiple items of clothing! Also it's super soft." —Sara

    Get it from American Eagle for $44.96 (originally $55.95; available in sizes 2XS–2XL and four colors).

    12. A cardigan sweater dress that'll let the whole world know you *are* The Main Character. Added bonus? You can also wear it unbuttoned as a super-cozy, extra-long cardi.

    Model is wearing a burnt orange cardigan dress and tan boots
    Eloquii

    Added bonus? New customers get 50% off one item + 40% off everything else you buy with that one item through December!

    Promising review: "I have NEVER worn it as a dress...I can. However, it's the perfect piece to other outfits as a sweater. This season has pockets! 😍 Perfect!" —Chanera H.

    Get it from Eloquii for $99.95 (available in sizes 14–28 and three colors).

    13. A snuggly sweater coat you'll be able to perfectly curl up in a ball inside while wallowing over which life you want to live: one in the big city or one on the family farm.

    an open front cardigan in blue with a red and green pattern
    ModCloth

    Get it from ModCloth for $89 (available in sizes XS–XL and 1X–4X).

    14. A bracelet featuring the handwriting of the person you love most — could be the person who taught you how to bake your prized cookies, your grandma who urged you to keep the family business alive, Dolly Parton (the queen of Christmas), whoever!

    a model showing a strip of hand writing and the bracelet of it
    CaitlynMinimalist / Etsy

    All you need is a copy of your favorite person's handwriting to have this one-of-a-kind accessory made. This bracelet has the potential to be either really sweet or very funny — your choice. Caitlyn Minimalist is an Asian woman-owned small business run out of Los Angeles that makes tons of stunning jewelry. 

    Promising review: "Perfect and exactly as I hoped it would be! Lightweight yet sturdy, and built rounded to sit nicely on the outside or inside of your wrist." —Kimberly Hall

    Get it from CaitlynMinimalist on Etsy for $27.75+ (originally $35; available in sizes 5.5–9.6 inches and in three styles).

    15. An oversized shacket (shirt and jacket) you'll praise yourself for buying when you find yourself heading on a first date with someone your haven't seen since high school but happened to run into at the market while picking up groceries for your mom.

    Ali Faccenda wearing shacket in mirror selfie
    Ali Faccenda / BuzzFeed

    BuzzFeed writer Ali Faccenda has this jacket and is a big fan! She said:

    "I have this jacket and I'm OBSESSED. I love to wear work from home outfits that are functional and cozy but also look trendy for meeting calls. This fits the bill to a tee and is perfect layered over a classic long sleeve. It's oversized so if you want it more fitted I'd suggest going down a size."

    Get it from Amazon for $69.90 (available in sizes 2XS–2XL, 2X–3X, and three colors).

    Psst: This item is included in Prime Wardrobe so you can give it a trial run if you're a member!

    16. Cozy handmade mittens, so instead of wearing your heart on your sleeve like *so* many of the leads in Hallmark films you can show 'em off while you sip on a festive drink during a tree lighting.

    Ornute / Etsy

    Ornute is a small business based in Minneapolis, Minnesota, that sells cozy handmade fashion accessories and home decor.

    Promising review: "These were so well made! My daughter needed mittens that were warm during the cold walks on campus. These made me think of the mittens my grandma used to make me every year. Thank you!" —kate405

    Get it from Ornute on Etsy for $45.99 (available in 27 colors).

    17. A chic sweater starring an asymmetrical hem long enough to cover your booty so your lover's royal family won't make snide comments behind your back.

    Amazon, amazon.com

    Promising review: "Ordered a small in the white version of this sweater and holy cow! I intend to buy this in black as well, so impressed. This sweater is incredibly soft and stretchy and comfortable. It does run slightly large in my opinion, however, I wouldn't order a size down. This has been washed several times since I ordered it and I am impressed with how it's held up. 10/10 would recommend to a friend! Great value for the money spent." —Elizabeth

    Get it from Amazon for $26.99+ (available in sizes S–XL and 27 styles).

    Psst: This item is included in Prime Wardrobe, so you can give it a trial run if you're a member!

    18. A reversible vest from FP Movement that'll prove once again that you are a professional who is ready for anything that comes your way — even the cold weather.

    a model in a sherpa vest
    Free People Movement

    Get it from Free People for $88 (available in sizes XS–XL).

    19. A casual one-shouldered number to help you show off a lil' skin when heading to the town's annual Christmas tree–lighting ceremony.

    Amazon

    Promising review: "Absolutely love this item! It's exactly like the picture and fits exactly how I expected. It's nice and loose fitting around the top and is snug around the bottom, around the hips." —Jadd_0424

    Get it from Amazon for $10.99+ (available in sizes S–2XL and six colors).

    20. Tights adorned with golden snowflakes you'll likely somehow find yourself wearing on the exact same evening you confess your love to the person you just reconnected with less than a week ago.

    black tights with gold snowflakes on them
    Virivee

    Virivee is a small business that sells unique tights for adults and children.

    Get it from Virivee on Etsy for $40 (available in sizes 1–8).

    21. A blanket scarf that'll keep you nice 'n' warm when you're walking home in snow flurries alongside the handsome businessman who should be your nemesis but you somehow found yourself at a romantic dinner with.

    Heather Braga / BuzzFeed, amazon.com

    I have one of these scarves and love wrapping it around myself on cold days for an extra layer of warmth *and* an added touch of style. They usually contain a whole bunch of colors in it so a single scarf coordinates nicely with an array of my outfits.

    Promising review: "This is a lot nicer than I thought it would be: It's really really soft and, because it's so big, it's warm, too, if you wrap it around your neck a few times. It's also really versatile: The first time I wore it I ended up using it as a blanket. I wear it nearly every day and have gotten a lot of compliments on it. I might get another one (or two). Love this thing." —madison

    Get it from Amazon for $13.99+ (available in 40 styles).

    22. A pair of casual cotton linen overalls you won't mind getting flour all over when putting in overtime hours baking the *perfect* sugar cookies for the annual competition you've been trying to win for years and years.

    amazon.com, amazon.com

    Promising review: "I just wanted these for kicking around in the garden and they have worked great for that...so I own three pairs now. They're lightweight and good for warmer days." —C. Zittel

    Get them from Amazon for $15.99+ (available in sizes S–3XL and four colors).

    23. Nutcracker earrings that'll go nicely with any outfit you pick out for the opening night of the ballet you've been directing for the local kiddos.

    a model with a nutcracker earring on
    BaubleBar

    Get them from BaubleBar for $44.

    24. A highly rated down jacket with a lining so cozy it'll definitely keep you snug as a bug when you head down a snow covered hill in a picture perfect sled as you try to ignore the fast-developing feelings you have for your boss/old high school beau/the local coffee shop owner/etc.

    buzzfeed editor maitland quitmeyer in the green coat
    BuzzFeed / Maitland Quitmeyer

    I can confirm that *many* of us on the BuzzFeed Shopping team own and love this coat!

    Promising review: "SO WARM. So stylish! I am so in love with this coat. It seems very well put together and heavy and sturdy. I am usually a size L/XL in everything and the large fits perfectly with the zippers up on the sides. It gets a bit narrow around the hips but it's adjustable so it's fine! Absolutely love this coat ❤️" —Lauren

    Get it from Amazon for $159.99+ (available in sizes 2XS–5X and 10 styles).

    25. An elegant sweater you'll feel like a Christmas angel granted you with thanks to its lantern sleeves and various special detailing.

    Amazon, amazon.com

    Promising review: "My new favorite sweater. Incredibly soft. Super-cute design. Love the sleeve detail. I received so many compliments on this sweater. Fits exactly as expected." —Triple Blessed

    Get it from Amazon for $18.99+ (available in sizes 4–16 and 10 colors).

    26. A Levi's denim jacket lined with Sherpa because, friends, Jack Frost is just getting started! Can't you picture Lacey Chabert strolling through a town lit by twinkle lights while wearing this beauty?

    amazon.com, amazon.com

    Promising review: "This jacket is amazing. It is so comfortable and looks cute with every outfit! The Sherpa lining is on the front and back torso plus the neck, and the sleeves have a different soft lining. Easy, comfortable, and cute!" —Eileen Eisen-Cohen

    Get it from Amazon for $72.93+ (available in sizes XS–4X and in seven colors).

    Psst: This item is included in Prime Wardrobe, so you can give it a trial run if you're a member!

    27. A chiffon blouse — this elegant lil' number is likely as close as you're going to get to being the actual romantic lead in a Hallmark movie this winter. I respect the attempt and think you're gonna look divine in this top!

    amazon.com, amazon.com

    Promising review: "This is a really great item. It’s a very nice material, and the print is vibrant. It’s not very long so if you’re tall, make sure you’ll want to tuck it into something high waisted. The sleeves are just the tiiiiiniest bit short on me, but as I said, I’m super tall so I’m used to it. I definitely recommend this top!" —Jessica

    Get it from Amazon for $22.99+ (available in sizes XS–2XL and 20 colors).

    28. A Sorel heeled rain boot — the lead of a Hallmark Christmas movie would never let the weather rain on their parade! Be like Danica McKellar and say goodbye to your stiff, clunky rain boots and embrace these chic ones instead.

    model wearing the chunky heeled black boots
    Sorel

    Get them from Amazon for $159.95 (available in sizes 5–12 and four colors) or from Sorel for $160 (available in sizes 5–12 and four colors). 

    29. Or ankle booties with delicate details that'll surely ~ruffle~ some feathers when you strut into the town meeting armed with new ideas to amp up the holiday celebrations.

    a reviewer holding the tan bootie with a ruffled back
    amazon.com

    Promising review: "I get compliments on these every time I wear them! They are soo cute with jeans, leggings, and dresses. Soft black material, true to size, and wear very well. I didn't know what would arrive at such an inexpensive price. They are quality!" —Stephanie

    Get them from Amazon for $32.98+ (available in sizes 5–11 and two styles).

    30. A sweatshirt adorned with Christmas trees to pay tribute to the farm you've grown up on and will fight forever to keep running — it's all about the holiday spirit, obviously!

    a grey sweatshirt with four different christmas trees on it
    Up2ournecksinfabric / Etsy

    Up2ournecksinfabric is a small business based out of East Providence, Rhode Island, that sells custom shirts and other apparel.

    Get it from Up2ournecksinfabric on Etsy for $25.90+ (available in sizes S–2XL).

    31. A plaid blazer, guaranteed to make the presentation you've put together to change your boss's mind about turning the local family bed and breakfast into a hotel chain that much more convincing.

    a model in a white and blue plaid blazer
    Target

    Promising review: "This blazer is fabulous. Worth the price. Very well made. Fits large. I’m 5-foot-9 and large was roomy, which is what I wanted. Love it!!" —Mary H

    Get it from Target for $34.99 (available in sizes XS–2XL).

    32. Ankle booties, a must-have if you want to look just like one of the characters who has spent their whole life helping their parents keep the family farm running.

    amazon.com, Amazon

    Promising review: "I have been wearing them constantly with the snow and ice. They have good traction. They aren't as warm as a leather shoe would be, but I can get from my car to wherever I'm going without freezing. They are super cute with skinny jeans or leggings. Since I am on a budget the price was great and so far I am very pleased with how they are holding up. I ordered the black and they go with everything." —Styleshopper

    Get it from Amazon for $17.74+ (available in sizes 5.5–11 and two styles).

    33. A beanie with a faux-fur pom to keep your head warm while you're caroling from door to door — you'll want to look wintry cute just in case you run into your soulmate.

    amazon.com, amazon.com

    Promising review: "I'm so happy with my pom beanie! It's so cute and literally goes with everything I'm wearing this season! It's also thick and will definitely keep my head warm! I love that the pom is also removable. I still can't get over that this hat is less that $15. I will purchase this beanie again in more colors!" —samantha

    Get it from Amazon for $14.99 (available in 32 styles).

    34. Pajamas featuring a button-down top with a collar and soft pants — if you're gonna spend the night crying over a lost love you're going to want to look fabulous when they inevitably show up at the door of your family's home on Christmas morning begging you to take them back.

    a reviewer in the pajamas in black with white trim
    amazon.com

    Promising review: "One of the best PJs I've owned. Was a bit skeptical to buy at first as I wasn't sure how the fit was going to be. But I read all the reviews and followed my gut to get my true size. So glad I did! They're also perfect for those cold nights at home, and I also don't sweat at night, which is a HUGE plus for me." —Keeks Francisco

    Get them from Amazon for $29.99+ (available in sizes XS–2XL and 51 styles).

    35. A fabulous velvet off-the-shoulder gown you'd obviously already have hanging in the back of your closet, just waiting for the moment you fall in love with a real-life prince and need the perfect outfit to impress the queen (his grandmother) at a holiday ball.

    a model in an off the shoulder burgundy velvet gown
    Windsor

    Get it from Windsor for $79.90 (available in sizes 1–9 and 13).

    36. And a sparkling beauty I'm honestly feeling myself getting a bit choked up over. I mean, what Hallmark romance holiday flick doesn't end with a stunning ring and engagement???

    a model with the thin diamond band on it featuring two small round stones and one middle stone
    a thin gold band on it featuring diamonds along it, two small round stones and one middle stone
    Catbird

    Each piece of Catbird jewelry is made in their Brooklyn studio!

    Get it from Catbird for $4,700 (available in sizes 3.4–12 and four metals).

    Now that I know your wardrobe is ready, you can find me watching Hallmark Christmas movies for the foreseeable future.

    The Hallmark Channel

    Some reviews have been edited for length and/or clarity.

    Looking for the perfect gift for any occasion? Check out all of BuzzFeed’s gift guides!

    illustrated gift guide banner
    BuzzFeed