Browse links
US residents can opt out of "sales" of personal data.
We hope you love our recommendations! Some may have been sent as samples, but all were independently selected by our editors. Just FYI, BuzzFeed and its publishing partners may collect a share of sales and/or other compensation from the links on this page.
Darkness is my only friend.
Promising review: "I absolutely love this lipstick. It's not greasy like most black lipsticks out there and has a smooth, matte finish. It's is also highly pigmented so a little goes a long way." —Emily Rose
Get it from Amazon for $13.90.
Promising review: "Great artwork and easy to install. Not a blackout curtain by any means, I am waiting on liners to help block the sunlight more. Other than that they are great and worth the price." —pa 1911 fan
Get them from Amazon for $64.95 (five sizes).
Get it from Pure Gold Slimes on Etsy for $1.
Get it from Amazon for $6.69.
Get it from Amazon for $15.95.
Get them from Amazon for $19.99 (three colors).
Get it from Think Geek for $12.99.
Get it from Manon the Moon Mystics on Etsy for $6.68 (13 colors).
Promising review: "Bought it for my son's 11th birthday. I used white cake mix and filled just the skeleton, put a drop of red food coloring in the eyes, and then filled the rest of it with green cake mix. When it was ready, it looked like a skeleton with glowing red eyes rising out of a swamp. The kids didn't even want me to frost it. Best cake pan ever. Make sure to spray it with non-stick very well." —Mary Popio
Get it from Amazon for $49.99.
Get it from Flavnt for $40 (sizes S–3X).
Get it from The Dark Exact on Etsy for $17.95.
What you get: handmade candles, spells from the Book of Shadows, smudge, herbs, ritual tools, sacred salts, and much more!
Promising review: "While I knew I would love a lot of the items included after looking at past boxes, I was initially suspicious of the price for this. But I just opened my fifth box and EVERY MONTH I am so excited about when this shipment comes. I am constantly posting on IG about the items, sharing with my friends, etc. The value is phenomenal if you are used to shopping in metaphysical stores (usually not cheap), the themes are creative, the items are thoughtful. CANNOT RECOMMEND ENOUGH — if you're on the edge, just do it. It will get you started if you're new to witchcraft, or it will enhance your current practice if you're a seasoned witch." —Niki
Get it from Cratejoy for $45 a month.
Categories include Frienemies, Technology and Science, Locations, Rick and the Family, History and Events, and a Wubalubadubdub Wild Card.
Get it from Think Geek for $19.99.
Get it from Bark Shop for $10.
Set includes: one teapot, one trivet, and two cups.
Promising review: "I took a risk on this tea pot. I mean, not the kind of risk that anyone will write a movie about, but a risk nonetheless — I like quality and have zero patience for anything cheap. The risk was that this tea pot was on the inexpensive side, so it could have ended up in a garage sale. Instead, it's perfect. The removable steel infusing basket is a really cool touch that preserves the rustic aesthetic, without the rustic pain in the ass. Love it." —J. Ryan Jones
Get it from Amazon for $13.99.
Get it from Charamath's Art Corner on Etsy for $5+ (three sizes).
Promising review: "I'm a huge fan of Dr. Martens. I have a lot of them and wear them all the time. This is a very cute boot; I bought it for the gorgeous rose embroidery and because I was looking for a taller boot. I wear women's US size 11, medium width, and Docs fit true to size for me. My feet are slightly narrow with a high arch. Seems like the newer Docs these days have better insoles and arch support." —NW Dryad
Get them from Amazon for $109.93+ (sizes 4–11).
Get it from Jane Austen And Company on Etsy for $13.
Get it from Dark Ideals on Etsy for $5.50+ (choose from 15 phrases and 13 colors)
Get it from Valfre for $32.
Promising review: "Some people may not like the title, but it makes me laugh every time I add to the book. It not only stores the information, but will help you remember additional things to add with space for notes. For those of us who really don’t know where to begin or what to include, this was a great beginning, and is making the process much more entertaining! Even if you store all your info online, this is much more personal." —LR
Get it from Amazon for $13.33, or find a copy at your local library.
Get it from Valfre for $64 (XS–XXL).
Get them from Wildfang for $8.
Promising review: "This dress is a winner! I was afraid it would be too small, or unflattering like some of the other retro dresses (claiming to be plus size) on Amazon but the fit is perfect. 3X — 22/24: it lifts the bust, defines the waist and flares, even the arms don’t tug. There’s no liner, but the fabric is thick enough that I don’t feel it’s revealing anything. I’m very satisfied with this buy, and it’s $25 w/ free returns! Worth checking out." —Amazon Customer
Get it from Amazon for $15.99+ (nine colors, sizes S–4X).
Some reviews have been edited for length and clarity.