Skip To Content

    13 Movies That Basically Spat On The Book They Were Based On And 14 That Are Like A Love Letter To The Book

    Note to filmmakers: Maybe don't give the movie an entirely different ending from the book.

    1. Missed the mark: Percy Jackson and the Olympians: The Lightning Thief

    Percy holding a water trident in the film

    2. Spot on: Dune

    Paul and Jessica in the desert

    3. Missed the mark: My Sister's Keeper

    Anna and Kate sitting outside

    4. Spot on: The Lord of the Rings (fine, if I have to choose...The Return of the King)

    Sam and Frodo climbing

    5. Missed the mark: The Hobbit

    Bilbo looking at the ring

    6. Spot on: Twilight

    Edward behind Bella in the forest

    7. Missed the mark: Breaking Dawn (Parts 1 and 2)

    Edward and Bella looking shocked

    8. Spot on: Matilda

    Matilda and Ms Honey in the bushes

    9. Missed the mark: A Wrinkle in Time

    Mrs. Whatsit and Meg holding hands

    10. Spot on: The Princess Diaries

    Mia after her makeover

    11. Missed the mark: Eragon

    Eragon on the dragon

    12. Spot on: The Hunger Games: Catching Fire

    Katniss in the wedding dress Cinna made her with caesar onstage

    13. Missed the mark: The Giver

    Jonas and Fiona holding hands

    14. Spot on: A Series of Unfortunate Events (the TV series)

    Count Olaf

    15. Missed the mark: A Series of Unfortunate Events (the movie)

    Count Olaf clutching Violet and Klaus

    16. Spot on: Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban

    Hermione and Harry in the hospital wing using the time turner

    17. Missed the mark: Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince

    Harry helping Ron walk in the dormitories

    18. Spot on: Room

    Joy and Jack watching TV

    19. Missed the mark: Before I Fall

    Lindsay and Samantha lying in bed together smiling

    20. Spot on: To All the Boys I've Loved Before

    Lara Jean writing in a notebook

    21. Missed the mark: All the Bright Places

    Finch smiling at Violet in the woods

    22. Spot on: Holes

    Stanley and Zero shaking hands

    23. Missed the mark: The Lorax

    the characters playing cards on the grass

    24. Spot on: Crazy Rich Asians

    Rachel at the wedding

    25. Missed the mark: The Maze Runner: The Scorch Trials

    the kids from the glades staring at a table of food

    26. Spot on: Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants

    the four girls walking together

    27. And finally, missed the mark: The Golden Compass

    Lyra and Iorek Byrnison - the armored bear - in the film

    What do you think? Any that should definitely be on this list? Let me know in the comments!