back to top

It's Time To Talk About “Girl Next Door” By Saving Jane

Guys...I don't know why this has never been discussed at length, but if you like "You Belong With Me", by Taylor Swift...prepare for some tea.

Posted on

We all know 2009 Certified Bop™ "You Belong With Me", by Taylor Swift.

Big Machine Records / Via

And maybe less people know another Certified Bop™ "Girl Next Door" by Saving Jane, released 4 years earlier in 2005.

Which is a tragedy in my humble opinion.
Universal Records / Via

Which is a tragedy in my humble opinion.

One day, I was listening to my throwbacks playlist on Spotify, as you do, and "Girl Next Door" came up on shuffle. This song was my jam back when I was 10, so I didn't think too much of me knowing all the words....until I realized I was singing the WRONG WORDS.

My playlist's name is "the way way back", in case you were curious. Follow it.

To my surprise, I had subconsciously began singing "You Belong With Me". When I realized this, I was #shook, like Taylor seen here.

OkChicas / Via

Here's the "You Belong With Me" chorus.

Big Machine Records / Via

And now, here's the "Girl Next Door" chorus.

Universal Records / Via

So, as you can see, they both reference the "other girl" being a cheerleader which is kinda specific, but not that bad. HOWEVER, when you examine music videos, you'll see that the similarities do not end there.

Big Machine Records / Via

While in the lyrics, Taylor never explicitly states that she's in the marching band, her music video makes it quite clear that she is. / Via

Which is a DIRECT PARALLEL to "She is the prom queen, I'm in the marching band".

And speaking of music videos, here's the only link I could find to the "Girl Next Door" music video which...bears discussion outside of the post anyway, but there are a couple of points I'd like to make.

View this video on YouTube / Via

First, the two videos are basically the exact same. One girl is popular, one girl is an "adorkable loser who wears glasses". I actually thought for awhile that the Saving Jane music video used the same idea of having the same actress play both girls, but I honestly can't tell with the low quality of this video.

Big Machine Records / Via

They also both have their main dramatic scene at the prom, where the adorkable loser finally gets to be the prom queen and stick it to this other girl (who, in the Taylor Swift video, basically was right about her boyfriend having feelings for another girl and her main flaw was being a cheerleader, so, take that as you will).

Big Machine Records / Via

And honestly, there are probably a lot of other similarities that I didn't find because looking at the low-res music video gives me a headache so ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

And I am NOT the only one who thinks this!!!! The comments on Saving Jane's music video are all essentially this:

I have been thinking about this since September, and I really needed an outlet, so thank you & goodnight.

why have we never discussed that you belong with me is a rip off of 2000s classic girl next door by saving jane



Get it trending folks.
Saving Jane / Via

Get it trending folks.

This post was created by a member of BuzzFeed Community, where anyone can post awesome lists and creations. Learn more or post your buzz!