1.
When Sarah Fuller's "gay" neighbors kidnapped her.
2.
When this lady took off all her clothes and gouged out her own eye.
3.
When Emma kills her own mother in front of Jacob, and he's kind of turned on by it.
4.
When the cult's safe house was discovered, and this crazy follower in a Poe mask jumped out.
5.
When masked Poe took to the streets and lit this nice journalist on fire.
6.
When it was revealed that once upon a time, Joe and Ryan had an epic bromance.
7.
When Paul flirts with Megan, chokes her while they make out, and is forced to kidnap her.
8.
When Paul outs Jacob as never having killed anyone.
9.
When Emma, Paul and Jacob made their serial love legit.
10.
When Joe manipulates his lawyer into unintentionally joining his cult.
11.
When Agent Parker flashed back to her cult days.
12.
When Joe said this...
13.
When this local cop turned out to be part of Joe's cult!
14.
When Claire discovered that a man (her "follower") has been secretly watching her every move for two years.
15.
When Emma ditched her two boyfriends and ran off with Joey.
16.
And when this epic moment happened*.
