1. Amanda Beckett — Jennifer Love Hewitt
Since the film: Jennifer Love Hewitt has become a mother of two! She gave birth to her second child just last year.
Best quote: "That is enough! God, I haven't even been single for like five minutes and already you think that I am just gonna strip off my clothes and do you right here."
2. Preston Meyers — Ethan Embry
Since the film: In 2006 Ethan Embry and his then-wife were robbed at gunpoint outside his home. Thankfully no one was injured.
Best quote: "I've always felt there was this unspoken connection between us...ever since the first time I saw you when you were holding my favorite Pop-Tart."
3. Mike Dexter — Peter Facinelli
Since the film: Peter Facinelli appeared in countless films and TV shows, including his role as Dr. Carlisle Cullen in the Twilight series.
Best quote: "I'll kick everyone's ass in this room!"
4. Kenny Fisher — Seth Green
Since the film: Seth Green has become the king of the Adult Swim network. He's the voice of Chris Griffin on Family Guy and the co-creator, co-producer, director, and writer for Robot Chicken.
Best quote: "I did not write 'Denise Fleming is a tampon' on your locker."
5. Denise Fleming — Lauren Ambrose
Since the film: Lauren Ambrose won two Screen Actors Guild Awards for her work on Six Feet Under.
Best quote: "I do think there's such a thing as fate. It just works in really fucked-up ways sometimes."
6. William Lichter — Charlie Korsmo
Since the film: Charlie Korsmo is a successful lawyer and an assistant professor of law at Case Western Reserve University. His scholarship has been cited by the New York Times, and President Obama appointed him to the Board of Trustees of the Barry Goldwater Scholarship and Excellence in Education Foundation.
Best quote: "Nobody drink the beer — the beer has gone bad!"
7. Watermelon Guy — Jason Segel
Since the film: Jason Segel has starred in several films and the TV series How I Met Your Mother. He also wrote and starred in the 2011 film The Muppets.
Best Quote: "Rooby Rooby Roo!"
8. Jock #2 — Sean Patrick Thomas
Since the film: Sean Patrick Thomas went on to co-star in the 2001 dance film Save the Last Dance with fellow '90s babe Julia Stiles. More recently he played Terry on American Horror Story: Asylum.
Best quote: "Maybe we should break up with our girlfriends too."
9. The Angel — Jenna Elfman
Since the film: Jenna Elfman became a Scientologist.
Best quote: "Oh, I'm the weird one? You're the one calling Barry Manilow from a phone booth at 2 a.m."
10. Trip McNeely — Jerry O'Connell
Since the film: Jerry O'Connell played Mariah Carey's cheating boyfriend in the music video for "Heartbreaker."
Best quote: "That's the best advice I can give you. Oh, that and...bring rubber flip-flops to the shower. I got warts all over my feet."
11. Yearbook Girl — Melissa Joan Hart
Since the film: Melissa Joan Hart starred in the sitcom Melissa & Joey with '90s heartthrob Joey Lawrence.
Best quote: "These are memories frozen in time, people!"
12. Girlfriend #1 — Jaime Pressly
Since the film: Jaime Pressly won an Emmy, a Golden Globe, and a Screen Actors Guild Award for her role of Joy on My Name Is Earl.
Best quote: "Who does he think he is? Brad Pitt?"
13. Lead Singer of Lovebürger — Breckin Meyer
Since the film: Breckin Meyer married the co-writer/co-director of Can't Hardly Wait and together they have two kids. Most recently he starred in the TV show Franklin & Bash.
Best quote: "This is our first show ever. Don't screw it up."
14. Drummer for Lovebürger — Donald Faison
Since the film: Donald Faison became most known for his role of Turk on the TV show Scrubs and for his IRL best friendship with actor Zach Braff.
Best quote: "This hat is not stupid! This hat is cool."
15. Cousin Ron — Erik Palladino
Since the film: Erik Palladino has appeared in 20 feature films and is best known for his role on the TV show ER.
Best quote: [After trying to make out with his cousin Amanda] "Shit. You're not gonna tell my parents about this, are you?!"
16. Hippie Guy — Eric Balfour
Since the film: Eric Balfour is the lead singer of the band Born as Ghosts, and briefly played Lauren Ambrose's character's boyfriend on Six Feet Under. He recently married fashion designer Erin Chiamulon; the two will celebrate their one-year anniversary this May.
Best quote: [Licks weed brownie off of Denise's face] "Don't wanna waste this stuff!"
17. Klepto Kid — Chris Owen
Since the film: Chris Owen is best known for his role as The Sherminator in the American Pie franchise. He's also appeared in the American Pie Presents spin-off series.
Best quote: [Casually steals a police car]