Skip To Content
    Posted on Aug 8, 2013

    How To Make Healthier Ice Cream Sandwiches

    With whole wheat oatmeal chocolate chip cookies (!).

    "This is the only item I've ever made that anyone asked for again. Because I found the cookie recipe on 101 Cookbooks, I've convinced myself it's healthy. I listen to old episodes of RadioLab or This American Life when making them; NPR goes well with a whole wheat, all-natural dessert. I replace the wheat germ in the recipe with more whole wheat flour. Not a problem at all.

    "It takes about 45 minutes for the cookies, then the only thing standing between them and my famous ice cream sandwiches is homemade vanilla ice cream. And the only thing standing between you and homemade vanilla ice cream is a Cuisinart ice cream maker. Obv the homemade part is totes optional, but use this machine once and you will never be impressed by homemade ice cream again — it is shockingly easy. Takes about three minutes of active time and 20 minutes of staying out of the kitchen because that machine is stupid loud." — Kate Lazarus, 30, lawyer, San Francisco, CA

    1. For the cookies you will need:

    Izy Hossack

    rolled oats (not instant)

    whole wheat flour

    baking soda

    baking powder

    fine grain sea salt

    unsalted butter

    natural cane sugar or light brown sugar

    firmly packed Muscovado or dark brown sugar

    large eggs

    vanilla extract

    semi-sweet chocolate bar

    Get the amounts and the full recipe at 101 Cookbooks.

    2. Line two baking sheets with parchment paper.

    Izy Hossack

    You can find parchment paper in the grocery store near the foil and plastic wrap.

    3. Combine the oats, flour, baking soda, baking powder, and salt.

    4. Make sure your butter is room temperature, then beat them together until they're light and fluffy.

    5. Add eggs one at a time and beat just to combine.

    6. Add the vanilla.

    7. Add the combined dry ingredients...

    8. ...then mix just until everything BARELY comes together. Don't overmix.

    9. Add the chopped chocolate chunks.

    10. Do your best not to eat too much of the cookie dough.

    11. Using a spoon or a small ice cream scoop, put cookie dough balls about 3 inches apart on the baking sheets.

    12. Bake them in a 350ºF oven for about 15 minutes.

    13. For the ice cream you will need:

    1 cup whole milk, well chilled

    3/4 cup granulated sugar

    2 cups heavy cream, well chilled

    1–2 teaspoons pure vanilla extract, to taste

    14. With a whisk or hand mixer on a low speed, combine the milk and sugar until the sugar dissolves.

    Izy Hossack

    This takes only a minute or two.

    15. Stir in the vanilla.

    16. Stir in the heavy cream.

    17. Pour the mixture through the ingredient spout into the freezer bowl of your ice cream maker.

    Izy Hossack

    Turn the machine on and let it go 25–30 minutes until the ice cream is thick. Then it needs to go in the freezer for about an hour — it's a little soft right out of the machine.

    18. FUN PART: Scoop ice cream onto cookie.

    19. Top with second cookie.

    20. Smush into sandwich.

    21. Repeat.


    Easy Homemade Vanilla Ice Cream

    Recipe courtesy of Cuisinart

    PREP TIME: 5 minutes

    TOTAL TIME: 30 minutes churning time plus 1 hour in the freezer

    Makes 10 1/2-cup servings


    1 cup whole milk, well chilled

    3/4 cup granulated sugar

    2 cups heavy cream, well chilled

    1–2 teaspoons pure vanilla extract, to taste


    In a medium bowl, use a hand mixer or a whisk to combine the milk and granulated sugar until the sugar is dissolved, about 1–2 minutes on low speed. Stir in the heavy cream and vanilla to taste. Turn machine on, pour mixture into freezer bowl through ingredient spout and let mix until thickened, about 25–30 minutes. Let the ice cream sit in the freezer for about an hour before you scoop it.

    If you've got a go-to recipe that should be featured on BuzzFeed Food, please send it to food editor Emily Fleischaker or share it in the comments. Check out previous go-to recipes here.