back to top
Shopping

Hundreds Of People Think This $1.50 Eyeliner Is As Good As Designer Brands

Less than $2, makes cat eyes easy, AND lasts all day?! I don't remember doing a good enough deed to deserve this.

Posted on

We hope you love the products we recommend! Just so you know, BuzzFeed may collect a share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page. Oh, and FYI — prices are accurate and items in stock as of time of publication.

Winged eyeliner: we've all suffered an, um, emotional morning or two from them. Even if I wasn't reduced to tears nearly every time, there's still a chance I'd wind up with raccoon eyes.

World of Wonder Productions

^^ Me talking to my shaky hands as I attempt a straight line.

So when I found this Nykkola waterproof eyeliner ($1.46 on Amazon) that already has hundreds of positive reviews, I definitely did a double take. No more smudged wings...for less than $2? Could it be?!

Promising review: "For $3, this liquid liner is absolutely amazing (and someone who is in love with Urban Decay eyeliner is speaking). I got this for daily wear. I tested it on the web of my hand for wear. It didn't crack not a bit. I tried wiping it off. *Cheap stuff never works?* BOY WAS I WRONG! This stuff sticks! Dare I say better then my favorite Urban Decay liner. This is an absolute steal. As a single mother? Worth it. Probably going to buy more. The applicator doesn't dry out before I get my wings right and it's soft doesn't irritate my extremely sensitive skin. It's amazing. Buy it. One for you, your best friend, ya moms, granny, cousin. It's amazing." —Kaitlyn reynolds
amazon.com

Promising review: "For $3, this liquid liner is absolutely amazing (and someone who is in love with Urban Decay eyeliner is speaking). I got this for daily wear. I tested it on the web of my hand for wear. It didn't crack not a bit. I tried wiping it off. *Cheap stuff never works?* BOY WAS I WRONG! This stuff sticks! Dare I say better then my favorite Urban Decay liner. This is an absolute steal. As a single mother? Worth it. Probably going to buy more. The applicator doesn't dry out before I get my wings right and it's soft doesn't irritate my extremely sensitive skin. It's amazing. Buy it. One for you, your best friend, ya moms, granny, cousin. It's amazing." —Kaitlyn reynolds

Well grab the tissues, because it's true! It's precise, long-lasting, super opaque, and makes sharp cat eyes actually easy for us rookies. My mascara is definitely running, because I am CRYING rn.

Krasnoff Foster Productions

It even comes with a regular eyeliner pencil (that's attached to the cap)!

Not to mention it already has 814 five-star reviews — and some of the best darn selfies I've ever seen as proof!

amazon.com

Promising review: "I was pleasantly surprised with this product! I thought that any eyeliner this cheap wouldn't be a high quality eyeliner. Boy was I wrong! This lasts all day without chipping or fading and it glides on very easily! I'm definitely going to have to buy a new one. This is gorgeous and a wonderful product for the price! I recommend at least giving this a try! What can you lose!" —Princess A.

It lasts all👏 day 👏 thanks to its waterproof formula so it can keep the drama going as long as you need it to (I'm speaking about your look, of course).

Promising review: "This lasts ALL day. I work 10 hour shifts and it doesn't even smudge. If I go to sleep with it sometimes I wake up perfect and sometimes it cracks a bit. Also I put it over my eyelashes after using mascara and it works great for making my eyelashes longer, thicker and more of a dark black. It's super dark and that's what I love about it." —☆
amazon.com

Promising review: "This lasts ALL day. I work 10 hour shifts and it doesn't even smudge. If I go to sleep with it sometimes I wake up perfect and sometimes it cracks a bit. Also I put it over my eyelashes after using mascara and it works great for making my eyelashes longer, thicker and more of a dark black. It's super dark and that's what I love about it." —

Plus, the super precise tip gives you total control over your wing's ~aesthetics~! Long, short, angled, WHATEVER. The choice is yours.

Promising review: "If you're considering buying it just buy it now. I love dramatic eyeliner so I wanted an opaque liner that wouldn't be virtually see-through. I wear eyeliner everyday. I can't go without it and this is my favorite eyeliner. The price is amazing so that I can go ahead and stock up on a bunch. When removing this it won't smear everywhere." —Maya
amazon.com

Promising review: "If you're considering buying it just buy it now. I love dramatic eyeliner so I wanted an opaque liner that wouldn't be virtually see-through. I wear eyeliner everyday. I can't go without it and this is my favorite eyeliner. The price is amazing so that I can go ahead and stock up on a bunch. When removing this it won't smear everywhere." —Maya

Can you believe how intensely pigmented this is?! People are not READY for our new boldness.

Promising review: "Amazing! This product is affordable and works great! The brush is nice and the eyeliner is still intact at the end of the day. I have used the product for a year and a half now and I honestly recommend this to everyone I meet! It's really easy to use and dark. I'm in love!" —Jill
amazon.com

Promising review: "Amazing! This product is affordable and works great! The brush is nice and the eyeliner is still intact at the end of the day. I have used the product for a year and a half now and I honestly recommend this to everyone I meet! It's really easy to use and dark. I'm in love!" —Jill

For $2 I may have to order a freight-load just for myself. My old eyeliner was $20! That's TEN of these for the same quality!

amazon.com

Promising review: "I have been winged challenged forever. I love the look of a nice black cat eye, but the technique has always escaped me. This tool is amazing! The tip is firm so you have lots of control and the actual liner is a nice intense black that dries down matte. I quickly stocked up on more of these because I'm thinking holy grail." —Tiarra Reyes

Not to mention it has a nice, smooth application in case this whole experience wasn't satisfying enough. If only I could find wine for this cheap...

Promising review: "I love this eyeliner so much! It goes on smooth and dries fast! Not to mention it stays on for a long time. I would definitely recommend for the price!" —Hannah Hunter
amazon.com

Promising review: "I love this eyeliner so much! It goes on smooth and dries fast! Not to mention it stays on for a long time. I would definitely recommend for the price!" —Hannah Hunter

Get it from Amazon for $1.46.

And be sure to check out our top picks for the best liquid eyeliners (that we tried and tested ourselves) on BuzzFeed Reviews!

Now excuse me while I take out a small loan to live off of these.

3 Arts Entertainment

The reviews for this post have been edited for length and clarity.

Shopping for something specific? Check out BuzzFeed Reviews to find the best things for every budget!

BuzzFeed