Skip To Content

    23 Game-Changing Condiments You Can Buy Online

    Your taste buds can thank me later.

    We hope you love the products we recommend! All of them were independently selected by our editors. Just so you know, BuzzFeed may collect a share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page if you decide to shop from them. Oh, and FYI — prices are accurate and items in stock as of time of publication.

    1. A bottle of Bee's Knees Spicy Honey made with crushed chili peppers to add juuuust enough heat to your sweet, whether you're drizzling it on freezer pizza, dripping it over ice cream, sweetening a cocktail, or taking it to the face with a big ole hunk of cheese.

    Sur La Table

    Promising review: "It goes great on everything! From yogurt to ice-cream, chicken and tea! It's got a kick and bite! The best way to eat it is one spoonful at a time! So good!!" —Robin O.

    Get it from Sur La Table for $14.

    2. A jar of truffle ketchup that'll so dramatically elevate your fry and burger game with its savory depth that you'll be like, "Did a cuisine-loving Parisian rat sneak into my kitchen under a chef's hat and make this?"

    Stonewall Kitchen

    Get it from Stonewall Kitchen for $10.50.

    3. A gluten-free Mediterranean za'atar spread made with thyme, sesame seeds, and sumac for that perfect blend of nuttiness and zest to put on grilled meats and breads.

    World Market

    Promising review: "I buy this frequently. Makes delicious za'atar bread using pizza dough in true Lebanese cuisine." —World Market Customer

    Get it from World Market for $6.99.

    4. A creamy roasted garlic aioli made with the teensiest touch of mustard to add a little extra ~oomph~ to pretty much every genre of food on your dinner plate.

    Stonewall Kitchen

    I am currently in possession of a jar of this aioli, and here's a running list of things I have put it on: a burger, asparagus, a baked potato, a pork chop, a salad, a grilled cheese, and if I have some leftover on my plate without anything to dip it in, literal air. My blood is 90% garlic aioli at the moment.

    Get it from Stonewall Kitchen for $7.50.

    5. A peach amaretto jam with just a ~touch~ of that distinctive almond flavor to give the sweetness a nutty depth, perfect for nibbling with some cheese or topping on your oh-so-sophisticated ice cream sundae.

    Stonewall Kitchen

    Get it from Stonewall Kitchen for $7.95.

    6. A bacon, jalapeno, and mac and cheese sauce so versatile, you can spread it on noodles, meat, veggies, or just straight up use as a dipping sauce for chips.

    World Market

    Promising review: "Great product. My son loves jalapeno anything! He thought this was great stuff!" —World Market Customer

    Get it from World Market for $6.99.

    7. A jar of raspberry white fudge peanut butter spread you can slather all over everything from apples to toast to warm banana bread (11/10 would also incorporate this into a brownie situation, just saying).

    World Market

    Promising review: "Great taste. I love it! I am using it on sliced apples." —World Market Customer

    Get it from World Market for $5.99.

    8. A bottle of Hello Kitty soy sauce that yes, technically tastes just as delicious as any Kikkoman soy sauce, except "sheer ridiculous cuteness" def counts as an extra flavor.

    World Market

    Promising review: "I saw this cute little Hello Kitty soy sauce holder at a restaurant. I'm so glad I was able to find it at World Market! It's reusable!" —World Market Customer

    Get it from World Market for $4.99.

    9. A bottle of Weak Knees Gochujang Sriracha, which is basically what happens if a bottle of spicy sriracha and a tangy fermented gochujang paste had a baby and then turned it into liquid gold you could spread all over veggies, burgers, or even a spicy Bloody Mary.

    Sur La Table

    Promising review: "I have gone through three bottles of this item in the last two months. I use it on breakfast sandwiches, add it to any kind of bowl I'm making with veggies and grains, use it to dip chicken into for an extra spice, marinate pork tenderloin before cooking, and in all soups and stews for a deep chili flavor. Gouchujang, Korean style fermented chili paste, is what gives this hot sauce its special flavor which is savory, sweet, umami, and completely addictive!" —Alexandra B.

    Get it from Sur La Table for $9.95.

    10. A jar of bacon queso to add some savory smoky goodness when you warm it up and put it on nachos, baked potatoes, or even slathered on a homemade burger.

    Stonewall Kitchen

    Get it from Stonewall Kitchen for $7.50.

    11. A mini tabasco sauce set, because this is game time, y'all. One for the kitchen, one for the living room, one for your nightstand. Every meal is just a tabasco sauce emergency waiting to happen.

    World Market

    Promising review: "We keep this in our TV room for those times we don't feel like going (back) to kitchen and, as always, great taste!" —World Market Customer

    Get it from World Market for $4.99.

    12. A sampler of jams from the iconic NYC brunch spot Sarabeth's, with so many delicious options that "breakfast for dinner" will be on your menu for at least a week.

    Sur La Table

    Each set comes with a 4-ounce jar of plum cherry, orange apricot marmalade, strawberry raspberry, pineapple mango, mixed berry, and peach apricot.

    Promising review: "Sarabeth's Jam is known to be a delicious. I have purchased one of the flavors in the past. This sampler pack is a great way to taste all the award-winning flavors." —Lisa T.

    Get it from Sur La Table for $25.

    13. A bottle of Frank's RedHot, because yes, you likely have a bottle and a backup bottle on hand, but what about the backup to your backup?? Don't leave your fifth round of Crock-Pot buffalo chicken hanging like this.

    Target

    Get it from Target for $3.59.

    14. A tube of chipotle paste so you can have all the heat and earthiness of chipotle peppers in your stews, meats, and sammies without busting out a whole can of them.

    Sur La Table

    Promising review: "I have used this paste in the past and love the convenience of being able to use a tablespoon without opening a whole can of chipotle peppers. The tube it bought was quickly snatched up by my niece, so I am reordering another. This product has great flavor and is really nice for adding the flavor without feeling guilty about now using a whole can of peppers." —Rouvi

    Get it from Sur La Table for $7.

    15. A jar of peach salsa you'll want to tip over and dump all over any spring-themed dish, whether it's fish or chicken or a salad that could use some sweet zest 🍑.

    Stonewall Kitchen

    Pro-tip: Stonewall Kitchen recommends mixing it with cream cheese for a sweet spread on top of toast or crackers!

    Get it from Stonewall Kitchen for $7.50.

    16. A ghost pepper and blueberry hot sauce, because honestly, how can you read those words in the same phrase and not be desperate to know what that combo of heat and sweet tastes like?

    World Market

    Promising review: "Really tasty 😋 Used on my French Toast! I think it'd be good on ice cream too! I'll probably try using it to BBQ or smoked meat.. It was spicy still, but with sweetness still. Nothing overpowering. Just yummy 😋" —World Market Customer

    Get it from World Market for $5.99.

    17. A raspberry honey mustard dipping sauce with a tangy sweetness that pairs with all your salty snacks like pretzels, cheeses, and crackers — perfect for anyone who has a sweet tooth *and* a salt tooth (it me).

    Stonewall Kitchen

    Get it from Stonewall Kitchen for $6.95.

    18. A cherry vanilla fruit preserve spread designed to pair with cheese that you could also use to jazz up your morning yogurt, top on your ice cream, or spread on a baguette.

    World Market

    Promising review: "These preserves are excellent on crackers, cheese, pound cake. If you like cherries, you will probably love this!" —World Market Customer

    Get it from World Market for $5.99.

    19. A buttery buffalo aioli basically screaming to get put on just about everything you've got lined up to consume, whether it's carrots and celery or tater tots or (be still my heart) the BLT to end all BLTs.

    Stonewall Kitchen

    Get it from Stonewall Kitchen for $7.95.

    20. A bottle of creamy, tangy Yum Yum sauce for all your shrimp, steak, and fried rice dishes — or if you're feeling extra impatient to get your sauce on, straight up drizzled on veggies or mixed into a salad.

    Target

    Get it from Target for $4.99.

    21. A pack of Peg Leg Porker’s award-winning sauces from Nashville that comes with two bottles and a dry rub, so you can cook with the authenticity of one of the most famous flavors in the BBQ business.

    Goldbelly

    Each package comes with the dry rub and two sauces — you can choose from their White Sauce, Mild BBQ Sauce, and Hot BBQ Sauce.

    Get it from Goldbelly for $49 (plus free shipping).

    22. A jar of Main Maple Champagne mustard with a lil' hint of maple syrup and the dry sweetness of champagne, so you can take your wraps and sandwiches to an entirely new delicious dimension.

    Stonewall Kitchen

    Get it from Stonewall Kitchen for $6.50.

    23. A bourbon molasses barbecue sauce with a thick, smoky sweetness that will have you dreaming about those ribs you slow-cooked looooong after you gobble them down.

    Stonewall Kitchen

    Get it from Stonewall Kitchen for $7.95.

    You after drizzling, spreading, and marinating these condiments all over everything in your pantry:

    Paramount Pictures

    Reviews have been edited for length and/or clarity.

    Shopping for something specific? Check out BuzzFeed Reviews to find the best things for every budget!

    BuzzFeed

    Need A Shopping Buddy?

    Get great products - from pros in the fine art of buying stuff online - delivered to your inbox!
    Newsletter signup form