back to top
Shopping

24 Custom Valentine's Day Gifts From Personal Creations That Everyone Will Love

From personalized candy mailboxes to whiskey stones to stackable rings, these gifts have your Valentine's name literally written on them!

Posted on

We hope you love the products we recommend! Just so you know, BuzzFeed may collect a share of sales from the links on this page. Oh, and FYI — prices are accurate and items in stock as of time of publication.

1. A fondue set that their neighbor won't "forget" to return because you can put their name on it!!!!!

Includes pot, four forks, and tea light. Personalize with any 1 to 3 line message up to 16 characters each in block or script font. Hand wash.Price: $24.99+ (available with or without chocolate)
personalcreations.com

Includes pot, four forks, and tea light. Personalize with any 1 to 3 line message up to 16 characters each in block or script font. Hand wash.

Price: $24.99+ (available with or without chocolate)

2. A ~personalized~ mailbox full of chocolate kisses to hold them over 'til you can give them some IRL kisses.

Includes 5 oz. of Hershey's chocolate kisses, and a personalized photo and text.Price: $24.99
personalcreations.com

Includes 5 oz. of Hershey's chocolate kisses, and a personalized photo and text.

Price: $24.99

3. A ~magical~ friend who'll project soothing constellations onto ceilings and walls as a bedtime helper.

Includes adoption certificate for their new bedtime buddy. Lights up in 3 colors: green, blue, and amber; projections include the moon and 3 constellations. 45 minute timer automatically switches unit off, ensuring complete darkness during deep sleep, as recommended by pediatricians. Includes 3 AA batteries. Spot clean.Price: $39.99+ (available in three creatures)
personalcreations.com

Includes adoption certificate for their new bedtime buddy. Lights up in 3 colors: green, blue, and amber; projections include the moon and 3 constellations. 45 minute timer automatically switches unit off, ensuring complete darkness during deep sleep, as recommended by pediatricians. Includes 3 AA batteries. Spot clean.

Price: $39.99+ (available in three creatures)

4. A pair of keychains that fit perfectly together, just like you!

Crafted of nickel plated–non tarnish metal. Engrave any 2 names up to 9 characters and numeric date. “Better” will always appear on one key chain, “Together” will always appear on the other.Price: $16.99
personalcreations.com

Crafted of nickel plated–non tarnish metal. Engrave any 2 names up to 9 characters and numeric date. “Better” will always appear on one key chain, “Together” will always appear on the other.

Price: $16.99

5. A handy mug sporting the beautiful likenesses of all their loved ones as a lovely daily reminder. (Or multiple times a day, depending on how they feel about coffee!)

Choose between 11 oz. black handle mug and 15 oz. white mug. Personalize with any title (Dad, Grandpa, etc.), up to 9 characters, and add up to 12 names, up to 9 characters each name and choose from multiple icons. Mugs are microwave- and dishwasher-safe.Price: $16.99
personalcreations.com

Choose between 11 oz. black handle mug and 15 oz. white mug. Personalize with any title (Dad, Grandpa, etc.), up to 9 characters, and add up to 12 names, up to 9 characters each name and choose from multiple icons. Mugs are microwave- and dishwasher-safe.

Price: $16.99

6. An adorable jar that'll remind them of your playfully salty convos every time they reach for a salty snack.

Personalize with any title and up to 10 letters with "nuts about" in the phrase. Airtight lid, hand wash.Price: $19.99
personalcreations.com

Personalize with any title and up to 10 letters with "nuts about" in the phrase. Airtight lid, hand wash.

Price: $19.99

7. A dashing silk tie with a secret pocket for love notes as a little special way to brighten their day.

personalcreations.com

Includes 25 paper hearts for love notes. Personalize with any name up to 6 characters.

Price: $49.99

8. A quartet of photo coasters as a ~friendly~ reminder to not set their glass down on the bare coffee table!

Made of tumbled stone with chiseled edges and protective cork backing. Choose 1 or 4 photos to feature, and personalize each coaster with up to 18 characters..Price: $24.99+ (available with or without holder)
personalcreations.com

Made of tumbled stone with chiseled edges and protective cork backing. Choose 1 or 4 photos to feature, and personalize each coaster with up to 18 characters..

Price: $24.99+ (available with or without holder)

9. A mermaid tail or shark blanket for lounging around by the seaside. Or the couch.

personalcreations.com, personalcreations.com

Fit most children up to age 12. Personalize with a name up to 9 characters. Machine washable.

Price: mermaid for $34.99 (available in two color combos) or shark for $34.99

10. An oversized mug with the delish pet name they'll never grow tired of hearing. OK, probably? I dunno, but this is perf for yummy ice cream, coffee, soup, and lots of other good stuff.

Holds 32 oz. Personalize with a word up to 10 characters. Microwave-safe, hand wash.Price: $17
personalcreations.com

Holds 32 oz. Personalize with a word up to 10 characters. Microwave-safe, hand wash.

Price: $17

11. A puppy gift (with human treats!) they won't have to train.

Includes a plush Dalmatian, 4 oz. of marshmallow hearts, 2 oz. of gummy bears, and 2 oz. of chocolate hearts in a red gift box. Personalize with any name up to 9 characters. Suitable for ages 3+.Price: $19.99
personalcreations.com

Includes a plush Dalmatian, 4 oz. of marshmallow hearts, 2 oz. of gummy bears, and 2 oz. of chocolate hearts in a red gift box. Personalize with any name up to 9 characters. Suitable for ages 3+.

Price: $19.99

12. A set of nine whiskey stones as a romantic reminder that'll keep their fav drink at the perfect temp.

Made of soapstone that maintains temperature for a long time. Includes a black velvet storage bag. Personalize with any 2 letter monogram, 3 letter monogram, or any 2 line message up to 8 characters each. Hand wash.Price: $29
personalcreations.com

Made of soapstone that maintains temperature for a long time. Includes a black velvet storage bag. Personalize with any 2 letter monogram, 3 letter monogram, or any 2 line message up to 8 characters each. Hand wash.

Price: $29

13. A garden stone to stand as a sturdy reminder of your enduring love.

Garden stone is made of durable cast resin. Personalize it with any 2 names, up to 10 characters each.Price: $29.99
personalcreations.com

Garden stone is made of durable cast resin. Personalize it with any 2 names, up to 10 characters each.

Price: $29.99

14. A pair of long-distance mugs that'll warm their hands, insides, and especially their heart when they're sipping their fav hot bev and thinking about your special relationship.

Personalize with any 2 states (all 50 available) and title (Sisters, Friends, Cousins, etc.) up to 10 characters. Microwave- and dishwasher-safe.Price: $16.99
personalcreations.com

Personalize with any 2 states (all 50 available) and title (Sisters, Friends, Cousins, etc.) up to 10 characters. Microwave- and dishwasher-safe.

Price: $16.99

15. A gorgeous love token necklace they can treasure at all times on their person!

Sterling-silver disc with cut-out heart charm on a 16" chain + 2" extender. Personalize with any message up to 10 characters.Price: $79
personalcreations.com

Sterling-silver disc with cut-out heart charm on a 16" chain + 2" extender. Personalize with any message up to 10 characters.

Price: $79

16. A colorful buddy who's ready to be filled with some yummy treats!

Plastic jar with airtight screw-top lid and polyester plush figure. Personalize with any name up to 9 characters. Candy not included.Price: $19.99 (available in four characters)
personalcreations.com

Plastic jar with airtight screw-top lid and polyester plush figure. Personalize with any name up to 9 characters. Candy not included.

Price: $19.99 (available in four characters)

17. A duo of soft pillowcases so there's no doubt as to whose side is whose — though I'm sure you'd be willing to share.

Made of 100% cotton with 300 thread count. Personalize each pillowcase with any name, up to 9 characters. Fits a standard-size pillow. Machine washable.Price: $29.99
personalcreations.com

Made of 100% cotton with 300 thread count. Personalize each pillowcase with any name, up to 9 characters. Fits a standard-size pillow. Machine washable.

Price: $29.99

18. A picnic backpack for the outdoorsy baes who'd prefer to dine al fresco but don't wanna rough it too much.

Made of polyester canvas with padded shoulder straps and an insulated inner compartment. Includes a detachable wine cooler, felt blanket, 4 melamine plates, 4 wine goblets, 12-piece flatware set, 4 napkins, bread knife, wooden cutting board, salt and pepper shakers, and sommelier's corkscrew. Personalize with 1 or 2 lines up to 15 characters each. Hand wash.Price: $89.99 (also available in a smaller version)
personalcreations.com

Made of polyester canvas with padded shoulder straps and an insulated inner compartment. Includes a detachable wine cooler, felt blanket, 4 melamine plates, 4 wine goblets, 12-piece flatware set, 4 napkins, bread knife, wooden cutting board, salt and pepper shakers, and sommelier's corkscrew. Personalize with 1 or 2 lines up to 15 characters each. Hand wash.

Price: $89.99 (also available in a smaller version)

19. A handsome clock so no one has an excuse to forget an anniversary because we aren't at Weasley-level clocks IRL just yet.

Personalize with a laser-engraved message on 1 line, up to 25 characters, and any date. Operates on one AA battery (not included).Price: $79.99
personalcreations.com

Personalize with a laser-engraved message on 1 line, up to 25 characters, and any date. Operates on one AA battery (not included).

Price: $79.99

20. A set of stackable rings with your initials on them that can be worn together or apart!

Made of sterling silver. Personalize with any 2 initials.Price: $79 (available in sizes 6–8)
personalcreations.com

Made of sterling silver. Personalize with any 2 initials.

Price: $79 (available in sizes 6–8)

21. A cheery puzzle so cute you could squeal — and they might?! So be prepared for that.

Includes 252 pieces. Design is also printed on lid of the gift tin. Personalize with any name up to 10 characters. "Be my Valentine" will always appear. Suitable for ages 3+.Price: $29.99
personalcreations.com

Includes 252 pieces. Design is also printed on lid of the gift tin. Personalize with any name up to 10 characters. "Be my Valentine" will always appear. Suitable for ages 3+.

Price: $29.99

22. An LED canvas for the mason jar enthusiast who's also the *light* of your life.

Personalize with any message up to 25 characters, numeric date, and 2 line message: up to 30 characters on the 1st line and up to 18 characters on the 2nd line. Lights turn on/off with a push of a button; remote control features steady or twinkling option. Remote control includes lithium battery. Canvas has on/off switch; uses 3 AAA batteries (not included). Price: $74.99
personalcreations.com

Personalize with any message up to 25 characters, numeric date, and 2 line message: up to 30 characters on the 1st line and up to 18 characters on the 2nd line. Lights turn on/off with a push of a button; remote control features steady or twinkling option. Remote control includes lithium battery. Canvas has on/off switch; uses 3 AAA batteries (not included).

Price: $74.99

23. A wallet-size bottle opener as a helper when you're not there to lend an IRL hand to bae.

Slides easily into a pocket or wallet credit card slot. Made of stainless steel with silver matte finish. Personalize with any message up to 20 characters and date up to 18 characters.Price: $14.99
personalcreations.com

Slides easily into a pocket or wallet credit card slot. Made of stainless steel with silver matte finish. Personalize with any message up to 20 characters and date up to 18 characters.

Price: $14.99

24. A year of votives to one-up the typical last-minute candle in a Valentine's Day-ish hue.

Includes 12 hand-poured soy votives presented in a wooden box and a story card that defines each word. Engrave box with any 2 names up to 10 characters each and date. "A Year of Love" will always appear.Price: $99
personalcreations.com

Includes 12 hand-poured soy votives presented in a wooden box and a story card that defines each word. Engrave box with any 2 names up to 10 characters each and date. "A Year of Love" will always appear.

Price: $99

Choosing one of these gifts is sooooo much easier than orchestrating this:

Touchstone Television

Looking for even more Valentine's Day gift ideas? Check out all of BuzzFeed’s Valentine's gift guides here!

Ryan Pattie / BuzzFeed
The best things at three price points