back to top

I Really Want This Theory About Taylor Swift's New Album To Be True

We're about to go deep.

Posted on

It's been less than a week (lol, I know, right?) since Taylor Swift announced her sixth album, Reputation, will be released on 10 November.

Instagram: @taylorswift

But seeing as hardcore Swifties moonlight as professional detectives, we already knew that announcement was coming.

On closer inspection of the clip it appears there could be a '2' and a '5' on the tail. Indicating a lead single co… https://t.co/ueNWM62hIU

And since the video for Reputation's lead single, "Look What You Made Me Do", dropped on Friday, fans have gone into overdrive with their theories and speculations.

View this video on YouTube

youtube.com

(You should watch the video if you haven't already, otherwise you won't understand ANY of this.)

Fans are discovering new hidden meanings within the video every single hour, but I'm not here to talk about that, because it's too overwhelming and this post will end up being longer and better-researched than my dissertation.

Read about the hidden meanings here and here, if you so desire.

Advertisement

HOWEVER, as every good stan will know, Taylor Swift has spent the last few days lurking and liking posts on Tumblr, and now's the time for me to put my detective hat on, because I have been stalking her likes and I have THEORIES TO EXPLORE.

First and foremost, let's establish that according to the iTunes preorder page, Reputation will consist of 15 tracks, and "Look What You Made Me Do" is track six.

And seeing as we haven't been given the option to preorder a ~deluxe edition~ of the album, fans were like, "holy shit, are we not getting a deluxe edition of the album?"

IS THERE A DELUXE VERSION OF REPUTATION I REALLY HOPE THERE IS OML WHY HAS THIS NOT BEEN CONFIRMED YET 😭 #LookWhatYouMadeMeDo

Taylor has offered deluxe editions of her last three albums – Speak Now, Red, and 1989 – each including bonus tracks, along with demos, acoustic versions, and remixes of the other songs on the album.

But Taylor has since liked this post on Tumblr, indicating that there won't be a deluxe version after all – because all the songs are so amazing that "they all deserved to be on the standard version".

Advertisement

And anyway, the most exciting theory comes from this post, which Taylor herself liked, and therefore it is confirmed. Don't @ me, I don't make the rules.

Remember how we established that there will be 15 tracks on Reputation? Well, fans have been speculating that the 15 Taylors taking their bows at the end of the "LWYMMD" video each correspond to a different track on the album.

Based on what we already know about the album's track list, that would make "Look What You Made Me Do" the sixth Taylor in the lineup – aka the ~receipts~ Taylor, who many think is an amalgamation of Kim Kardashian and Katy Perry.

Big Machine Records / youtube.com

That would make sense, because the song seems to be about getting back at the people who caused her fall from grace – and I think it's well established at this point that Kim Kardashian (along with her husband Kanye West) and Katy Perry can take credit for that.

Advertisement

But, if that's true, what do the rest of the Taylors represent? Some fans have latched on to an in-depth theory about the fourth Taylor – who is wearing an outfit from her Red era. FULL DISCLOSURE: Taylor didn't like this post, so this is one theory that isn't confirmed.

It all stems from an alleged leaked tracklist that listed the fourth song as being almost nine minutes long.

ERM APPARENTLY THE FIRST SINGLE IS 8 MINUTES 47???? ALL TOO WELL 2.0

Longtime fans think this means that the fourth song on the album ~could~ be an extended version of Taylor's song "All Too Well". It was rumoured back in 2012 that the song was originally around 10 minutes long, but Taylor decided to cut it down at the last minute because it wouldn't fit on the album. Fans have been begging her to release the full, uncut version ever since.

So, if we're going with this theory (which we are, because it's awesome and because this is Taylor Swift and there are no coincidences, especially when it comes to numbers), there are seven songs on the album from the perspectives of her past personas.

Big Machine Records / youtube.com

There's Red Taylor, Fearless Taylor, the 2009 VMAs Taylor, the 2014 Met Gala Taylor, "You Belong With Me" Taylor, "Out of the Woods" Taylor, and "Shake It Off" Taylor. The rest of them are her new personas from the "LWYMMD" video.

Some of the references are pretty obvious – like the seventh Taylor, who is wearing her 2009 VMAs dress and exclaims she wants to be "excluded from this narrative", referencing her ongoing feud with Kanye West.

In that case, the seventh song on the album could be about the infamous Kanye incident – and, judging by "Look What You Made Me Do", it may not be as forgiving as "Innocent", the song she wrote about it in 2010.

Advertisement

The Taylor of "You Belong With Me" is also in the track list lineup, but this time her shirt is covered with the names of her current ~squad members~ rather than the signatures on the original shirt.

There's been a lot of speculation about the names that are missing from the shirt: squad leaders Karlie Kloss and Lorde aren't present, and there are a lot of "Bad Blood" stars missing. But maybe song 10 could be about exactly that – the media's constant speculation about the legitimacy of Taylor's many friendships.

Or maybe it'll be about her fake friends. [sips tea]

But some of the Taylors are wearing outfits that don't seem to have any ~huge~ significance, like the 2014 Met Gala Taylor. And, frankly, I can't wait to know what this particular track is about.

Because Taylor also liked this Tumblr post about the theory, suggesting we'll be getting songs from the point of view of each character.

The use of the word "character" is particularly important when it comes to this specific Taylor, who only appears for a few seconds and who doesn't seem to be dressed up as any persona at all.

Big Machine Records / youtube.com

(Side note: This headband is a Look. I'm wearing a headband to the Reputation tour.)

Advertisement

People are theorising that this Taylor isn't a character, but the real deal – and she's standing behind all her meticulously created personas, watching it all play out from behind the scenes.

And, again, Taylor liked this post, so it's law.

The theory goes that, as this Taylor is standing behind all the rest, she represents the 15th and final track on the album – one where we are finally blessed with the perspective of the real Taylor.

This would follow Old Taylor's tradition of concluding her albums with songs about new beginnings. (Even though Old Taylor is dead, her traditions live on.)

Big Machine Records / dailyswiftgifs.tumblr.com

Both Red and 1989 end with songs – "Begin Again" and "Clean", respectively – about letting go of old relationships and starting fresh.

  1. THOUGHTS?

    THOUGHTS?
    Correct
    Incorrect
    This is so cool, and I'd love this theory to be true!
    Correct
    Incorrect
    You're reading way too much into this. It's not that deep.
    Correct
    Incorrect
    I would very much like to be excluded from this narrative.
Oops. Something went wrong. Please try again later
Looks like we are having a problem on the server.
THOUGHTS?
  1.  
    vote votes
    This is so cool, and I'd love this theory to be true!
  2.  
    vote votes
    You're reading way too much into this. It's not that deep.
  3.  
    vote votes
    I would very much like to be excluded from this narrative.
 
Take quizzes and chill with the BuzzFeed app.