People Are Mad At This Newspaper Headline About Katie Ledecky

"This headline is a metaphor for basically the entire world."

Posted on

On Sunday, Nancy Leong, a law professor at the University of Denver, was looking online for newspaper stories on the Olympics for an upcoming class when she spotted a photo of one headline that made her gasp.

She tweeted the picture with the caption "This headline is a metaphor for basically the entire world." It immediately went viral.

This headline is a metaphor for basically the entire world.

"This seemed like a particularly clear-cut example of a situation where you have two achievements, one by a man and one by a woman, that were given the wrong treatment," Leong told BuzzFeed News.

"Not only that, but the achievement by the woman is objectively more impressive, but it was put in smaller font below the man's headline."

The headline is from the lead page of the sports section of Saturday's edition of The Eagle, a newspaper in Bryan-College Station, Texas, with a staff of roughly two dozen people.

Kelly Brown, the paper's editor, defended the copy editor who wrote the headline, telling BuzzFeed News Leong's tweet lacked context because it cropped out a photo of Ledecky, which she said helped to "balance" the layout.

"Is it perfect? Absolutely not," she said. "When I first saw it I wondered why it was that way, as well. Could it have been better? Yes."

"But I don't think it's as egregious as people are saying, especially because she cropped out the key part of it." (Leong did not take the picture herself, but rather found it online.)

Others, though, defended the newspaper for its decision to lead with Phelps, describing his loss as the greater newsworthy event.

Twitter

But then just spawned accusations that people were "mansplaining."

Twitter

Leong said she wasn't intending to badmouth the paper's staff for the headline. "I would feel a bit bad if the editor at the paper ended up catching blame for it because I could have picked any one of four dozen different examples," she said.

"This is not just one editor at one paper," she said. "It's a systemic problem.

"It's not that people are being malicious, but they're not sufficiently conscious of what they're doing when they put a man's name in big, bold font for an achievement that's objectively less impressive."

David Mack is a reporter and weekend editor for BuzzFeed News in New York.

Contact David Mack at david.mack@buzzfeed.com.

Got a confidential tip? Submit it here.