Skip To Content
    Nov 6, 2019

    A New Horror Film Called "Girl On The Third Floor" Has Been Getting High Praise And I Watched For People Who Can't Do Horror

    The most disturbing film I've seen this year.

    Greetings, folks. I know normally these reviews are of stuff on Netflix, but this week I'm telling you about a new movie I rented on Amazon called Girl on the Third Floor. I'd seen multiple tweets and reviews insisting it's a disturbing, unique horror flick. After I watched the trailer, I was certain I had to check it out. Here, watch for yourself:

    View this video on YouTube

    youtube.com

    Here's how Amazon describes the movie:

    Amazon

    "Don Koch tries to renovate a house with a sordid history for his growing family, only to learn that the house has other plans."

    Let me tell you, it was one of the STRANGEST things I've ever watched and I don't know how I'm going to explain it, but here we go!

    Dark Sky Films

    We start by meeting Don Koch, who is renovating his new house.

    Dark Sky Films

    Don is with his beautiful dog, Cooper. All I know is that Cooper needs to go unharmed for the next hour and 30 minutes.

    Dark Sky Films

    GOOD BOY METER: 10/10

    Early on, nothing scary happens but the house itself is DISGUSTING. Here's one example: There's a puddle of some unknown goo, a condom, and a bunch of dead flies on the floor in one room. For some reason, Don cleans it with a towel and HIS BARE HANDS.

    Dark Sky Films

    GET THAT MAN SOME LATEX GLOVES METER: 10/10

    We meet someone who lives near Don named Ellie. She comes over unannounced (A TRULY SCARY CONCEPT) and offers him bourbon and friendly conversation.

    Dark Sky Films

    We also meet Don's wife, Liz, who is pregnant and away while he fixes up the house. They talk over a video-chat. She seems very sweet. Still nothing spooky here.

    Dark Sky Films

    FIRST SCARY MOMENT OF THE MOVIE ALERT: Around 16 minutes in, a figure can be seen walking behind Don. I think it was effective horror, because I said "nope" out loud.

    Dark Sky Films

    MORE GROSS HAPPENINGS: While Don is trying to work on a sink pipe, a bunch of brown stuff shoots out onto him.

    Dark Sky Films

    SCORE:

    The House: 2

    Don: 0

    Don spots this woman outside of his house and they briefly greet each other. Methinks she's the girl on the third floor who this movie's title is referring to.

    Dark Sky Films

    I may have missed the part where she says her name, but according to IMDB it's Sarah.

    Ah yes, even MORE GROSSNESS. Don goes to take a shower and it shoots out this goop that looks like...something.

    Dark Sky Films

    I respect Don's determination, but how many strange fluids must one come in contact with before they take the L and hire a general contractor.

    Another scary moment: There's a figure standing in the mirror in the shot seen below. Don doesn't spot it, do you?

    Dark Sky Films

    Don sees Sarah outside playing with his wonderful, magnificent, perfect pup, Cooper and he invites her inside. Uh oh.

    Dark Sky Films

    Don gives Sarah a tour of his house like it's a haunted-ass episode of MTV Cribs. It definitely feels like he's about to do something stupid.

    Dark Sky Films

    DON'T CHEAT ON YOUR WIFE METER: 10/10

    Dammit, Don.

    Dark Sky Films

    So Don and Sarah hook up. The next night, she comes back for round two, but Don decides to not cheat on his wife this time! Hooray!

    Dark Sky Films

    Later that night, Don has a dream that he's getting intimate with his wife...

    Dark Sky Films

    His wife turns into Sarah...

    Dark Sky Films

    And Sarah turns into this pancetta-faced entity.

    Dark Sky Films

    I'm not even quite sure what it is, but Don wakes up in a cold sweat after hooking up with it in his nightmare.

    OK, if you want to watch this movie for yourself without pretty much everything being spoiled, stop here. If you want to continue down the extremely random, profoundly eerie roller coaster that the last hour of this movie is, scroll on!

    Dark Sky Films

    At 33 minutes in, we're introduced to Don's friend, Milo, who comes to help him fix the house up.

    Dark Sky Films

    I was genuinely enjoying their dynamic, but I won't delve any further into Milo's character because the movie didn't either. Here's Milo LESS THAN EIGHT MINUTES after he was introduced, being killed off by Sarah.

    Dark Sky Films

    DISAPPOINTED BUT NOT SURPRISED METER: 7.5/10

    Sarah had been showing up at Don's house even though he asked her not to, and she was growing increasingly aggressive, but this confirms that she's this movie's antagonist. Milo was in the house alone when Sarah popped up and violently took him out. Then she texted Don from Milo's phone, so Don thinks Milo is fine.

    Don is video-chatting with his wife when she spots something (it's Sarah) swoop by in the background. Don searches the house but finds nothing. He's freaked out, so the next morning he changes the locks and installs a camera.

    Dark Sky Films

    REMEMBER EARLIER HOW I SAID COOPER THE PERFECT DOG BETTER GO UNHARMED FOR THE ENTIRETY OF THIS FILM? Well, he doesn't and it's really, REALLY awful.

    Dark Sky Films

    I absolutely hated everything about this moment, so I'll spare you the details and just say that Sarah killed Cooper in a very, very horrible way. It's legitimately my least favorite thing from any of the horrors I've watched thus far.

    Dark Sky Films

    Don sees on the camera that Sarah was in his home, so he knows she's the one who killed Cooper. Sarah shows up and Don tells her he has a gift for her in the kitchen. I think she's expecting flowers or jewelry, but it turns out all he has is a blunt force object to the back of her head.

    Dark Sky Films

    After killing Sarah, Don cleans up the mess and stashes her body.

    Dark Sky Films

    Don leaves for a second and Sarah's body disappears. Then, Don searches the house for Sara's body and winds up discovering some disturbing art, and this strange, bloody, organ-like thing breathing in the walls.

    Dark Sky Films

    He also finds Eight Minute Milo's body stashed in the walls.

    Dark Sky Films

    It gets even weirder. Cabinets start opening and shutting, then this thing crawls out of a drawer. It's a really weird, chopped open face with teeth in places they don't belong.

    Dark Sky Films

    The teeth-face person puts a marble inside of Don's leg for some reason, and he tries to cut it out with a box cutter (it's super gory). Somehow, the marble scurries up his leg and body, all the way up to his eye.

    Dark Sky Films

    Don eventually squeezes the marble out.

    Dark Sky Films

    Why? I don't know, Don. I don't know.

    The teeth-face person is closing in on Don, then she sends a bunch of marbles into his body.

    Dark Sky Films

    Liz comes to the house to surprise Don, but he's nowhere to be found. She goes across the street and talks to the neighbor Ellie. When she comes back, there's like a weird sex show or something happening, and creepy dudes are watching from a third floor balcony.

    Dark Sky Films

    I'M CONFUSED METER: 9/10

    Liz finds Don. He's slashed his body up trying to get the marbles out. Liz is like, "We should leave this house," and Don is all ,"It's complicated, I screwed up," implying that he cheated.

    Dark Sky Films

    Liz is pissed about his infidelity, but Don is bleeding everywhere. Plus there's a sex show and creepy dudes right outside the door, so you'd think those things would be bigger priorities but nope.

    Don slices his skin off and it turns out it's Sarah inside? Look, I genuinely don't know what's happening anymore, so if you're reading this asking, "WTF?!" know that I was doing the same as I watched it.

    Dark Sky Films

    Liz runs off. On her way out, she smashes the teeth-face person's head with a hammer, because they weren't letting us out of this movie without another astoundingly gross shot.

    Dark Sky Films

    We cut six months into the future and...LIZ IS STILL LIVING IN THE HOUSE, NOW WITH HER BABY. Cool. Cool, cool, cool. That's a totally safe, sensible thing to do.

    Dark Sky Films

    When Liz leaves the room, we see the baby looking up at the vent, where Don is lurking. END CREDITS.

    Dark Sky Films

    FINAL THOUGHTS:

    Dark Sky Films

    IS IT MORE GROSS OR SCARY?: I don't think it will scare most people, but I'm almost certain that there's at least one scene in this that'll, at the very least, lessen your appetite.

    BEST PART: I'm a fan of Phil 'CM Punk' Brooks (Don), and if you are too, you'll definitely enjoy seeing him show off his acting chops.

    WORST PART: Cooper the dog's death. 100% could've done without it.

    GORY RATING: 9/10

    SCARY RATING: 5/10

    IS IT WORTH PAYING TO RENT OR BUY?: If you like gore, or CM Punk, or super dark, twisted things, or all of the above, it's definitely worth renting and watching for yourself. I just need others to tune in so they can explain to me what I've witnessed.

    SUM THE MOVIE UP IN ONE MOMENT: See screenshot above.

    PREVIOUSLY WATCHED:

    Eli on Netflix

    Eerie on Netflix

    Secret Obsession on Netflix

    Midsommar in theaters

    Murder Mystery on Netflix

    The Perfection on Netflix

    The Wandering Earth on Netflix

    The Silence on Netflix

    Black Summer on Netflix

    How It Ends on Netflix

    Set It Up on Netflix

    The Kissing Booth on Netflix

    Veronica on Netflix

    Dude on Netflix

    Irreplaceable You on Netflix

    TV and Movies

    Get all the best moments in pop culture & entertainment delivered to your inbox.

    Newsletter signup form