back to top

Louisiana Justice Would Ignore U.S. Supreme Court Same-Sex Marriage Ruling

"The most troubling prospect of same sex marriage is the adoption by same sex partners of a young child of the same sex," Louisiana Supreme Court Justice Jefferson Hughes writes.

Posted on
Kathleen Flynn / AP

Michael Robinson, left, and Earl Benjamin, partners for almost 14 years, exchange vows before Judge Paula Brown in a ceremony at Orleans Parish Civil District Court on Monday, June 29, 2015, in New Orleans.

On Tuesday, the Louisiana Supreme Court dismissed as moot a pending case about the rights of a same-sex couple married out of state because, the court ruled, the U.S. Supreme Court decision on marriage and marriage recognition "resolved" the matter:

The decision means that the California marriage of Angela Marie Costanza and Chastity Shanelle Brewer is to be respected in Louisiana, including for purposes of second-parent adoption.

Hughes disagreed that the U.S. Supreme Court resolved the issue, calling adoption "of a young child of the same sex" by same-sex couples "[t]he most troubling prospect" of marriage equality:

At the other extreme, even Justice Jeannette Theriot Knoll — who wrote the court's decision upholding the state's marriage ban a decade ago — acknowledged she was "constrained to follow" the U.S. Supreme Court ruling:

Justice Scott Crichton simply noted his agreement with Justice Guidry:

Neither Chief Justice Bernette Johnson nor Justice Marcus Clark weighed in with any written opinion on the matter.

Chris Geidner is the legal editor for BuzzFeed News and is based in Washington, DC. In 2014, Geidner won the National Lesbian & Gay Journalists Association award for journalist of the year.

Contact Chris Geidner at

Got a confidential tip? Submit it here.