back to top
Tech

A Teacher Is Suing Breitbart And James O'Keefe's Project Veritas For Defamation

The teacher's attorney alleges that an undercover video shot by a disguised reporter was "creatively edited ... to make him appear violent and dangerous."

Originally posted on
Updated on

Steve Wentz, the president of a Kansas teachers union, last week filed a defamation lawsuit in Orlando against Breitbart News and Project Veritas, the self-described investigative video site run by conservative activist James O'Keefe.

The 66-page lawsuit concerns a video posted by Project Veritas and an accompanying article in Breitbart News from June 2016. In the video, Wentz, who was attending a conference in Orlando, is shown suggesting that he has threatened students with physical violence. “Son, go for it and I’ll give you the first shot … I will kick your fucking ass,” Wentz says in the opening of the Veritas video. The Breitbart article ran with the headline, "O’Keefe Sting — Teachers Union President Brags About Threatening Student: 'I Will Kick Your F***ing Ass.'"

In the suit, Wentz's attorney alleges that the video — shot by a Veritas reporter — was "creatively edited ... to make him appear violent and dangerous." The lawsuit argues that the recording was made using a "concealed recording device ... without Wentz's authorization." Florida, where Veritas recorded the video, has a two-party consent law, making it illegal to record a conversation if both parties involved haven't agreed to be recorded. The suit continues that Veritas's video and Breitbart's summary omitted "most of the reasoning and all explanatory detail from O'Keefe's story," which twisted the purpose of Wentz's words.

Wentz's attorney argues that the actual story he told to the Veritas reporter was part of a "particularly memorable anecdote of an incident when he had feigned force, or used 'tough love,' to connect with and eventually help a troubled student." The suit suggests that Wentz had since reconnected with the student and that both "agreed to put this incident behind them." Years later, the suit reads, "Wentz ran into that former student, who gave Wentz a hug."

A spokesperson for Project Veritas responded to a request for comment by asking: "In what possible context is what Mr. Wentz said on video ever justifiable or acceptable?"

The timing of the suit, filed late last week, is perhaps inopportune for Project Veritas, which is in the middle of another big story. On Tuesday morning, O'Keefe and Veritas released a highly edited video of a man, purporting to be a CNN producer, disparaging CNN's coverage of the investigation into President Trump's Russia ties.

As far as Breitbart's involvement goes, the suit alleges that the Breitbart article is defamatory as it "falsely explains that Wentz met with 'journalists,' when in reality, an individual who faked her identity and recorded Wentz covertly, without his permission, had tricked him." Furthermore, the suit focuses on Breitbart's decision to append the search tags for "child abuse" and "union corruption" to the story. The suit alleges that when a visitor clicks through the "child abuse" tag, Wentz's photo and name are "sandwiched between a story about female genital mutilation and a mother who starved her children."

In a slack message today obtained by BuzzFeed News, Breitbart Editor-in-Chief Alex Marlow notified employees of the suit. "Breitbart just got sued for a story connected to Project Veritas -- not today's CNN video -- I believe this one was from 2015," he wrote. "It should go without saying that you should not comment on or tweet about the suit. Forward any media requests to me, Larry, and John Kahn please."

Wentz and his attorney are suing for unspecified damages to Wentz's reputation and name. Wentz is also suing for any money made by the video, which had 20,000 views at the time of writing.

Breitbart has not responded to a request for comment.

Charlie Warzel is a senior writer for BuzzFeed News and is based in New York. Warzel reports on and writes about the intersection of tech and culture.

Contact Charlie Warzel at charlie.warzel@buzzfeed.com.

Got a confidential tip? Submit it here.