back to top
DIY

10 Cult Beauty Brands On Etsy You Had No Idea Existed

Ditch your current cosmetics and find out what you've been missing.

Posted on
Justine Zwiebel / BuzzFeed

1. Portland Black Lipstick Company

Black lipstick is actually a thing, and Portland Black Lipstick is kill-ing it. As you would expect, the shop is known for its Original Black Lipstick ($10), which has a brilliant opaque finish.
BuzzFeed / Portland Black Lipstick Co / etsy.com

Black lipstick is actually a thing, and Portland Black Lipstick is kill-ing it. As you would expect, the shop is known for its Original Black Lipstick ($10), which has a brilliant opaque finish.

2. Pretty and Polished

This isn't your ordinary polish. With unique shades and a color-changing line, Pretty and Polished will take your manicures to the next level. A recent favorite is the deep purple, Tears of Dionysus ($8.50), which is currently sold out.
BuzzFeed / Pretty and Polished / etsy.com

This isn't your ordinary polish. With unique shades and a color-changing line, Pretty and Polished will take your manicures to the next level. A recent favorite is the deep purple, Tears of Dionysus ($8.50), which is currently sold out.

3. For Strange Women

For Strange Women's fragrances come in solid and liquid form, which embrace natural scents from the great outdoors. The Mini Mix-and-Match Set of 3 ($15) is the perfect starter product for your perfume adventure.
BuzzFeed / For Strange Women / etsy.com

For Strange Women's fragrances come in solid and liquid form, which embrace natural scents from the great outdoors. The Mini Mix-and-Match Set of 3 ($15) is the perfect starter product for your perfume adventure.

4. Impulse Cosmetics

Sure, this shop has a lot of eyeshadows, but its lipsticks are some of the best things on Etsy. The Opaque Matte Lipsticks ($6.99) have great, bold coverage and range from black to pastel green.
BuzzFeed / Impulse Cosmetics / etsy.com

Sure, this shop has a lot of eyeshadows, but its lipsticks are some of the best things on Etsy. The Opaque Matte Lipsticks ($6.99) have great, bold coverage and range from black to pastel green.

5. Soapopotamus

Soapopotamus has a variety of products, including soaps and lip butters, that take on many food shapes and fragrances. Who wouldn't want to clean their bodies with a Jumbo Cinnamon Roll ($6), or better, the Sushi Soap Set ($10)? One main ingredient you'll find is goat's milk, which according to store owner, Regina, is "generously kind and gentle to sensitive skin, and has lovely restorative properties, too!"
BuzzFeed / Soapopotamus / etsy.com

Soapopotamus has a variety of products, including soaps and lip butters, that take on many food shapes and fragrances. Who wouldn't want to clean their bodies with a Jumbo Cinnamon Roll ($6), or better, the Sushi Soap Set ($10)?

One main ingredient you'll find is goat's milk, which according to store owner, Regina, is "generously kind and gentle to sensitive skin, and has lovely restorative properties, too!"

6. Bunny Butt Apothecary

If the dangers of mainstream deodorant have left you scared, give this shop's THE PITS Veggie Protein Deodorant ($9.95) a try, which comes in 16 different scents.
BuzzFeed / Bunny Butt Apothecary / etsy.com

If the dangers of mainstream deodorant have left you scared, give this shop's THE PITS Veggie Protein Deodorant ($9.95) a try, which comes in 16 different scents.

7. Orange Thyme

Besides the cute packaging, Orange Thyme has great moisturizing Lip Balms ($3.50 ea.) that have flavors like Warm Apple Cider and Lavender Lemonade.
BuzzFeed / Orange Thyme / etsy.com

Besides the cute packaging, Orange Thyme has great moisturizing Lip Balms ($3.50 ea.) that have flavors like Warm Apple Cider and Lavender Lemonade.

8. Borne Cosmetics

Shop owner Jennifer is dedicated to creating mineral foundations and skin care that are irritant-free. As an added bonus, Jennifer also wants to reach out to women of all skin-tones. THE BASICS Starter Kit ($17.85) is perfect for beginners and it includes foundation, concealer, and blush.
BuzzFeed / Borne Cosmetics / etsy.com

Shop owner Jennifer is dedicated to creating mineral foundations and skin care that are irritant-free. As an added bonus, Jennifer also wants to reach out to women of all skin-tones.

THE BASICS Starter Kit ($17.85) is perfect for beginners and it includes foundation, concealer, and blush.

9. 8 Bit Cosmetics

8 Bit focuses on the glittery and colorful things in life, like awesome shadow. The line Everyone's A Hero has pretty colors from the shimmery gold Phoenix ($4) to the sleek cobalt All American Hero ($4). Loose powder eyeshadows are common in the indie makeup scene, and are often packed (if desired) by the user.
BuzzFeed / 8 Bit Cosmetics / etsy.com

8 Bit focuses on the glittery and colorful things in life, like awesome shadow. The line Everyone's A Hero has pretty colors from the shimmery gold Phoenix ($4) to the sleek cobalt All American Hero ($4).

Loose powder eyeshadows are common in the indie makeup scene, and are often packed (if desired) by the user.

10. Book of Shadows

Finally! Book of Shadows sells empty and creative cases for depotted shadows, bronzers, and other powders that aren't potted.The magnetic boxes have cool designs and patterns like The Gilded Rose Set ($15.99).
BuzzFeed / Book Of Shadows / etsy.com

Finally! Book of Shadows sells empty and creative cases for depotted shadows, bronzers, and other powders that aren't potted.The magnetic boxes have cool designs and patterns like The Gilded Rose Set ($15.99).

The best things at three price points