1. Puppy/Kitty Surprise
The reason you preferred it: This toy had more toys inside... basically every kid's dream! If you pulled five puppies or kittens out of their tummy, you hit the jackpot.
2. Polly Pocket
3. Doodle Bear
4. Baby Tumbles Surprise
5. My Little Pony
6. Betty Spaghetty
7. Beanie Babies
The reason you preferred it: Beanie Babies were so soft and huggable it was impossible not to want to collect them all. You really enjoyed how the tags included the Beanie Babies date of birth and back story.
8. Troll Doll
9. Sky Dancers
10. Lego
11. Bop It
12. Cabbage Patch Kids
13. Etch A Sketch
14. Littlest Pet Shop
15. View-Master
16. Baby All Gone
17. Furby
18. Game Boy Pocket or Game Boy Color
The reason you preferred it: These little beauties brought some of your favorite characters like Mario and Brock from Pokémon to life.
19. Power Ranger Action Figures
20. Super Soaker
21. Tamagotchi
22. Kitty, Kitty, Kittens
23. Quints
24. American Girl Doll
CORRECTION
Oops! The toy pictured on the right in number 18 is a Game Boy Color. An earlier version of this post misidentified the model.