We hope you love our recommendations! Some may have been sent as samples, but all were independently selected by our editors. Just FYI, BuzzFeed and its publishing partners may collect a share of sales and/or other compensation from the links on this page.
First, let's browse through some pottery gifts, shall we?
1. An adorable six-piece set of ceramic owl planters — aka the perfect opportunity to use the line "Owl always love you."
2. A cute ceramic rose seated in a terracotta planter with a note that says, "Happy 9th 'pottery' Anniversary" so they can keep it on their work desk and be reminded of how loved they are every day.
3. A gorgeous seven-piece ceramic dining set complete with handmade plates, a mug, and bowls guaranteed to make their way onto the table during all those candlelit dinners you enjoy together.
4. A ceramic aloe vera ring holder just begging to be accompanied by an "Aloe you vera much" comment as they open their gift.
5. A ceramic "Spoon me" spoon rest that serves two purposes: to save the countertops from getting gross and to subtly request a cuddle sesh.
6. A 2-in-1 ceramic wax melt/candle warmer and dish for them to ~stylishly~ fill the house with their favorite scents — especially the ones that remind them of you. 🥺
7. A tiny ceramic honey pot with a wooden dipper for your ~honey~ who's "as sweet as can bee."
8. A set of three ceramic cat sculptures for your S.O. to add to their collection of adorable home decor they've accumulated since you got meow-rried.
9. An elegant ceramic head vase just radiating ~vintage vibes~ they'll fall head over heels in love with (just like they did nine+ years ago).
10. A stylish handmade ceramic serving platter for them to use at every anniversary and dinner party for the foreseeable future — because these things truly last forever, just like your love for each other.
11. A ceramic electric tea kettle, so your loved one doesn't have to wait around for the water on the stove to heat up for their tea each morning or night. This little kettle will have their water ready in minutes — all they have to do is flip a switch!
12. And a large 21-ounce Bosmarlin ceramic mug to gift alongside that tea kettle, because sometimes a 12-ounce mug is simply not enough room for all the tea/coffee necessary to get through the day.
How about tossing in some willow-themed gifts as well?
13. A personalized cutting board featuring a laser-engraved willow tree with both your initials carved into it, plus your names, wedding date, a quote, or whatever else you want to occupy the rest of the board.
14. An anniversary card adorned with a llama made from willow branches to show your S.O. a ~whole llama love~.
15. A willow picnic basket fully equipped with melamine plates, acrylic wine glasses, a corkscrew, and flatware for the two of you to take on your next romantic picnic outing.
16. A handmade willow gemstone tree you can customize everything about, from its size and gemstones to the wire color and rock type, so it's really made for your other half.
17. A set of three handmade candleholders (tea lights included!) crafted from reclaimed willow wood to add a touch of sentimental rustic (and romantic) decor anywhere they put it.
18. A personalized piece of wall art featuring your names, a date (probably your anniversary, right?), and your choice of text printed on metal, canvas, or paper.
19. A bundle of three gorgeous bonsai willow trees if your S.O. has a green thumb and loves having plants around the house.
20. A two-pack of handcrafted LED-lit artificial willow branches for them to place in any room to add some cozy/romantic ambience.
21. Or a 7-foot-tall artificial willow tree from Nearly Natural (in other words, it'll look super real!) for your S.O. who adores plants but might not be the best plant parent.
22. A handmade eco-friendly willow bird feeder so you two ~love birds~ can sit and birdwatch together. Maybe hold hands or something too.
Or maybe you're not really feelin' the pottery or willow themes, and that's totally OK because we have some other great gift ideas up our sleeves.
23. A box of gourmet chocolate biscotti cookies for your ~sweetie~ who always has a sweet tooth.
24. A movie scratch-off poster so you guys can bond while debating over the classics.
25. A bath bomb gift set to remind your S.O. they deserve to treat themselves to a relaxing spa-like experience.
26. A diamond painting kit for you guys to work on together during stay-at-home date nights.
27. A color-changing essential oil diffuser to fill your home with both of your favorite scents. This is truly a gift that stinks...in the best way possible.
28. A mini fill-in-the-blank book for you to fill out and surprise your most loved one with, because what's cuter than that?
29. And a Himalayan salt rock night-light that'll give off a warm, comforting glow, act as a natural air filter, and add a little extra ~zen~ around the house. Romantic mood lighting = complete.
Happy anniversary, you love birds, you! 🎊
Looking for the perfect gift for any occasion? Check out all of BuzzFeed’s gift guides!
Reviews have been edited for length and/or clarity.