It's been five years since the show went off the air, and just look at how grown up Justin is!
Betty's big sister, Hilda — OK, actress Ana Ortiz — couldn't be there, but posted this sweet throwback shot. ❤️
And she and Ugly Betty director Victor Nelli Jr. cheers'd to the birthday girl.
Co-stars Michael Urie (Marc St. James), Becki Newton (Amanda Tanen), and Eric Mabius (Daniel Meade) were all seemingly busy working in London, L.A., and Chicago, respectively. But we're sure they would've been there if they could've!