back to top

We Tried The Butterbeers At The Wizarding World Of Harry Potter And Wow

Accio ALL the Butterbeers.

Posted on

But unless you're willing to perform an Engorgio charm on your stomach, it's tough to decide which Butterbeer to indulge in. Luckily for you, we Muggles decided to put all three flavors to the test to see which came out on top.



Brian: The first thing you notice with the Frozen version is that it has the consistency of a frozen margarita, which is nice and actually quite refreshing on a hot day — which it happened to be on the day we visited, despite all the snow covering the roofs of Hogsmeade. Also, the overall sweetness is less pronounced at first and subtly comes in the more you drink it.

Sam: The Frozen Butterbeer is the type of indulgent treat you'd want to knock back after a major Quidditch victory. Of the three, it feels the most like a dessert, although its notes of butterscotch and vanilla don't overwhelm the taste buds. I approve of this drink, and I think Madam Rosmerta would too.


Brian: OK, so this simply delicious and what I always imagined Butterbeer would taste like. It's a magical bubbly concoction that tastes like something between root beer, cream soda, and Coca-Cola. I could basically drink this all day and, also, now I know why all the students at Hogwarts were HOOKED on it.

Sam: I'd say this is the version of Butterbeer that Hermione's dentist parents would least approve of, and I'm HERE for it. The bottom portion basically tastes like cream soda, which is fine. But the creamy head is the real winner — a delicious frothy top that tastes like vanilla and Gryffindor winning the House Cup. Basically, my version of the Room of Requirement would be filled with the stuff (and also Cedric Diggory).


Brian: OMG, this tastes like Christmas in a cup!!! Like every time I take a sip it tastes like something slightly different, but still equally delicious. It tastes a bit like butterscotch and white chocolate mixed together. It's also bit thick, like Mexican hot chocolate and creamy, definitely something you'd want to drink on a cold day. Not going to lie, I'd fight Voldermort for a second mug of this (OK, maybe not Voldermort, but I'd knock over a first year for a mug).

Sam: I felt like I was literally drinking a waffle. Or maybe I was making out with a gingerbread man. Either way, my taste buds were in HEAVEN. But remember that this drink is HOT, just like Neville Longbottom in the last Harry Potter movie. Maybe it's not the best choice to order a warm sugary drink in SoCal, but do it anyway.

Final thoughts:

Brian Galindo/ BuzzFeed

Brian: It's hard to choose just one that I like, 'cause they were all delicious. But, if I had to make a choice, I will say go with the Traditional, it's light and refreshing, which is what you need when you plan on exploring all of Hogsmeade and Hogwarts. I will say though, that if there is a bit of chill in the air then definitely try the Hot, it'll make you feel like you're sitting in front of fire in a common room, while wrapped in a warm blanket.

Sam: Listen, if you put a wand to my head, I'd have to choose the Traditional Butterbeer. The creamy top is just too good to pass up. But that being said, I'm going to say you might as well live a little and try all three versions of Butterbeer. Drink now, ask questions later. It's what Ron Weasley would want you to do.

Alright, so what's YOUR favorite version of Butterbeer?

View this video on YouTube