Skip To Content

    21 Gifts That Will Make Every ’90s Girl Say, "OMG, I’m Totally Buggin'"

    A list full of items that are all that and a bag of chips.

    by ,

    We hope you love the products we recommend! All of them were independently selected by our editors. Just so you know, BuzzFeed may collect a share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page if you decide to shop from them. Oh, and FYI — prices are accurate and items in stock as of time of publication.

    Hey! While we’re doing our best to make sure the products we feature will arrive in time for Christmas, shipping times are especially tricky this year and can vary depending on where you live, which product you purchase, and more. Shop early and be sure to double-check the retailers’ websites for shipping information to ensure that your gift will arrive in time for the 25th!

    1. A Morphe x Lisa Frank makeup palette that comes with, of course, almost every color imaginable and in packaging that literally looks like every '90s girl's middle school folder.

    A product shot of the Lisa Frank makeup collection showing three palettes, brushes, and beauty blenders
    Morphe

    Promising review: "So, I got the palette yesterday and I tried out some BEAUTIFUL looks and they turned out SO GOOD. It's so pigmented and colorful, it's totally worth the price! Lisa Frank was my whole childhood and this brings back memories so my '90s BABIES YOU UNDERSTAND!!!" —Cynthia!

    Get it from Morphe for $30 or at Ulta for $30.

    2. A bottle of Gap Dream, which was everyone's signature scent back in the day.

    A hand holding a bottle of Gap Dream up towards the sun
    Amazon

    Promising review: "This smells EXACTLY like Dream! When I wore it back in the day, it was my husband's favorite scent. I didn't tell him I'd bought this and just put some on as a true test of how accurate the scent is. His reaction was 'How is it I can smell Dream?!' Like I said, this is an exact copy of the original fragrance. :)" —D. Quinlan

    Get it from Amazon for $22.

    3. A Clueless tote that has one of the most iconic movie quotes of the '90s on it.

    A pink tote that says "You're a virgin who can't drive"
    Amazon

    Get it from Amazon for $8.

    4. A vinyl copy of Mariah Carey's Daydream album on vinyl, 'cause it's a classic and worth it just for "Always Be My Baby" alone!

    The black and white cover for Day Dream which has a close-up of Mariah's face
    Amazon/ Sony

    Promising review: "I love this album! One of the greatest of all time! Every song is gorgeous and the vocals are on a whole new level!" —Raphael

    Get it from Amazon for $21.98.

    5. An oh-so-'90s Solo Jazz printed travel mug that will likely hold coffee now instead of soda.

    The aqua blue, violet, and white Solo Jazz pattern on a coffee travel mug
    Alex Officer/ Society 6

    Get it from Alex Officer on Society6 for $20.30.

    6. The Friends: The Official Cookbook, which will help your friend bring out their inner Monica.

    The Friends cookbook which features two photos of the cast a giant baked turkey on a roasting pan wearing a cartoon cartoon glasses and a red fez
    Amazon

    Promising review: "I got this for myself as a birthday present (HUGE Friends fan here) and it’s so much more than I expected! Great quality, sturdy, bigger than I thought, pictures, design, humor...absolutely love it. I just got it today so I haven’t cooked anything yet, but I’ll say that it’s a must even if just as a collectors item. So happy with it ♥️." —Valerie R.

    Get it from Amazon for $16.02.

    7. A Tamagotchi, because it's the perfect distraction that doesn't require a phone.

    A hand holding a purple Tamagotchi
    Urban Outfitters

    Get it from Urban Outfitters for $25.

    8. A TLC "No Scrubs" T-shirt that'll def have anyone singing "Oooh noooo, I don't want noooo scrub."

    A black T-shirt with TLC on it wearing red, yellow, and green tees and "No Scrubs" written along the side
    Hot Topic

    Promising review: "Dope shirt from a dope girl group." —Dessss

    Get it from Hot Topic for $22.90+ (available in unisex sizes S–2XL).

    9. Of course, 2020 has been the year of puzzles, and this Cardinal Blockbuster: Titanic Jigsaw Puzzle will bring back good memories of rushing to Blockbuster to rent Titanic, again.

    A Titanic puzzle
    Target

    Get it from Target for $9.99.

    10. A mystery Beanie Baby bundle two pack — to help rebuild their collection of Beanie Babies that were probably tossed out in the early '00s.

    A giant pile of Beanie Babies with a pink frame around the photo
    ShopAllieBear/ Etsy

    Get it from ShopAllieBear on Etsy for $8.

    11. A tube of MAC x Selena: Queen of Cumbia lipstick, which will leave anyone's lips looking como la flor, or more accurately, como la rosa roja.

    A deep red lipstick with a rose outline on the crayon portion
    MAC

    Promising review: "This is the BEST matte lipstick I have ever used! It stays on all day after one application and doesn't dry out my lips! Love the Selena line, MAC did her proud!!!" —Joelynn

    Get it from MAC for $20.

    12. A pair of Steve Madden Slinky Slides that was once a must-have for every '90s girl! Best of all: they're comfy!!!!

    Steve Madden

    Promising review: "I have been wanting shoes like these for forever! Such a '90s look! Buy these if you are considering them! Worth the price, good quality, very comfortable, but just size up!" —Ambar P.

    Get it from Steve Madden for $92.95 (available in sizes 5–11).

    13. A Spice Girls T-shirt that will spice up anybody's life!

    A white T-shirt with the five spice girls wearing black and white and Spice Girls written in black beneath them
    Amazon

    Promising review: "I told my other T-shirts MOVE OVER because this T-shirt just made me SPICE UP MY LIFE." —Jesus

    Get it from Amazon for $19 (available in sizes S–3XL and in black).

    14. A BlueRica Yin and Yang pendant necklace, which is the perfect gift to bring some balance to someone.

    A black and white yin and yang pendant on a rope necklace
    Amazon

    Promising review: "It's absolutely perfect! A little bigger than a quarter which is even better. It's not too big, not too small. I highly recommend it to anyone who's looking for a simple, sturdy, and inexpensive yin and yang necklace. Thank you! 😊" —Jess

    Get it from Amazon for $9.95.

    15. A Trent unisex sweater that'll make them want to binge-watch Daria while wearing it.

    A black sweater with Trent inside a heart on the center chest of it
    HelloSailorTees/ Etsy

    Promising review: "Yesssss!!! Instant nostalgia gratification! Extremely comfortable and amazing detail." —Brenda Raitto

    Get it from HelloSailorTees on Etsy for $27 (available in sizes men's small–4X and in three colors).

    16. A copy of Janet Jackson's seminal album, The Velvet Rope, on vinyl — which sounds as good and perfect today as it did 20 years ago.

    Cover of The Velvet Rope which features Janet looking down with her hair covering part of her face
    Amazon/ Virgin

    Promising review: "When I first heard this album years ago, I could not stop listening to it. Every song on it tells her story of depression and despair, as well as topics of love and self-worth. She had her highs and lows on this album. It's almost as if she was sharing her own personal struggles with this album and I loved it. I'm feeling ya Janet on this album. This is by far one of her deepest and best albums to date. You gotta own it." —KA

    Get it from Amazon for $16.98.

    17. A pack of Scream stickers, which are perfect for that '90s girl who likes scary movies (and stickers).

    Stickers featuring different characters from scenes in Scream
    RosalesArtGalleryLLC

    Promising review: "Dying over these! Love them!" —mamaunicorn17

    Get it from RosalesArtGalleryLLC on Etsy for $1.50.

    18. A Sailor Moon x ColourPop: Pretty Guardian Shadow Palette, which will leave anyone who you give this to saying, "In the name of the Moon, this is the perfect gift!"

    A pink eyeshadow palette open with the the box cover featuring Sailor Moon on it
    ColourPop

    Promising review: "So vibrant and fun. I absolutely love creating looks with this palette." —Brittany B.

    Get it from ColourPop for $22.

    19. A 6-Piece Gelly Roll pen set, which is the perfect stocking stuffer.

    A pack of Gelly Roll pens in a soft pastel package
    Amazon

    Promising review: "Cute gel pens! Great for art or note-taking!" —Pohakala van Veen

    Get if from Amazon for $11.31.

    20. A Polaroid Now i-Type Instant Camera, because let's be honest, no amount of filters can ever re-create the look of an analog camera — plus, there is just something magical about waiting for the photo to develop.

    A white Polaroid camera
    Nordstrom

    Get it from Nordstrom for $100 (also comes in black and the film is sold separately).

    21. A Caboodles On the Go Girl case, which is a '90s girl staple and still one of the best organizers ever made.

    A teal and lavender Caboodles
    Target

    Promising review: "Super nostalgic for me, I used this to store Barbie clothes and accessories when I was a child. I am using one now for sewing supplies, but also bought a second for my daughter to store her Barbie clothes in." —Runningmom18

    Get it from Target for $19.99.

    Reviews in this post have been edited for length and clarity.

    Find the perfect gift for any occasion, from white elephant gift exchanges to gifts for teachers, housewarming gifts to birthday gifts, and even the perfect gift basket if you’re truly stumped. Plus, check out the BuzzFeed gift guide for even more incredible gifting ideas.

    Amazon Prime Day is coming!

    Sign up for the BuzzFeed Shopping newsletter to get the best deals delivered right to your inbox.
    Newsletter signup form