back to top

13 Seriously Underrated ‘90s TV Crushes

Kelly Kapowski, Winnie Cooper, and Topanga weren't the only TV characters we fell hard for in the '90s.

Posted on

1. Karen Arnold, The Wonder Years

Played by: Olivia d'Abo

Why we love her: Sure, we all lusted after Winnie Cooper, but Kevin's free-spirited sister, Karen, was the real stunner on the show.

2. Myra Monkhouse, Family Matters


Played by: Michelle Thomas

Why we love her: Why was Steve Urkel so busy chasing after Laura when he could have had Myra, who was not only hot, but completely crazy in love with her "Stevie-kins"?

3. Rayanne Graff, My So-Called Life


Played by: A.J. Langer

Why we love her: Rayanne is the type of girl who burns hot, bright, and fast. Sure, she had a drinking problem — but overall she was a lovable mess.

Of course, Jordan Catalano learned firsthand why she earned a place on the sophomore list as “Most Slut Potential."

10. Clare Arnold, Beverly Hills, 90210


Played by: Kathleen Robertson

Why we love her: Clare was perfect: not too crazy and not too wholesome (remember when she handcuffed herself to Brandon’s bed?).

Every. Tasty. Video. EVER. The new Tasty app is here!