Browse links
US residents can opt out of "sales" of personal data.
We hope you love our recommendations! Some may have been sent as samples, but all were independently selected by our editors. Just FYI, BuzzFeed and its publishing partners may collect a share of sales and/or other compensation from the links on this page.
A perfect cat eye for half the price.
It also comes in different colors! Alas, the only colors currently in stock are black, brown, and grey, but still good info for later.
Also, I find that with inkier liners like Nyx, the liner will stamp onto the crease of my lid if I'm not careful. Stila dries pretty quickly, so I don't have a problem with smudging.
"Best liner I have ever used. Lasts all day. Beautiful dark pigment. Would keep eye makeup wipes handy for mistakes as this liner does set quickly and does not budge once dry." —jessicaty
"Been using this eyeliner for years, but when it ran out, I decided to try some other brands. BIG MISTAKE. I found numerous beauty bloggers who swore by a Maybelline option that can be found at drugstores. I don't know what is up with THEIR eyes, because the drugstore stuff didn't work well AT ALL on me. I went straight back to Stila! Sometimes you really do get what you pay for. This stuff has amazing stay power. It lasts all day no matter how much my eyes water and no matter how oily my hooded eyelids are. I've even slept in it when I was too lazy to take my makeup off before bed, and like 75% of it was still in place the next day." —twingomatic
Reviews have been edited for length and/or clarity.