1. Zachary Levi — First Date
2. Sebastian Stan — Picnic
3. Santino Fontana — Rodgers + Hammerstein's Cinderella
4. Billy Magnussen — Vanya and Sonia and Masha and Spike
5. Matt Doyle — Book of Mormon
6. Billy Porter — Kinky Boots
7. Zachary Quinto — The Glass Menagerie
8. John Arthur Greene — Matilda
9. Brian J. Smith — The Glass Menagerie
10. Daniel Craig — Betrayal
11. Orlando Bloom — Romeo and Juliet
12. Bryan Terrell Clark — Motown the Musical
13. Andy Mills — Rodger and Hammerstein's Cinderella
14. Sir Patrick Stewart and Sir Ian McKellan — Waiting for Godot, No Man's Land
15. Cory Michael Smith — Breakfast at Tiffany's
16. Ryan Steele — Matilda
17. Stark Sands — Kinky Boots
18. Ephraim Skyes — Motown: The Musical
19. Orion Giffiths — Pippin
20. Billy Crudup — Waiting for Godot, No Man's Land
21. Corey Cott — Newsies
22. Ethan Hawke — Macbeth
23. Tom Sturridge — Orphans
24. Arthur Darvill — Once
25. Matthew James Thomas — Pippin
26. Grasan Kingsberry — Motown: The Musical
27. Reeve Carney and Justin Matthew Sargent — Spider-Man Turn Off the Dark
28. Andrew Keenan-Bolger — Newsies
29. Ian Paget — Soul Doctor
30. Dennis Stowe — Annie
31. Ben Rappaport — Picnic
32. Maurice Jones — Romeo and Juliet
33. Jay Armstrong Johnson — Hands on a Hardbody
34. Bobby Cannavale — The Big Knife
