Skip To Content
  • Viral badge

This Little Detail In "Harry Potter" May Have Warned Us About Dumbledore's Death

Did Professor Trelawney get another prophecy right?

So this lady right here — Professor Trelawney, taught Divination and whatnot — made some prophecies and stuff.

Warner Bros.

She wasn't often right, but when she was, she was right BIG TIME.

A clever Harry Potter fan has come up with a theory that would make one more of Trelawney's prophecies correct.

It's more of a superstition than a prophecy, but you get it.

It points out a moment in Prisoner of Azkaban (the book, not the movie) where Trelawney refuses to sit with 12 others at dinner, because it's a bad omen.

Warner Bros.

"When 13 people dine together, the first to rise will die," she says. However, Ron may have had Scabbers/Peter Pettigrew in his pocket, meaning 13 people were already sitting, and since Dumbledore stood up to draw out a chair, that doomed him to die.

There's no mention in the text that Ron had Scabbers with him at that moment. However, he did have the rat in his pocket at other key times that year, so it's a definite possibility.

Warner Bros.

Which means that J.K. Rowling would have foreshadowed Dumbledore's death THREE BOOKS in advance.

This isn't the only time this happens in the books, either: In Order of the Phoenix, Sirius is the first to stand up from a table of 13.

Warner Bros.

It doesn't go so well for him later on.

After Alastor Moody's death, Remus is the first to stand up in the Weasleys' living room...where 13 people are sitting.

Warner Bros.

So this seems to be a recurring theme, which means the Dumbledore bit might have been intentional.

Very clever. Very clever indeed.

Warner Bos.

Want great book recommendations in your inbox every week? Sign up for the BuzzFeed Books newsletter!

Newsletter signup form